FA Cup Games 16/17/18/19 Feb,replays 27/28th

[cookster]

Modern technology using a Sinclair ZX80.

It did have colour so minimum Spectrum

 

[Neville Kneville]

Probably just offside but not clear and obvious.

Imo decisions that tight should not be reviewed.

But it's offside on the BT lines as Mata's knee is on the line & the defender's isn't but that is now being perverted by Scholes Savage etc as being wrong.

This is what we will get, forever. Marginal decisions will be shouted down if they go against rags or Liverpool etc.

Huddesfield should have had a clear pen earlier but this is the controversy instead.
.

 

[Blue Til Death]

Huddersfield totally bossing the midfield but toothless up front and defending like us at our worst.... Can't see em scoring, need jones on to stick one away for Huddersfield .....
Every time a rag falls over they get a free kick, shite refereeing

 

[pudge]

Offsides are black and white in the strictest sense, unlike the other decisions. Technically you're either right or wrong. Any marginal decision makes sense with offsides and VAR

But you can't review them with VAR then unless you change the criteria of what's reviewable.

If that was given you couldn't argue against it.

 

[mat]

Imo decisions that tight should not be reviewed.

But it's offside on the BT lines as Mata's knee is on the line & the defender's isn't but that is now being perverted by Scholes Savage etc as being wrong.

This is what we will get, forever. Marginal decisions will be shouted down if they go against rags or Liverpool etc.

Huddesfield should have had a clear pen earlier but this is the controversy instead.
.

Good point.

Smallthings handball has been buried.

 

[malg]

Fuck me, for so many on here to slag that decision it really must have been shite!

 

[moon]

Shows VAR won't always correct wrong decisions

 

[Danamy]

Offside is the correct decision

 

[Mancityus]

It was offside, just because it was close does not matter. Correct decision.

 

[MCFC1993]

Turns out with the straight lines he actually was offside.

How the fuck are BT studio arguing now they've seen the straight lines.