Who is the player you have been most gutted about leaving city?

[Jamoid]

For me it has to be Shaun Goater mans a legend where would we be now without his goals getting us out of the third division

 

[warpig]

is out of a short list of Colin Henry, uwe rosler, geo kinkladze and SWP. they all hurt pretty much the same .

 

[gordondaviesmoustache]

Never understood the obsession with Ian Bishop, who must have had the worst win percentage of any popular City player.

I reckon Mark Lillis would give him a run for his money, especially if you take Bishop's second stint into account.

 

[pete1970]

Barnes and owen
Thought Joe Royle leaving was bad too

 

[gordondaviesmoustache]

For me it has to be Shaun Goater mans a legend where would we be now without his goals getting us out of the third division

In the third division?

 

[Stevieatlasblue]

Gary Owen and Peter Barnes

I have to agree..we had it twice in one go. Two brilliant players...why?????????

 

[AkanjisAfro]

Elano

 

[urban genie]

Andy Hill, Hendry, TC, Bobby Brightwell,

 

[Cellarite]

Went with SWP and Bishop on page 1. Since then, David White, Michael Hughes, Tony Coton and NDJ have all been good calls but SWP was the worst for me. I was on holiday in Norfolk when he went and it put me in a bad mood for a few days.

 

[AliBobbyJ]

Bobby Johnstone. One of a very few who deserve to be called genius.

 

[worsleyweb]

Lee,Barnes,Owen, Flitcroft,SWP,Dunne and Barry.
Roger Palmer scored a couple in my first game at Maine Road.So I was gutted when he left.

As a side noted I invaded the pitch at boundary park at Rogers testimonial game and have never felt a surface like it. It was the worst plastic pitch in living memory - I went arse over tit and got a huge Astro turf burn all along my arm. I see it every day and every time I look at it, I think of roger. Has kind of soured my memory of him.