Wigan (a) pre-match thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
Stones and Laporte must start. They are both more important to our future successes than Kompany and therefore need the minutes more than him. Stones needs to re-find his early season form and Laporte needs games to adjust to the team. To me it seems the obvious selection.
 
If the bolded is true, isn't that a strong reason to play him against Wigan?

Since like you said, he won't be starting any of the bigger games.

Personally, I think he is no more risky than a rusty Kompany and a recently error prone Stones. And he is a better Left sided Center back. So I see no legitimate reason why he shouldn't start.

Well actually, there is one reason ( If Pep concludes he is the best LCB on the squad and has decided to predominantly save him for the big games). In that case, he is likely to start the very games you think he won't start :)

But if I'm reading Pep right ( which I often don't) this will be a Stones/ Laporte start because they both need game time, but more importantly that means he gets to save Kompany to play in the finals and lift the cup If we win.

I sense Pep will play Kompany in the Cup finals (all of them if we make it to each final). The sentiment of the Captain lifting the cup is important to him.

And he has hinted at this before. So I'm almost certain Kompany plays against Arsenal. Not so certain he does here. And if he does, I expect it will be with Laporte.

Actually if I’m right it wouldn’t make sense to start Laporte because Stones needs game time and Kompany is rusty.

At least we agree on Kompany starting the cup finals :)

Would make sense to start Kompany tonight as he is rusty and needs rediscover top form before the final, there is a long rest between games so it is not necessary to rest him tonight.

We’ll see soon who starts.

For the record I think we’ll see the following provided everyone is fit:

Wigan- Kompany-Stones
Cup final- Otamendi- Kompany
Arsenal away- Otamendi- Stones
Chelsea home-Otamendi-Kompany

What’s your prediction of CB pairings for these matches?? Then we can compare ;)
 
If the bolded is true, isn't that a strong reason to play him against Wigan?

Since like you said, he won't be starting any of the bigger games.

Personally, I think he is no more risky than a rusty Kompany and a recently error prone Stones. And he is a better Left sided Center back. So I see no legitimate reason why he shouldn't start.

Well actually, there is one reason ( If Pep concludes he is the best LCB on the squad and has decided to predominantly save him for the big games). In that case, he is likely to start the very games you think he won't start :)

But if I'm reading Pep right ( which I often don't) this will be a Stones/ Laporte start because they both need game time, but more importantly that means he gets to save Kompany to play in the finals and lift the cup If we win.

I sense Pep will play Kompany in the Cup finals (all of them if we make it to each final). The sentiment of the Captain lifting the cup is important to him.


And he has hinted at this before. So I'm almost certain Kompany plays against Arsenal. Not so certain he does here. And if he does, I expect it will be with Laporte.
Sounding close to a dipper there mate. No doubt Vincent might play the final but if he does it's because Pep feels he is a better fit against Arsenal than the other 2 CBs he displaces. Pep is as unsentimental as it gets.
 
I'd much prefer to go with Stones and Laporte if Otamendi isn't going to play. They are more suited to the way we play than Kompany I think.

Having said that, perhaps Guardiola will hold one of them back to play with Otamendi in the final next weekend and give Kompany a run out this evening.
Me too.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top
  AdBlock Detected
Bluemoon relies on advertising to pay our hosting fees. Please support the site by disabling your ad blocking software to help keep the forum sustainable. Thanks.