Clown car defending

Exeter Blue I am here

Well-Known Member
Joined
30 Jan 2011
Messages
9,318
Location
Take a wild guess.......
There's admittedly probably a tendency for it not to register when opposition defenders fuck up, but is there any other team, not just in the Premier League but in Europe, whose back 4 attempts to commit ritual suicide with such astonishing regularity as ours?
I'm not talking about being exposed by a lack of midfield cover or making an error under pressure or repeat failures of an offside trap, but absolute complacent fucktard pieces of defending (particularly relating to fannying around instead of clearing the ball) that leave you purple faced in rage and bewilderment, and unable to comprehend that these are some of the highest paid professional footballers in the world we're talking about.
Whatever, sometimes we've paid the ultimate price and other times we've gotten away with it, but I am at a loss to explain the cause. Is it coaching, is it lack of leadership, is it arrogance, is it a lackadaisical approach to defending in general, are they just fucking stupid?
Off the top of my head then I came up with this lot (mostly from recent weeks), and I appreciate that there were probably a load more at the start of the season I've forgotten about.......

Norwich (h) - Hart drops the ball on his own goal line under no pressure from anyone and Jerome taps in to an empty net.
Liverpool (h) - 1. Mangala gets his feet in a tangle and backheels the ball past Joe Hart for an own goal.
2. Mangala and Dimichelis get in each other's way, Firmino takes advantage and tees up Coutinho for a goal.
Juventus (a) - Otamendi falls down under minimal contact hoping for a cheap free kick and Mandzukic scores.
Everton (a) - 1. Otamendi as last man has a 5 yard start over Barkley, but dithers, allows himself to get knocked off the ball and Hart has to make a last ditch save.
2. In a packed penalty area, Mangala collects the ball on the edge of the 6 yard and instead of clearing his lines, attempts an absolute hospital pass to a City player on the edge of the box, which pass is promptly intercepted and results in a shot at goal.
West Ham (a) - A hopeful West Ham throw travels fully 40 yards into our 6 yard box with only 1 West Ham player even in our half, Otamendi has all day to deal with it, but falls asleep and allows that one player to run round behind him and poke it past Hart.
Everton (h) - Otamendi races out of position, dives in needlessly on Barkley, gets nowhere near the ball and the Everton player runs on to score.
Sunderland (a) - under no pressure from anyone Dimichelis plays a needless and suicidal short pass on the edge of our box straight to a Sunderland player, who has a free run on goal that Hart manages to block.
Rags (h) - Dimichelis plays a woefully underhit back pass whilst looking in the opposite direction, which sees Joe Hart depart on a stretcher.
PSG (a) - Hart plays an utterly pointless goal kick to Fernando, who has his back to the opposition and doesn't realise Ibrahimovic is coming up behind, and the City midfielder duly turns straight into him and the ball cannons into the empty net.
Newcastle (a) - 1. under no pressure Kompany tries a needless dribble out of defence, only to get caught in possession by Sissoko, who runs clean through on goal only for Hart to save the day.
2. In the 90th minute, Kolarov has all day to clear the ball, but dithers and allows Wijnaldum to race through on Hart, who makes another point blank save.
Southampton (a) - 1. Otamendi falls asleep and allows a player 3 yards behind him to beat him to the ball and toe end it past Hart.
2. Kolarov has all day to clear, but dithers and then whacks the ball straight into the back of a Southampton player. The ball duly loops back over Kolarov's head and sets Long free.
3. Zabaleta, Otamendi and Kolarov all have the opportunity under pressure by the deadball line, to whack the ball out for throw ins. All opt to try and dribble or shield the ball out of play, all get robbed of possession with Southampton players then running the ball back into our near empty penalty area.
 
Last edited:
Imagine the meltdown on here if we'd signed Morgan and Huth but to use the old cliche they do what it says on the tin, they defend, a concept that seems alien to most of our defenders and probably to the manager and coaching staff too. We seem over-reliant on midfield protection and are unable to cope when that breaks down.
 
excellent post John. I can't wait to start next season. I bet mancini is watching from afar and thinking wtf.

Elegant footballer though he may well be, I'm not overly enthused by the news that our primary defensive transfer target is John Stones, a player whose error rate (probably brought about by too much faith in his own ability) is alarmingly high. Regardless though, we can't possibly defend worse next season can we?!
 
I was watching Otamendi in particular last week, and he is the one 'marshalling' - he checks where his defenders are, he'll shout for the line to move up etc etc.

Despite this, he is the one who routinely leaves his line and goes and commits to a flying tackle on the half way line.

The whole backline is just pretty brainless without Vinny.
 
Imagine the meltdown on here if we'd signed Morgan and Huth but to use the old cliche they do what it says on the tin, they defend, a concept that seems alien to most of our defenders and probably to the manager and coaching staff too. We seem over-reliant on midfield protection and are unable to cope when that breaks down.

I've said for a long time that if we are going to sign central defenders on a punt we should go for a cheap punt.
 
Is Pellers any better at defensive coaching than Martinez? That's the question.
 
Everytime mangala receives the ball I get the feeling in my stomach I'm watching my 2 year old child come down the stairs unattended for the first time. I can't make my mind up if mangala is a giraffe with roller skates on or a giraffe on ice with roller skates on. Very nervous.
 
Everytime mangala receives the ball I get the feeling in my stomach I'm watching my 2 year old child come down the stairs unattended for the first time. I can't make my mind up if mangala is a giraffe with roller skates on or a giraffe on ice with roller skates on. Very nervous.
Ha ha quality. I'd go for a giraffe with roller skates on ice but blindfolded too!
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top
  AdBlock Detected
Bluemoon relies on advertising to pay our hosting fees. Please support the site by disabling your ad blocking software to help keep the forum sustainable. Thanks.