Paul Ince: Paul Robinson - a joke and a liability Mark Hughes: Joe Hart - Easily the best young keeper in the country Paul Ince: Ooijer, Samba, Nelson, Warnock, the Georgian, Danny Simpson Mark Hughes: Micah Richards, Dunne, Onouha, Zabaletta, Garrido, Tal Ben Haim (Â£5m) Paul Ince: Tugay (102 years old), Fat Dunn, injured Stephen Reid, Pederson, Keith Andrews, Treacy Mark Hughes: Kompany, Hamman, injured Johnson, injured Petrov, Elano, Ireland, SWP, Gelson Paul Ince: Santa Cruz (who has virtully given up playing until Jan), Roberts, Fowler, Derbyshire, McCarthy Mark Hughes: Robinho (you know, one of the best player in the world, 32m etc), Benjani, Vassell, Sturridge (besxt young striker in the country), Evans (great prospect). Paul Ince (spent circa Â£10m maybe - at a guess) Mark Hughes (spent circa Â£50m) Paul Ince: No young players of much note apart from Bentley. Best players are old and a year slower. Mark Hughes: Several top class young prospects who should be a year older and better compared to last year. Paul Ince: took over a team that has lost probably its two best players (freidal and bentley) and not got the money to replace them. Mark Hughes: took over team that has only lost one player (Charlie) and replaced him with an Argie international. On top of this has brought in over Â£50m of extra talent Paul Ince: backwater club, expected to struggle, empty ground. Mark Hughes: club expected to do well on all fronts, be a very serious challenger for Uefa and possibly 4th Champ league place and to capitalise on an excellent young squad. Paul Ince: Unfailing public support from players Mrk Hughes: Some public support from players, some maoning from Elano, constant rumours of unrest Paul Ince: 12 points Mark Hughes: 18 points Paul Ince: League Cup Qtr finals - out to best team in the country Mark Hughes: Out to Brighton at the first hurdle Paul Ince: No European football Mark Hughes: two good Euopean performances (Twente and Schalke). through to last 32. So, which one of these is judged to be in an untenable position at this stage in the season?