aguero93:20
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 21 Oct 2013
- Messages
- 90,262
- Location
- Hunting Cats.
- Team supported
- Some gobshites in day-glo green and black.
No. But referees will just bottle showing yellows for dives if it's being dealt with retrospectively.
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
M
M
mat
Guest
Will it fuck.well there goes Ashley Young's career.
Him, shitguard and Nappy Rash will be exempt whilst Raz,Jesus,Sterling will take it turns being banned for fuck all.
also just heard that the yellow card by the ref in the game save anymore punishment and the panel can not look at it also the ref match report is key if he says he seen it and did not think it was a dive again the panel can not use the video. this is going to be the key to united players getting away with it and SKY and BT will make a case for anything other than for united players. the video angels slow motion they will use will also and again sky and bt hold all the cards here
its going to be use for all the wrong thing and players at a club that play in red can still do what they like and dare any ref to stand up them
its going to be use for all the wrong thing and players at a club that play in red can still do what they like and dare any ref to stand up them
B
B
blueinsa
Guest
Just watched fat Sam's reaction to it all and he has it spot on imo.
sdm
Well-Known Member
The panel selection will tell you everything you need to know about this from day one.
Lets say ex player is terry butcher and ex manager is graeme souness (or other way round) . I couldnt see those two falling for any bullshit dives or pissing about like players pretending they have trodden on a landmine or have taken a right hook from anthony joshua.
On the otherhand if they select someone who has just retired and could hide behind a pool cue and has been throwing himself to ground under managers orders. Then we might aswell not bother because nothing will change.
Lets say ex player is terry butcher and ex manager is graeme souness (or other way round) . I couldnt see those two falling for any bullshit dives or pissing about like players pretending they have trodden on a landmine or have taken a right hook from anthony joshua.
On the otherhand if they select someone who has just retired and could hide behind a pool cue and has been throwing himself to ground under managers orders. Then we might aswell not bother because nothing will change.
Worried about this and even more so about the idea of sin bins. Open to abuse and do you honestly think they will ban Rooney, Hazard etc for diving. Yet we should have a penalty, its not given despite being nailed on, and we will pick up a ban for diving also
Open to so much abuse. Media witch hunts with Sky, BT and MotD setting the agenda is almost a certainty.
Plus, although these bans are a detriment to the team that suffers them, the team that was cheated doesn't necessarily gain anything and in fact might be at a disadvantage because the banned player might miss a game against the cheated team's rivals. Full of holes and I don't trust it will work to anything but our disadvantage.
Plus, although these bans are a detriment to the team that suffers them, the team that was cheated doesn't necessarily gain anything and in fact might be at a disadvantage because the banned player might miss a game against the cheated team's rivals. Full of holes and I don't trust it will work to anything but our disadvantage.
BlueHammer85
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 13 Oct 2010
- Messages
- 33,733
I get the mistrust. But surely it's a step in the right direction - if you get a 3 match ban for diving why would you as a player take that risk ? It's a very good punishment. A yellow or a 10 min sin bin as Sam suggested isn't. Plus the fact some decisions take time to come to a conclusion, if a video ref only has one or two angles this will delay the game - we've seen how pundits have argued whether it was a dive or not, yes like anything in sport there will be mistakes and uproar - but a retrospective ban is something I've called for a long time.