Lúcio

[jdawson-mcfc]

We already have the best CB in the world in Kompany. Good in the air, great tackler/decision maker and reads the game tremendously. He's also a great ball player and if you look back has been the starting point for a lot of our attacks/goals this year and last.

Lucio is top class no doubt but would we really want to spend money on something were going to have to replace again in 2-3 years.

My choice would be either Pique or Phil Jones (cough ahem). The latter of which although a rag knows the prem and has easily proven himself.

 

[blink922]

We already have the best CB in the world in Kompany. Good in the air, great tackler/decision maker and reads the game tremendously. He's also a great ball player and if you look back has been the starting point for a lot of our attacks/goals this year and last.

Lucio is top class no doubt but would we really want to spend money on something were going to have to replace again in 2-3 years.

My choice would be either Pique or Phil Jones (cough ahem). The latter of which although a rag knows the prem and has easily proven himself.

With a couple mediocre displays, a ton of poor performances and what, 3 own goals?

Guess that's all it takes to prove yourself these days.

 

[The_Mo]

would'nt mind him tbh.

 

[bondsman]

Kompany and vidic best in world for me and what a pair they would be.

 

[MCC]

Not for me. 10 years ago maybe but he is too old now.

 

[vonksbignose]

We already have the best CB in the world in Kompany. Good in the air, great tackler/decision maker and reads the game tremendously. He's also a great ball player and if you look back has been the starting point for a lot of our attacks/goals this year and last.

Lucio is top class no doubt but would we really want to spend money on something were going to have to replace again in 2-3 years.

My choice would be either Pique or Phil Jones (cough ahem). The latter of which although a rag knows the prem and has easily proven himself.

Phil fuckin Jones?

I sincerely hope I'm being Clarkied here!

If not, one word for you mate - RAG!!!

 

[SS117]

Best defender in the world, I'm going for Pique.

 

[Pride_In_Battle]

Best defender in the world, I'm going for Pique.

I'd look good in defence for Barca, he's good, but not world class, he just never has anything to do other than collect long balls and pass it to Xavi! If he has a striker running at him he's terrible, just look at Rooney's goal against him in the CL final!

 

[Amadeus20]

Too early to say Kompany.

I dont know how he would do against Messi.

Rooney usually rapes him when we play United.

 

[Unknown_Genius]

Too early to say Kompany.

I dont know how he would do against Messi.

Rooney usually rapes him when we play United.

Whaaaaaat.....