Swings and Roundabouts -Decisions for and Against

[Ricster]

Other fans have said it today that for every decision against your team, you get them back over the course of the season. Well I think it's now time to keep a log and see if this is true.

Clear cut decisions, no dodgy or blue tinted decisions, just clear cut.

If you want to post the incidents, I will do my best to keep this first page up to date whenever I'm online.

Scale of decision - 1 low 5 high.


10/08, West Brom (A) W 0-3 -
Incidents For

Incidents Against

16/08, Chelsea (H) W 3-0
Incidents For

Incidents Against

23/08, Everton (A) W 2-0
Incidents For

Incidents Against

29/08, Watford (H) W 2-0
Incidents For

Incidents Against

12/09, Crystal Palace (A) W 1-0
Incidents For

Incidents Against
3.Knee high challenge from Scott Dann resulting in Aguero injury. Received Yellow.
4. Nasri penalty claim

15/09, Juventus (H) L 2-1
Incidents For

Incidents Against

19/09, West Ham (H) L 2-1
Incidents For

Incidents Against
2. Offside resulting in goal for West Ham
5. Kolarov clearing the ball. Corner given when ball hadn't crosses line.
5. Sanga attacking by line. Ball incorrectly given out.

26/09, Spurs (A) L 2-1
Incidents for
2. De Bruyne offside for City's goal, Demichelis 2nd yellow

Incidents against
5. Kyle Walker offside.
5. Harry Kane offside.
1. Demichelis 1st yellow.

30/09, BMG (A) W 2-1
Incidents for
5. Foul on Stindl by Fernandinho. Penalty. Not given.

Incidents against
5. Raffael fouled by Otamendi. Player was already going down. Dive. No penalty.
5. Demichelis goal. Not allowed.

17/10, Bournmouth (H) W 5-1
Incidents for
5. Foul by Otamendi in the area. Penalty not given.

Incidents against
5. Kelechi scores. Wrongly chalked off for offside

25/10, United (A) D 0-0
Incidents For
4. Foul by Sterling in the area. Penalty not given.

Incidents against
2. Rojo stamp on Navas. No action.

31/10, Norwich (H) W 2-1

03/11, Sevilla (A) W 3-1
Incidents for,
2. Foul by Sagna, penalty not given.

Incidents against,
4. Foul on Fernandinho, penalty not given

 

[Ricster]

Add the incidents missing below and I will add them

 

[mrtwiceaseason]

Add the incidents missing below and I will add them

Martin should have been sent off v spurs 2 yellows

 

[FantasyIreland]

Lamela should have received a red for challenge on Kolarov.

 

[jimharri]

Martin should have been sent off v spurs 2 yellows

Yes. But if the laughable officiating for the first decision hadn't happened, there'd have been no first yellow card; he'd have had nothing to argue with the ref about. One of the decisions that went against us had an influence on one that went for us. He still shoudn't have done it though; refs hardly ever change their minds, and never when there's been play in the intervening period.

 

[Don Karleone]

BENT!!

 

[Millwallawayveteran1988]

We certainly got one for us in the CL, not that it helped.

Against v palace

Penalty against Nasri not given.

 

[yeseye]

BENT!!

He's level!

 

[Gundogan's Moustache]

BENT!!

Decisions like this are inexcusable , what's the linesman going to say when asked about it?

 

[Pubteam Lomas]

Those who say they even themselves out are talking bollox.
Getting the benefit of the doubt when you're 4 up doesn't compare with a horror decision like yesterday, on the stroke of half time.
To give it some balance. Costa should have gone against Arsenal, but Gabriel sees red instead.
Panel over turn decision and give Costa retrospective 3 match ban. Doesn't help Arsenal. Had Dean done his job correctly Arsenal would've been playing against 10.