Swings and Roundabouts -Decisions for and Against

[karrenstein]

Fuck, this is blatant cheating.

- The penalty Hart saved was from a poor Thespian dive.
- The alleged Fernandinho penalty was another dive correctly spotted; though Turpin was gutted to show the yellow.
- The other alleged Fernandinho penalty was not, as the ball bounced to his elbow and his arm was folded over his chest.
- Their goal was built with an offside player to the right.
- City's first goal was Demichelis', cheated by the lino and the other **** next to the goal post.
- El Kun was kicked in the shin inside the box, stonewall penalty; then again the Platini minion was gutted to award it.

No swings and roundabouts there, just daylight robbery.

This is ridiculous. But I am sure if many of you analyse like this we will have a great time in the sheikh stadium.

1. Penalty: I can't tell. I have seen several perspectives. Possibly a dive.

2. alleged dive (Stindl): definitly this was no dive and penalty would have been the right decision.

3. 1:0: just a goal, no offside

4: Penalty (allegedly hand after shot from Xhaka): it's a maybe penalty. I tend to say no penalty

5. Penalty (1:2): absolutly correct

 

[almir]

Their goal look offside or very close to it from any pic shown with that angle. But it's very close call so it's hard for refs to judge

 

[cookster]

Anyone mention the rub of green we got today? 1 nil to the Geordies and a good goal chalked off for offside. 2 nil and it might have been a different outcome.

We've had a few go our way this season so can't complain after a couple of bad decisions at Spurs.

 

[mcfcfc]

Anyone mention the rub of green we got today? 1 nil to the Geordies and a good goal chalked off for offside. 2 nil and it might have been a different outcome.

We've had a few go our way this season so can't complain after a couple of bad decisions at Spurs.

spurs game wasn't just a couple of bad decisions ...was a daylight robbery

 

[Ricster]

Anyone mention the rub of green we got today? 1 nil to the Geordies and a good goal chalked off for offside. 2 nil and it might have been a different outcome.

We've had a few go our way this season so can't complain after a couple of bad decisions at Spurs.

it was their RB that was given off, not the player in the middle

 

[grim up north]

Mitrovic was offside for the Hart save also

 

[es1]

it was their RB that was given off, not the player in the middle

he wasnt off though

 

[Rolee]

Anyone mention the rub of green we got today? 1 nil to the Geordies and a good goal chalked off for offside. 2 nil and it might have been a different outcome.

We've had a few go our way this season so can't complain after a couple of bad decisions at Spurs.

We got away with that one but it was a tight decision so we can still complain as the decisions at WHL were farcical

Mangala is just about playing their RB on

 

[JGL07]

Anyone mention the rub of green we got today? 1 nil to the Geordies and a good goal chalked off for offside. 2 nil and it might have been a different outcome.

We've had a few go our way this season so can't complain after a couple of bad decisions at Spurs.

You are missing the point that the flag went up and the whistle sounded, rightly or wrongly. The defence stopped playing. There is no guarantee that Newcastle would have got the ball in the net had the offside decision not been given.

 

[cookster]

You are missing the point that the flag went up and the whistle sounded, rightly or wrongly. The defence stopped playing. There is no guarantee that Newcastle would have got the ball in the net had the offside decision not been given.

Not missing the point at all, some go our way some don't.
Sick of hearing our fans moaning like fucking Mourinho about refs and decisions. We get decisions our way as well but those are conveniently overlooked.