Time for fouling culprits to get their comeuppance

Steelymark

New Member
Joined
9 Dec 2012
Messages
2
How about the person who has fouled and injured a player being banned for the same time until that player is back in action be it 2 weeks , 3 months or year if necessary .
 
How about the person who has fouled and injured a player being banned for the same time until that player is back in action be it 2 weeks , 3 months or year if necessary .
Retrospective review of potential red-card fouls endangering the health of players needs to be part of the P/L review process - whether or not, the referee, during the game, awarded a penalty/yellow card or not.

Currently, if a player receives a yellow, it's a get-out-of-jail-free card. Which is totally wrong - referees are hesitant to produce red cards unless absolutely necessary and clear cut - if a potential red-card foul is seen, frequently it happens so quickly that the full extent of the foul isn't picked up. VAR (best - as sending off happens immediately if warranted) or retrospective review (far worse as the offending team may be punished but not in the game at hand) needs to severely punish fouls that endanger a player's career.
 
agree that the rules preventing 're refereeing' of yellow card tackles needs to be looked at. it needs to be as simple as any act of serious foul play / violent conduct can be reviewed post match and upgraded to a red card if deemed appropriate, no matter what the ref has given.

dont agree with players being banned while the person they injured is out. think back to how james mccarthy broke his leg last month in a totally unintentional clash with solamon rondon, seems unfair to ban him for a year for that.
 
They just need to scrap the notion your offence can't be looked at if you get a yellow. It's a nonsense.

Same length ban as a player is injured wouldn't work. Say Kane fouled Danilo and got a red. And Danilo was out for around 3 weeks. But we knew in the 4th week Spuds were playing a game we didn't want them to win, we could potentially say, no, Danilo is still injured, so Kane can't play in that game. It would be open to all sorts of corruption..
 
Retrospective review of potential red-card fouls endangering the health of players needs to be part of the P/L review process - whether or not, the referee, during the game, awarded a penalty/yellow card or not.

Currently, if a player receives a yellow, it's a get-out-of-jail-free card. Which is totally wrong - referees are hesitant to produce red cards unless absolutely necessary and clear cut - if a potential red-card foul is seen, frequently it happens so quickly that the full extent of the foul isn't picked up. VAR (best - as sending off happens immediately if warranted) or retrospective review (far worse as the offending team may be punished but not in the game at hand) needs to severely punish fouls that endanger a player's career.


Agree with this.
 
agree that the rules preventing 're refereeing' of yellow card tackles needs to be looked at. it needs to be as simple as any act of serious foul play / violent conduct can be reviewed post match and upgraded to a red card if deemed appropriate, no matter what the ref has given.

dont agree with players being banned while the person they injured is out. think back to how james mccarthy broke his leg last month in a totally unintentional clash with solamon rondon, seems unfair to ban him for a year for that.

If the refs sanction the tackle with a red or yellow then it should apply. If, in those immortal words of Crappenberg as Andersen wrapped his legs round Micah and felled him inside the Rag area, it was a 'coming together,' and seen as part of the rough and tumble contact of the sport then it shouldn't apply. The only thing being that those who play in blue would be sanctioned post match whilst those in scarlet, carmine, puce and all shades at the red end of the spectrum would be exonerated!
 
How about an orange card, meaning the player stays on the pitch but the ref thinks maybe it needs looking at in retrospect.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top
  AdBlock Detected
Bluemoon relies on advertising to pay our hosting fees. Please support the site by disabling your ad blocking software to help keep the forum sustainable. Thanks.