ID list of every single Manchester band in order of greatness.

[calum down]

Now if anyone was to mention Slaughter & the Dogs, they'd get my vote.

i was just about to say the same.

 

[calum down]

it's a load of bollox.
"every single manchester band" my arse.

 

[Barcon]

The top 2 are bang on. As is your choice of best band ever.

Buzzcocks are about right, Take That should be higher, really they should.

I haven't seen the list but I assume Buzzcocks are no.1 and Joy Division no.2

 

[manctheknife]

The drones should be in there, as well as ed banger and the nosebleeds.........The band the smiths could have been...

 

[Manchester1894]

Doves beaten in that list by the fecking Ting Tings and Blossoms??

 

[Oh YeahOh Yeah]

Puressence not mentioned. Joke list. They should be in the top 5 at least.

 

[canyerdogputoutafire]

This band also missed on the role of honour .

 

[BimboBob]

I'm sure godley and creme are from prestwich and the other two out of 10cc are from droylsden and Denton.
And for the record I'm going seeing depeche mode at the arena Friday.
Cheers.

Sunday in Brum for me.

 

[BimboBob]

I haven't seen the list but I assume Buzzcocks are no.1 and Joy Division no.2

Reported.



****.

 

[Nightmare Walking]

completely agree.


live in 1977
(sadly ruined by mick fucknell's face in the crowd at 3:59)

and not in a million years were new order better than joy division.


quite simply, how can anyone who knows anything about music not include them?

Joy Division may have been better lyrically than New Order, but musically New Order were head and shoulders above Joy Division.