Alexis Sanchez

Status
Not open for further replies.
Franknorgrovesnephew said:
I do think we need him due to Sergio or Jesus not really ripping it up at the moment,sterling being top scorer shows this.so his versatility is much needed in these last few months of the season
Click to expand...

That’s cos they are rotated. They are not top scorers because they switch unlike Jesus Kane who plays every game. Imagine what would happen if they were rotated in a 3. I also don’t think sterling or Sané are doing bad supported by Bernardo.

When you are on a winning streak like ours I don’t understand the risk of upsetting the chemistry .he is a great player but our team spirit seems great why risk that.
 
kevin horlocks wand said:
That’s cos they are rotated. They are not top scorers because they switch unlike Jesus Kane who plays every game. Imagine what would happen if they were rotated in a 3. I also don’t think sterling or Sané are doing bad supported by Bernardo.

When you are on a winning streak like ours I don’t understand the risk of upsetting the chemistry .he is a great player but our team spirit seems great why risk that.
Click to expand...
 
kevin horlocks wand said:
That’s cos they are rotated. They are not top scorers because they switch unlike Jesus Kane who plays every game. Imagine what would happen if they were rotated in a 3. I also don’t think sterling or Sané are doing bad supported by Bernardo.

When you are on a winning streak like ours I don’t understand the risk of upsetting the chemistry .he is a great player but our team spirit seems great why risk that.
Click to expand...

Is it not better to be proactive rather than reactive?
The performances are good now, but that does not serve as a guarantee for the remainder of the season. If we started dropping points in the league, got knocked out of the UCL and one or both of the domestic cups due to an inability to deal with fixture congestion then delaying Sanchez until the summer will look like really poor management. We have the chance to reinforce the squad with a genuine world-class player for what is peanuts in today's market. To pass that up because things are going well in this moment would be insane.
 
Lets sign him and mario back. Everyone will be so fucked off that mario is back causing trouble that sanchez will be seen as a great guy and no harmony issues :)
 
So because they are rotated it prevents them from scoring goals,it's nothing to do with rotation it's due to them not putting away the chances they are being given,look at the last game Sergio missed plenty of chances and what if one or both get injured in next few months,yes he's needed in my eye's not everybody else's but there your views
 
FantasyIreland said:
Given we only have two strikers,and we are entering the latter stages of top competitions,in a very congested season......then leaving his signing until the summer is anything but a 'no brainer'.

The player would bring extra energy and dimension to a team that needs to keep up this incredible momentum.

Get him signed asap,more silverware will follow.
Click to expand...
ITK?
 
 
Neville Kneville said:
I didn't want Sanchez because I wanted Sane & Sterling to develop, which they have, but imo, all the attackers are suffering from the incredible amount of physical & mental effort they have put into this run. In actual fact, wheras he might have been a spare part for most of the season, we could have done with Sanchez this week, when all are a little bit jaded.

A new spark is not essential, but it could be pretty fucking good.

It may cause a bit of resentment from Sergio in particular, if he has to miss out more, but with a Premier League title dangling like a ripe peach, plus a possible crack at the Champions League, & two cups, would you really want to sulk & risk missing out on it all, or would you rather fight for your place & do your whinging in May, once it's all in the bag ?

Imo, the player most worried should be Bernardo Silva, anyhow. He is very much a 'stand in' for Sane, Sterling etc right now wheras Sanchez would be a genuine alternative, not a 'stand in'. Sanchez could eclipse him completely if he hit the top form immediately.

Also, if you were looking for a player to adapt, drop back & do the kind of new baldy toughnut playmaker job David Silva now does, Sanchez is a much tougher unit, than Bernardo & has been trained already by Pep, so imo there could be another string to this bow IF it happens.

No lose either way now for me. We are great with or without him.
Click to expand...
I personally think Bernardo would welcome Sanchez, as you say he's currently being used to fill in for Sterling and Sane but with Sanchez's arrival he'd be utilised as rotation with Spanish Dave and KDB where I think his game is best suited. Those that think he's too lightweight and slow for this position please don't write him off just yet. Spanish Dave is obviously irreplaceable but cast your minds back when he first arrived in the Premier League everyone was saying the same about him and given time he transformed into the player he is now.
 
The league is ours already, therefore, I don't think we need to splash 50 mil on a player who will be available for free in the summer. Mendy is out until April/May which means we won't play 3-5-2 until Mendy is fit again. As we are playing 4-3-3 now, there is no urgency in spending 50 mil because this system requires only one recognized striker. Sanchez is world class and would improve us but it would be wise to save those 50mil and spend them to buy a world class defender.
 
Dipsis_LTU_MC said:
The league is ours already, therefore, I don't think we need to splash 50 mil on a player who will be available for free in the summer. Mendy is out until April/May which means we won't play 3-5-2 until Mendy is fit again. As we are playing 4-3-3 now, there is no urgency in spending 50 mil because this system requires only one recognized striker. Sanchez is world class and would improve us but it would be wise to save those 50mil and spend them to buy a world class defender.
Click to expand...
will be nothing like 50m
 
manygoose said:
Can't find anything about same league transfer apart from football manager forum posts
Click to expand...

Gone quiet on that one.

When you actually look for details in this kind of thing, it is notoriously sketchy. If you look up loan regulations & whether it counts toward a players eligibility as 'home grown' for example it's really difficult.

There is a section in the FA rules which might cover this pre contract business, which is worded in such a way that it suggests that a club has the right to 'offer' a player over 24 a new contract, when the present one runs out & then, on receipt of that offer, the player has 28 days to accept, if the offer is rejected, 'the player is immediately free to negotiate with another club'.

So it could perhaps be, that is the FA rule here, wheras the rule for other counties follows Bosman.

Hence, if you want to play here, you have to abide by the FA rule.

That's the best I can come up with.
 
Dipsis_LTU_MC said:
The league is ours already, therefore, I don't think we need to splash 50 mil on a player who will be available for free in the summer. Mendy is out until April/May which means we won't play 3-5-2 until Mendy is fit again. As we are playing 4-3-3 now, there is no urgency in spending 50 mil because this system requires only one recognized striker. Sanchez is world class and would improve us but it would be wise to save those 50mil and spend them to buy a world class defender.
Click to expand...
Repeating 50m three times doesn't make it any more accurate.
 
I just can’t see Wenger doing a deal in January. I think if we could do a deal for 25-30 million most clubs would bite our hand off but this is Arsenal and Wenger. He thinks he will gain the respect of the fans by stringing us along and hoping that either PSG make an offer or he can convince Sanchez to stay. He’s already shown that he has a lack of respect for City - any decision to sell in January would be as a result of pressure from the Arsenal board.
 
Danamy said:
I personally think Bernardo would welcome Sanchez, as you say he's currently being used to fill in for Sterling and Sane but with Sanchez's arrival he'd be utilised as rotation with Spanish Dave and KDB where I think his game is best suited. Those that think he's too lightweight and slow for this position please don't write him off just yet. Spanish Dave is obviously irreplaceable but cast your minds back when he first arrived in the Premier League everyone was saying the same about him and given time he transformed into the player he is now.
Click to expand...

Yes I agree, not to write Bernardo off in that role, but if you look at what Pep has done with DS, look at Bernardo, then look at Sanchez, if Pep wanted to 'convert' another player to be an option there, I would suggest that, apart from his habit of trying a few too many 'glory' passes, Sanchez could play there tomorrow & would actually be physically stronger than DS. It's purely down to whether he is smart enough to keep possession a bit more. He can tackle & hunt down, just as well as DS or KDB, no problem.
 
Danamy said:
I personally think Bernardo would welcome Sanchez, as you say he's currently being used to fill in for Sterling and Sane but with Sanchez's arrival he'd be utilised as rotation with Spanish Dave and KDB where I think his game is best suited. Those that think he's too lightweight and slow for this position please don't write him off just yet. Spanish Dave is obviously irreplaceable but cast your minds back when he first arrived in the Premier League everyone was saying the same about him and given time he transformed into the player he is now.
Click to expand...

Not everyone. I can honestly claim to have wanted Dave at City before we were linked with him and to have never fallen into the too lightweight trap.

I think Bernie might benefit from working on his upper body strength but I'm sure there's a balance to be struck. I do think we need to be able to rotate KDB and Dave out more...

I've wanted Sanchez all along; I wanted him when he left Barca. Getting him now would have far more positives than negatives; although getting him in the summer without paying Arsenal a dime would be sweet. However, the right couple of signings in this window could help City ice the cake and add a cherry on top.
 
Neville Kneville said:
Yes I agree, not to write Bernardo off in that role, but if you look at what Pep has done with DS, look at Bernardo, then look at Sanchez, if Pep wanted to 'convert' another player to be an option there, I would suggest that, apart from his habit of trying a few too many 'glory' passes, Sanchez could play there tomorrow & would actually be physically stronger than DS. It's purely down to whether he is smart enough to keep possession a bit more. He can tackle & hunt down, just as well as DS or KDB, no problem.
Click to expand...

I think one of the beauties of Sanchez, if we can eventually get him, is that he can play anywhere across the front line but also drop a little deeper and cover one of the positions Dave and Kev own. I don't think that should be hugely to the detriment of Bernie, who has time on his side to build a long fruitful City career. If Pep can rotate more and vary things more without a drop in quality, players like Bernie and Gundo may benefit from having Sanchez here.
 
 
OB1 said:
I think one of the beauties of Sanchez, if we can eventually get him, is that he can play anywhere across the front line but also drop a little deeper and cover one of the positions Dave and Kev own. I don't think that should be hugely to the detriment of Bernie, who has time on his side to build a long fruitful City career. If Pep can rotate more and vary things more without a drop in quality, players like Bernie and Gundo may benefit from having Sanchez here.
Click to expand...

Possibly, & BS is such a talented player, but when Sane came on v Newcastle, imo there was suddenly a feeling that Newcastle were in iminent peril, if they lost the ball, which isn't there when BS plays & tbf, imo wasn't there whe Silva & Nasri played either, great as they were. We strike terror into opponents now.

Imo Sterling & Sane are now a blueprint for footballing terror which Pep has discovered through trying different options, & much as I love DS, if he was playing in place of Sterling or Sane, (assuming both are on form) I'd say we were a 'weaker' team, than with those two in it. Not necessarily so, with Sanchez up there, as he can still go direct like Raheem & Leroy do. But Bernardo, DS, even KDB, in a front 3 position, is now usually a step down in attack imo.

Of course that can change with the incessant bus parking negating their pace, but even then both Raheem & Leroy tend to shoot & run in behind more too.

As it stands, Sanchez would be a great alternative to either, or to Jesus/Aguero, but if Pep decides he can play as an alternative to DS & KDB, I think both Bernardo & Gundogan may have a problem.

Don't forget, Pep wanted both Sanchez & Mbappe. Maybe the idea wasn't for both to play in the front 3.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Unread Posts

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top