Wasting money, or buying smart?

I was talking to a friend about this very thing this past weekend. City only has two players that have played significant minutes that they bought in the off-season. Ederson and Walker. Bernardo Silva is getting more time lately due to match congestion. Mendy would have played significantly more were it not for his injury. I dare say that Ederson and Walker have been fantastic additions and I have no reason to believe that Mendy would have been the same. Silva isn't in the same class as KDB or Spanish Dave.

This team finished a distant third last year and didn't win a trophy or make it too deep in the CL. So what has happened? First, our much maligned, overspent on players such as Sterling and Stones stepped up their play to a point that I've not heard anybody talk about their price tag in months. Others also have shown great improvement. Due to Kompany playing more and the improved play of the rest of the back line, Otamendi has been rock solid and the crazy tackles have become much less common. Delph who many thought was only on the roster to keep the English player count up, has been really good out of position at LB. Sane has gotten better, Gundogen has played some quality minutes when needed, and Jesus and Aguero are both able to play together or apart and give the team scoring options. KDB, D. Silva, and Ferandinho have been in top form.

So the reality is that the success of this team is multifaceted. Good signings that live up to their cost, paired with improvement in play in all levels of the team, and continued greatness from those that were at that level before. All signs point that the decision makers at City know what they are about.
 
This may tip into the media bias thread, apologies if it does.

So, City were heavily criticised for the outlay of money £30m+ for a goalkeeper, £50m+ for fullbacks, a right attacking mid, and a centre mid in Luiz.
Spend £216m (ish).

Several points here......
21 players have left (6/7 on loan)... realising £70m+...
Giving the benefit of the doubt (assuming wages are paid for loaners), 15 less on the wage bill...including some significant earners

So, a net spend of £146m....but 15 less wages to pay, no, it probably doesn't balance out...but it isn't too much of a yawning gap.

Who has been replaced??????
How much criticism did City get for Bravo, and the defence last year?
In comes 3 top quality defenders and a goalkeeper....makes sense to me.

Silva coming in...maybe Merlins long term replacement, but a player which adds another dimension , I would go as far to say, he is world class.

So...City are stronger.

Age.....
Average age of players bought......23
Average age of players that gave left .... 26

To summarise so far....
Younger, better players brought in to positions that were desperately needed.

Last point...timing.
City bought early....probably why the press went nuts....all done at once....and early.
Look what has happened to the transfer market since mid July.....a very average premier league player is now £20m or so (Gray to Watford £18m as an example).
Pep got in before the prices went even more crazy.

Quick comparison to the Rags

3 players in £146m ...average age 25

6 players left £7.25m average age 23 (not counting Ibrahimovic as likely to stay).
3 of the 5 players loaned....so only Rooney & Januzaj have left.

Players brought in.....
A forward replacing a forward....more mobile yes, but will he score more
A centre mid
A centre back

The Rags issues were scoring goals....I don't see how this has improved

In conclusion

Tfr net difference
City £146m
Rags £139m

Players off the books (wage reduction)
City 15 or 16
Rags 3 (inc Ibra)

Average age of recruits
City 23
Rags 25

Average age of release players
City 26
Rags 23 (25 inc Ibra)

Players replaced in need of positions
City....keeper and full backs...yes
Rags...forwards....yes in that Ibra is injured.....but no stronger than last year.

Rags also still looking to buy more, in the heightened market

Wasting money, or buying smart?

So, city have bought, younger, better players, in positions they needed to..... before the prices hiked up even further....in total contrast to the Rags

I think Pep has bought smart

Ahem, I'm not often right...but I was on this one
 
I was inthe City Store today looking for some Champions gear and at those prices we could afford to buy Neymar and make him play for the EDS.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top
  AdBlock Detected
Bluemoon relies on advertising to pay our hosting fees. Please support the site by disabling your ad blocking software to help keep the forum sustainable. Thanks.