All-time City XI

[itisrising]

But with a twist. Based solely on their overall abilities not their overall contribution to the club, how would your all time City 11 look like.

Mine would be:

Peter Schmeichel

Kompany Boateng Laporte

Vieira KDB

Bell Silva Law

Aguero Weah

 

[Ardwick Green Blue]

But with a twist. Based solely on their abilities not their overall contribution to the club, how would your all time City 11 look like.

Mine would be:

Peter Schmeichel

Kompany Boateng Laporte

Vieira KDB

Bell Silva Law

Aguero Weah

It's all about opinions.....I suppose...


No matter how bizarre.

 

[gouldybob]

But with a twist. Based solely on their abilities not their overall contribution to the club, how would your all time City 11 look like.

Mine would be:

Peter Schmeichel

Kompany Boateng Laporte

Vieira KDB

Bell Silva Law

Aguero Weah

Do you mean while at City or in their careers.
Because Weah, Boateng and even Schmeichel were bang average or worse with us. Two of them were way over the hill

 

[itisrising]

Do you mean while at City or in their careers.
Because Weah, Boateng and even Schmeichel were bang average or worse with us. Two of them were way over the hill

Regardless of their time here, just overall ability.

 

[Bpughh]

-------------------Eddie--------------
Zaba---kompany--laporte---Power
------------------Toure---------------
--------------KDB------silva----------
----Kinkladze---aguero--tevez----

 

[Gorton_Tubster]

Corrigan

Laporte
Kompany
Walker
Zaba

KDB
Silva
Morrison

Aguero
Tevez
F. Lee

Subs
Hart
Ederson
Yaya
Summerbee
Tueart

 

[franksinatra]

Trautmann
lake—-Kompany—Woosnam
Yaya
Silva KdB Bell
Meredith Aguero Doherty

Subs:
Lee
Francis
Swift
laporte
Vieira
Law
Kinkladze
Power

 

[Millwallawayveteran1988]

Based on their very best form of their careers but obviously not always whilst playing for us.

Hard to come up with 12 so I’ll go with a squad of 22.

Keeper - Ederson, Seaman

Defenders - Zab, Book, Van Buyten, Kompany, Power, Doyle, Watson

Midfield - De Bruyne, Silva, Toure, Bell, Summerbee, Vieira, McMahon, Sterling

Forwards Aguero, Weah, Fowler, Tevez , Lee

Sure I have missed a few who should have made it.

 

[The Stockport Iniesta]

Trautmann
Lake
Kompany.
Laporte
Power
Toure
Bell
Silva
De Bruyne
Lee
Aguero

 

[ganganvince]

No place for Rocky

 

[@BluePhil8]

Will only go on what I’ve seen live;

Ederson
Zabaleta Kompany Laporte Clichy
De Bruyne Yaya Silva
Tevez
Aguero Dzeko

On a knife edge between Dzeko and Sterling. Dzeko’s monster finish to the 13/14 title winning season and his game at Goodison give him the edge.

 

[Cellarite]

Based on their very best form of their careers but obviously not always whilst playing for us.

Hard to come up with 12 so I’ll go with a squad of 22.

Keeper - Ederson, Seaman

Defenders - Zab, Book, Van Buyten, Kompany, Power, Doyle, Watson

Midfield - De Bruyne, Silva, Toure, Bell, Summerbee, Vieira, McMahon, Sterling

Forwards Aguero, Weah, Fowler, Tevez , Lee

Sure I have missed a few who should have made it.

Ederson and Seaman over Schmeichel?

 

[Grealish’s Shinpads]

Gunnar Nielsen - Sun Jihai, Tal Ben Haim, Glauber Berti, Danny Mills - Vuoso, Fernando, Jack Rodwell, Scott Sinclair - Jo, Santa Cruz

 

[Ribchester]

Trautman
Maicon Watson kompany clichy
KDB Yaya Deyna Silva
Aguero Francis

 

[Grealish’s Shinpads]

Gunnar Nielsen - Sun Jihai, Tal Ben Haim, Glauber Berti, Danny Mills - Vuoso, Fernando, Jack Rodwell, Scott Sinclair - Jo, Santa Cruz

On a more serious note and based off players I’ve seen play I’d probably say...

Schmeichel - Maicon, Kompany, Boateng, Zabaleta (too young to remember us ever having a decent left back so two right backs it is) - KDB, Lampard, Vieira, Silva - Aguero, Weah

Honorary mentions to Yaya, Kolo, Laporte, Anelka, Seaman, Tevez and Van Buyten.

 

[yeseye]

 

[itisrising]

Trautman
Maicon Watson kompany clichy
KDB Yaya Deyna Silva
Aguero Francis

Maison is a brilliant shout, can't believe I forgot him.

 

[Millwallawayveteran1988]

Ederson and Seaman over Schmeichel?

I couldn’t bring myself to pick rags other than Tevez who I don’t really see as a rag. If I could remove my hatred and bias I would probably have picked him and Cole.

 

[hateutd]

It's all about opinions.....I suppose...


No matter how bizarre.

Definitely, with Trautmann,Lee, Bell,Summerbee,Doyle,Goater, Aguero...

 

[RiversideBlue]

Gunnar Nielsen - Sun Jihai, Tal Ben Haim, Glauber Berti, Danny Mills - Vuoso, Fernando, Jack Rodwell, Scott Sinclair - Jo, Santa Cruz

surely Michael Frpntzech deserves a place in this team.