I've deferred this year and thank God I did. Personally, and for the long term benefit of fans who just want to be easy going match attending supporters rather than tech laden participants in some kind of Orwellian social control experiment, I hope it's a disaster. Only then will those in the Ivory Towers realise that the masses will not be made fools of unduly. I'm kind of hoping this will be like the Poll Tax; a great idea on paper but it was detested enough to cause mass riots and non payments.
The saddest thing about this however, is the realisation of just how out of touch our club has become with the very people who were once its lifeblood. We are now regarded as nothing more than a colourful backdrop to the product being sold around the world. In short, clubs views fans as high maintenance liabilities (Policing, Security, Insurance, Stewards, Staff, Ticketing etc) for the revenue they generate and introduction of such schemes without any genuine fan consultation show the complete disregard In which we are kept.
I'll leave you with this little thought:- How long before virtual fans/noise are considered the easy option and the way to go? We had a season experimenting with it and I can guarantee there will have been some interesting number crunching going in by the bean counters during that time.