Next Manager after Pep

[Long Slow Goodbye]

If the next guy can match Pellers record all is well and good. Apart from perhaps the CL I think Pep's record when he
leaves will be almost impossible to match. Indeed it may mark an end to the era of City as the team to beat.

Thats why it’s an ideal time for him to leave - his success came at a time when nobody else in the league had a depth of quality to compete; now everybody else is stockpiling talent too, so whoever succeeds him is going to be operating in a much more competitive environment, will struggle to win as many titles and therefore be deemed inferior.

We were on a rapid decline under Pellegrini. It was getting worse and worse every season and the defence was a joke. He benefitted a lot in his first year from the defensive organisation left over from Mancini, similar to Martinez’s first year at Everton, but as time went by that organisation eroded away. We wouldn’t have got top 4 16/17 season if he had stayed and we only got it by the skin of our teeth in his final year.

To be fair the recruitment under Pellegrini was the worst of the 4 managers of the Abu Dhabi ownership. I agree he residually benefitted from Mancini’s work, but the fact all 3 of them won titles show that it’s the club that’d been built to win over the past decade, regardless of whether Guardiola turned up or not. I’d also point out that Mancini and Pellegrini’s final seasons were sabotaged by the knowledge they were going to be replaced.

 

[Phil1]

He won the league when he had the best squad in the competition, the same way Guardiola has in every season he’s coached. You think Pep would have won the league with the Liverpool and Leicester sides Rodgers has?

Disrespectful motherfucker.

Aplogies to @gordondaviesmoustache for pinching material but it seemed apt.

 

[Johnny Mars Bar]

What’s the criteria? Inheriting Barcelona 2 years after they’d won a European Cup, with key players from the Spain Euro 2008 team and a Messi who was naturally destined to be the best player in the world? Or winning default titles at Bayern while neutralising them Europe? Or winning a 3 titles in his 5 years here, in each of which he had the best squad in the league?

Where’s the evidence of superiority, that can’t be accredited to circumstance?

He doesn’t have a reference point of overachievement - the true barometer of greatness for a manager - like Ferguson did with Aberdeen or Klopp had with Dortmund and Liverpool.

You'd think he personally dragged the club up from Division 2 and won us our first Premier League title the way some on here deify him.




Yep. Winning means nothing if it’s inevitable - I’d rather have done it the Leicester way; an owner who wants to invest rather than monopolise, develop our own talent and win one title and cup in 5 years if it was achieved more organically than simply buying £1b of players to neutralise the competition.

LOL.

I had you on ignore already for something or other...but fuck me what a weird take you bizarre bell end.

 

[theres only one carlito]

Hansi flick

 

[Lkzerinho]

I liked the guy at Ajax, Ten Hag?

 

[gordondaviesmoustache]

Disrespectful motherfucker.

Aplogies to @gordondaviesmoustache for pinching material but it seemed apt.

Don’t worry about it mate, I purloined it myself!

 

[Lavinda Past]

I sure City have a list of people they are watching and, along with Rodgers, I expect Enrique is on there.

I suspect Premier League experience may get more priority with the next manager selection.

I suspect Champions League experience will be higher on the club's wishlist. Whether or not we've won the CL during Pep's tenure.
It's where the biggest money is. That's the priority.

 

[OB1]

Dismiss what he did in Scotland, tinpot league that even Gerrard has won.

Look at his recent seasons with Leicester, bottled CL qualification 3 years in a row.

His piss poor management cost Liverpool the title as it has with his recent years with Leicester. It is not a coincidence they struggle when the pressure gets on top.

He didn't bottle the top 4 and his players don't amount to the fourth best team or squad in England.

 

[OB1]

I'm not sure why it would, the Abu Dhabi ownership have never hired a manager with Premier League experience and we've won 5 titles out of it.

Very true. It's just a feeling: they may want to take less risks next time round because following on from Pep is such a tall order.

 

[OB1]

I suspect Champions League experience will be higher on the club's wishlist. Whether or not we've won the CL during Pep's tenure.
It's where the biggest money is. That's the priority.

Possible but the league and UCL qualification is bread and butter.

 

[daflanger]

Not sure if a German can succeed at City. I think we should be looking at a Spanish or Portugese coach

 

[decmancity]

He won the league when he had the best squad in the competition, the same way Guardiola has in every season he’s coached. You think Pep would have won the league with the Liverpool and Leicester sides Rodgers has?

He’s also got a very good track record of identifying and developing young talent, something that the ideal candidate for the job should have, given the amount of elite potential there is in our academy now. I don’t think we’d be seeing £60m utility players under him.

Yes. I think Pep does win the league with the liverpool squad. Leicester, no.

Pep is the gold standard for developing young players despite what some believe. Just because he hasn't sold Gundogan so McAtee gets to start doesn't mean he doesn't know what hes doing.

I think most of the credit for the players that Leicester have bought should go to their scouting and footballing director.

He didn't bottle the top 4 and his players don't amount to the fourth best team or squad in England.

Who did then?

Hes finished 9th, 5th and 5th. How on earth could he possibly come in and takeover as Pep. We tear the rags apart for bringing in Moyes, this would be on the same level. "Done a good job with limited resources and made a challenge once so he deserves a shot".

It would genuinely be embarassing if we replace Pep with Rodgers.

 

[wayne71]

Not sure if a German can succeed at City. I think we should be looking at a Spanish or Portugese coach

We should be looking at the best coach.

 

[eyalluvitt]

Yes. I think Pep does win the league with the liverpool squad. Leicester, no.

Pep is the gold standard for developing young players despite what some believe. Just because he hasn't sold Gundogan so McAtee gets to start doesn't mean he doesn't know what hes doing.

I think most of the credit for the players that Leicester have bought should go to their scouting and footballing director.


Who did then?

Hes finished 9th, 5th and 5th. How on earth could he possibly come in and takeover as Pep. We tear the rags apart for bringing in Moyes, this would be on the same level. "Done a good job with limited resources and made a challenge once so he deserves a shot".

It would genuinely be embarassing if we replace Pep with Rodgers.

Guaranteed to finish in positions 3-2-1

 

[Citizen Green]

If the next guy can match Pellers record all is well and good. Apart from perhaps the CL I think Pep's record when he
leaves will be almost impossible to match. Indeed it may mark an end to the era of City as the team to beat.

Not for me, Pellegrini had 1 good season and 2 very subpar ones in my opinion.

We have to aspire to remain the team to beat.

 

[jimharri]

Looks like Steve Bruce might be available shortly. One to keep in mind, methinks.

 

[franksinatra]

Not for me, Pellegrini had 1 good season and 2 very subpar ones in my opinion.

We have to aspire to remain the team to beat.

We were on a downward trend with Pellers. The lack of energy and work rate was the worst I had seen until his West Ham side came along.

 

[city warrior]

He won the league when he had the best squad in the competition, the same way Guardiola has in every season he’s coached. You think Pep would have won the league with the Liverpool and Leicester sides Rodgers has?

He’s also got a very good track record of identifying and developing young talent, something that the ideal candidate for the job should have, given the amount of elite potential there is in our academy now. I don’t think we’d be seeing £60m utility players under him.

One of the stupidest comments(an the one before) that I've seen.

Just answer this. Rodgers would be paid way less than Pep. If Rodgers give the same results as Pep does, then why is he not being offered what Pep is? Pep resigns tomorrow, and you can be sure all the big clubs in Europe would be behind him offering whatever he wants. Could you answer why? Do you know more than owners and all people in football?

I don't even need to talk about how he produced, maybe, the best team in football history from a team that was 3rd 20 points!! below R. Madrid in the season before. Or how he won the league with Barca B, or how he has destroyed all the league records in Spain, Germany and England. Or how he has produced the best football in England, or how he's the only manager in the last 20 years that has stayed at Bayern for 3 seasons...

 

[117 M34]

Wouldn't be too keen with rodgers.
I think he is a decent manager - until mid April - but I'd don't think he would inspire the players.
Imagine him doing a player meeting with serial winners and talking about 3 envelopes.

 

[JGL07]

Nick Cushing and Gareth Taylor possibly back in the frame??

I would prefer Peter Cushing or Graham Taylor to be honest!