Just read this and thought "Yeah, that sums up how I feel about Mancini". Turns out it's my own words, lmao.
I think with all the glory Pep has brought us, the job Mancini did at City has been forgotten a bit. Not by us, just by younger City fans and the media. I guess it was almost 15 years ago now and time marches on. But Pep, as much as he didn't come into a title-winning team, came into a club that had experienced some success and had been built with the expectation that he would one day be the man to make us globally popular and one of the biggest, most decorated clubs in the world. Pep has instilled an elite mentality. But I think the job he had, taking us from a team with some experience of silverware (on the edges of the elite) to the next level, was easier than the job Mancini had.
Mancini walked into a club that finally a had a bit money to play with but no real focus on how to turn cash into trophies. We were still a frightened club that had lived in United's shadow for 20-ish years. He got a big taste of that inferiority complex in his first few derbies - with those last-minute defeats and the Rooney overhead kick - and I think he took it upon himself to take the pessimism and weaknesses instilled by years of underachievement and relegation and crush it. That 35 years banner at Old Trafford gave Mancini and the players a target. Something to focus on and achieve, just win a trophy and get that banner down. By the time he left we were on a par with United and heading beyond them long-term.
Things ended badly. I did want him out after the Wigan FA Cup final - our style of play had become far too predictable and narrow and he was clashing with more players than we knew about at the time - but not in the way it went. He deserved that one last FA Cup final with the players fully committed to his plans, and he'd have been able to walk away with his head held high, knowing he'd achieved his mission and then some. As it was, it kind of ended like a toxic teenage first love, where Mancini and the City fans took years to get over each other after a fiery break-up. I think it took until the Centurions season or even the domestic treble season for us to move on.