Worst Goalkeeper

Kieth macrae kept big joe out of the side for a while. I didn’t think he was too bad. Dibble for me. Especially at forest that was embarrassing
 
Dibble, got his move to us from a penalty save for Luton against Arsenal in the League Cup final.

He was average at his very best and utter gash normally.

Pleased to say Howard Kendall spotted how bad he was instantly and signed Tony Coton (exceptional and one of our best ever keepers), amazingly part of our fan base was angry that Dibble was dropped, quite an incredible reaction, much like a lot of the idiots of today that question Ederson.
 
Peter Schmichael purely because he was past it and it was a bit insulting to have some rag cast off go through the motions for a season who clearly couldn’t give a fuck about the club.

Proper dickhead.

Wound up Gary Neville though so that was one positive.
 
flook said:
keith macrae (showing my age) and I'm sure many will disagree, but I thought Kasper was vastly over rated
Click to expand...
Disagree on the Ginge as he was nowhere near the worst IMO
But, KS was the biggest cnut ever! Once passed him in the hallway behind the boxes laughing his cock off after another home defeat when Joe was being picked ahead of him, rightly so! I said something like "I'm glad you find that funny..... you fkin rag!" and he looked at me for a few seconds, then walked away still laughing his cock off. It took me all my restraint not to follow him and give him a proper slap!
 
BufordUSABlue said:
Disagree on the Ginge as he was nowhere near the worst IMO
But, KS was the biggest cnut ever! Once passed him in the hallway behind the boxes laughing his cock off after another home defeat when Joe was being picked ahead of him, rightly so! I said something like "I'm glad you find that funny..... you fkin rag!" and he looked at me for a few seconds, then walked away still laughing his cock off. It took me all my restraint not to follow him and give him a proper slap!
Click to expand...
He was poor for us, stuck to his line on corners and crosses 1 or 2 years out. His dad pulling out at OT was also a disgrace, "injured in the warm-up". Carlo was better.
 
genuinely can't believe how many single out Dibble, thought he was a decent keeper for City , remember the home game v Villa when Paul Lake did his injury, Dibble was outstanding in a 2-1 win and was a decent back up to Coton and as for hearing Zack Steffen mentioned seriously? was outstanding whenever he played in covid season away win at Chelsea, cup wins at swamp and Goodison, made a mistake against dippers at Wembley which affected him but those 2 definitely made more of positive contributions than likes of Isaakson, Seaman and Immell, David James gets a honourable mention as he always seems to be on the pre-match shows these days but i remember he couldn't wait to jump ship to 'Honest Harry's' Portsmouth
 
gloryhuntersince85 said:
genuinely can't believe how many single out Dibble, thought he was a decent keeper for City , remember the home game v Villa when Paul Lake did his injury, Dibble was outstanding in a 2-1 win and was a decent back up to Coton and as for hearing Zack Steffen mentioned seriously? was outstanding whenever he played in covid season away win at Chelsea, cup wins at swamp and Goodison, made a mistake against dippers at Wembley which affected him but those 2 definitely made more of positive contributions than likes of Isaakson, Seaman and Immell, David James gets a honourable mention as he always seems to be on the pre-match shows these days but i remember he couldn't wait to jump ship to 'Honest Harry's' Portsmouth
Click to expand...
Seaman, Simon Tracey, Margetson, Immel, Tommy Wright etc were considerably worse for us than Dibble by some margin. Seaman in particular was in disgraceful shape for a professional. Never forget seeing him floundering about like a beached seal at a pre season friendly at Mansfield and realising he was here for one last payday and nothing else.
Ended up paying up his contract and fucking him off mid season under the pretence of a ‘back injury’ to spare everyone’s blushes
One of Keegan’s weaknesses was that he was always overly partial to a ‘showbiz’ signing of over the hill veterans, and while the likes of Pearce paid off, Seaman was a disaster
Andy Dibble was decent enough for where we were at the time.
Legendary shagger though, some of the stories of his extra curricular activities were eye opening!
 
LongsightM13 said:
Seaman, Simon Tracey, Margetson, Immel, Tommy Wright etc were considerably worse for us than Dibble by some margin. Seaman in particular was in disgraceful shape for a professional. Never forget seeing him floundering about like a beached seal at a pre season friendly at Mansfield and realising he was here for one last payday and nothing else.
Ended up paying up his contract and fucking him off mid season under the pretence of a ‘back injury’ to spare everyone’s blushes
One of Keegan’s weaknesses was that he was always overly partial to a ‘showbiz’ signing of over the hill veterans, and while the likes of Pearce paid off, Seaman was a disaster
Andy Dibble was decent enough for where we were at the time.
Legendary shagger though, some of the stories of his extra curricular activities were eye opening!
Click to expand...
Agreed mate.
It was clear when Schmeichel got here, there was still a couple of seasons in him at least and was a great bit of business, with Seaman, that clearly wasn’t the case.

Having said that, I still see Fowler as being the worse bit of business we did under KK, I was willing Bernstein to stick to his guns on that one.
 
gloryhuntersince85 said:
genuinely can't believe how many single out Dibble, thought he was a decent keeper for City , remember the home game v Villa when Paul Lake did his injury, Dibble was outstanding in a 2-1 win and was a decent back up to Coton and as for hearing Zack Steffen mentioned seriously? was outstanding whenever he played in covid season away win at Chelsea, cup wins at swamp and Goodison, made a mistake against dippers at Wembley which affected him but those 2 definitely made more of positive contributions than likes of Isaakson, Seaman and Immell, David James gets a honourable mention as he always seems to be on the pre-match shows these days but i remember he couldn't wait to jump ship to 'Honest Harry's' Portsmouth
Click to expand...
Dibble could be brilliant and calamitous in equal measures. And i agree, he doesnt come into the top 5 shite goalies since ive been watching since the early 80s.
Possibly isnt even in the top 10!

Tracey, burridge, sydall, seaman, stowell, mimms, ellegurd (sp), all comfortable sit above him, and thats without thinking of more.
 
Jack74 said:
Always remember Summerbee saying the season we went down under Ball that he knew we where in big trouble cause Immel couldn't see properly and was cross eyed
Click to expand...
If it was Mike saying that ok, but is it was Nicholas, FFS that cnut should keep quiet.
 
Dirty Harry said:
Agreed mate.
It was clear when Schmeichel got here, there was still a couple of seasons in him at least and was a great bit of business, with Seaman, that clearly wasn’t the case.

Having said that, I still see Fowler as being the worse bit of business we did under KK, I was willing Bernstein to stick to his guns on that one.
Click to expand...
Yep another showbiz signing
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Unread Posts

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top