Nottingham Forest (H) | Sat 23rd Sept | PL | Post Match Thread

Your comment about Phillips is 100% spot on. He had a couple of runs deep into their half. He lost control and made himself look amateurish. Sorry to say it (I know he wears a blue shirt), but what is he doing in one of the best squads in the world?
Down to 10 men who predictably were going at us big time, I agree he ran deep into their half and lost the ball (as their players crowded him out)...... but he had no other City player within 25 yards to give it to and he had taken it out of our territory, thus giving the defence some respite. Second half we had to tough it out.
 
Watching the match back, and paying closer attention to Forest and their chosen way of stopping the best team on the planet. I now see that City players were getting a real kicking, right through the match. Shortly before his red card, Rodri was absolutely clobbered from behind. Taylor was letting far, far too much go.
Those two goals are among the best you'll see at any stadium on earth. Same thing for that final save from Ed.
Really proud of this team.
Fuck Forest.
I guess that depends on your definition of clobbered.

It was more a push in the back, which should have been a free kick, imho, but not in the referee’s.

Those challenges have gone on since the dawn of the game. They happened again when we were trying to keep the ball near the corner flag later on too.

Rodri lost his head. It happens,
 
Anybody else find something vaguely comical about that business of two grown men putting their foreheads together, rolling them up and down, from side to side, while talking to each other from a distance of about three inches?
IMG_1968.jpeg

‘Two alpha males rutting on the wild plains of the Etihad.‘
 
That’s not the point though is it? When the results dropped off (I assume you mean Brighton and Brentford) Pep made wholesale changes, not just Phillips. The players also had their minds in bigger fixtures, all of them. I agree Pep clearly isn’t keen, but my point is Phillips did ok yesterday yet still he is the one people slag off. Godri got sent off, Erling missed a sitter, but a lot of people just want to dig out Kalvin. He did ok yesterday

Yes philips did fine considering he has hardly played any football! Regarding our other two players you mentioned they have proved themselves! Philips firstly hasn't proved himself in training over the last 12 months+ is why he hasn't been picked hardly!
 
I guess that depends on your definition of clobbered.

It was more a push in the back, which should have been a free kick, imho, but not in the referee’s.

Those challenges have gone on since the dawn of the game. They happened again when we were trying to keep the ball near the corner flag later on too.

Rodri lost his head. It happens,
It was immediately prior to the push in the back and looked nasty and calculated.
 
I guess that depends on your definition of clobbered.

It was more a push in the back, which should have been a free kick, imho, but not in the referee’s.

Those challenges have gone on since the dawn of the game. They happened again when we were trying to keep the ball near the corner flag later on too.

Rodri lost his head. It happens,

You're talking about the second foul (the one which led to the altercation), I think. Immediately before it, Rodri's got the ball, he's running away from his Gibbs-White and he doesn't merely shove Rodri in the back, he whacks him, hard, his right leg on Rodri's left. Furthermore, if you look closely, Rodri's left leg is slightly bent laterally. Could have been seriously nasty. That is in fact what sends Rodri over. Clear yellow card, and free kick to us. Not the slightest intention of playing the ball.
Yes, those kinds of challenges go on on Hackney marshes every Sunday. Not, thankfully, in the modern professional game at the highest level. They are sanctioned, and rightly so. If Taylor had did what he should have done, there's no incident following it. Rodri was stupid, and it's a red, but there's a lead-up to it, and Taylor is completely responsible there. (By the way, they'd already been doing it in the latter stages of the first half).
Play it back once or twice. You'll see.
 
You're talking about the second foul (the one which led to the altercation), I think. Immediately before it, Rodri's got the ball, he's running away from his Gibbs-White and he doesn't merely shove Rodri in the back, he whacks him, hard, his right leg on Rodri's left. Furthermore, if you look closely, Rodri's left leg is slightly bent laterally. Could have been seriously nasty. That is in fact what sends Rodri over. Clear yellow card, and free kick to us. Not the slightest intention of playing the ball.
Yes, those kinds of challenges go on on Hackney marshes every Sunday. Not, thankfully, in the modern professional game at the highest level. They are sanctioned, and rightly so. If Taylor had did what he should have done, there's no incident following it. Rodri was stupid, and it's a red, but there's a lead-up to it, and Taylor is completely responsible there. (By the way, they'd already been doing it in the latter stages of the first half).
Play it back once or twice. You'll see.
Sounds like VAR should have sent Gibbs-White off and been charged with assault.

These things happen all the time.
 
For the minute, we're involved in four competitions (that's not even thinking about the World Club Championship). It's a marathon. Not a sprint, nor even a 10,000m. We had the game won twenty minutes in. They presented no kind of a threat. In those conditions, keep the ball, knock it around, conserve energy.
That's how you get a treble won. Or even — dare I say it? — a quadruple.
Thats fucked it then ;-
 
You're talking about the second foul (the one which led to the altercation), I think. Immediately before it, Rodri's got the ball, he's running away from his Gibbs-White and he doesn't merely shove Rodri in the back, he whacks him, hard, his right leg on Rodri's left. Furthermore, if you look closely, Rodri's left leg is slightly bent laterally. Could have been seriously nasty. That is in fact what sends Rodri over. Clear yellow card, and free kick to us. Not the slightest intention of playing the ball.
Yes, those kinds of challenges go on on Hackney marshes every Sunday. Not, thankfully, in the modern professional game at the highest level. They are sanctioned, and rightly so. If Taylor had did what he should have done, there's no incident following it. Rodri was stupid, and it's a red, but there's a lead-up to it, and Taylor is completely responsible there. (By the way, they'd already been doing it in the latter stages of the first half).
Play it back once or twice. You'll see.

A very good assessment.

I'm not 100% convinced it should have been a red but hard to see why Gibbs-White hit the deck, other than play acting. I did though look straight to the ref as I feared the worst and he was quick to go to his top pocket.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top