Ilkay Gundogan

Status
Not open for further replies.
jaiguruKun said:
Really torn on this. He isn't quite the player he was and he left on such a high note it seems a shame to risk his legacy at the club. On the other hand if he can produce somewhere close to his last couple of season's form he'll be a welcome addition!
Click to expand...

He could come on, score 5 own goals in the derby and then go off in a wheelchair, how does that take away anything from him being our treble winning captain and club legend.
 
pennblue said:
My worry is that Barca are going to fuck this up. They'll get some cheeky 10mil bid from fenerbache or a Saudi club and say, "oh I know we told you you could leave for free but we really need the money, we need a few million to save face"

Am I overthinking how shitty Barca are run?
Click to expand...

They need him off the payroll and the player only wants to come to city. They can’t really play funny buggers.
 
Edwaardz said:
Genuinely happy Gundo is coming back, so not complaining in the slightest, but…

What was our actual plan for midfield reinforcement going into this season, given Gundo leaving Barca is just a chance event that we’re lucky to be able to pounce on.

You’d think they’d have been planning throughout last season for the best way to solve the Rodri dependency issue and this clearly isn’t that plan.

Bit of a get out of jail free card.
Click to expand...
They trusted Kovacic to do it when needed, and in their defense, there was no plan for Bobb to break his leg this late in the window. I know Bobb plays further up the field but a utility player like Gundo coming available fixes more than 1 issue short term.
 
Edwaardz said:
Genuinely happy Gundo is coming back, so not complaining in the slightest, but…

What was our actual plan for midfield reinforcement going into this season, given Gundo leaving Barca is just a chance event that we’re lucky to be able to pounce on.

You’d think they’d have been planning throughout last season for the best way to solve the Rodri dependency issue and this clearly isn’t that plan.

Bit of a get out of jail free card.
Click to expand...

I think it was Bruno G. We obviously didn’t value him at £100m but thought we could get him for £85m but, that depended upon him forcing the move - which he obviously wasn’t prepared to do; or maybe Newcastle just wouldn’t contemplate selling and we’ve struggled for a credible plan B.
 
Edwaardz said:
Genuinely happy Gundo is coming back, so not complaining in the slightest, but…

What was our actual plan for midfield reinforcement going into this season, given Gundo leaving Barca is just a chance event that we’re lucky to be able to pounce on.

You’d think they’d have been planning throughout last season for the best way to solve the Rodri dependency issue and this clearly isn’t that plan.

Bit of a get out of jail free card.
Click to expand...
Txiki and Pep have been reading the market like an open book and knew there would be coming opportunities, they just had to wait and decide then. Release clause days are over, at least this summer.

They maybe didn't have Gundo on their cards, but hey.
 
DATOIA said:
Gundo is great addition for two reasons.

1) Rodri cover.
When I imagine this midfield, I am not that worried about Rodri being rested or rotated.
Very high quality and decent midfield, capable to play against any team I bet.
---------Gundo------------
Bernie------------Kovacic

2) Julian Alvarez replacement. Can play second striker / false 9 roles. Especially after Oscar Bobb got injured, we needed someone like Gundo.

Here I am talking about Gundo as a squad player.

If Pep somehow returns to his "treble winners" formation, I think we still have the team to beat that RM Galacticos or whatever the fuck they call themselves.

Gundo makes all the sense there is.
Click to expand...
FC Franco.
 
jaiguruKun said:
Really torn on this. He isn't quite the player he was and he left on such a high note it seems a shame to risk his legacy at the club. On the other hand if he can produce somewhere close to his last couple of season's form he'll be a welcome addition!
Click to expand...
He's had 12 months warm weather training in the Barça sun. He'll be fully refreshed & ready to get back to the Manchester graft... :-)
 
I don't see how this doesn't affect Foden and his playing on the wing far more than he wants. If he finds himself on the wing this season, he has every right to be pissed.

Can you imagine Pep putting a player who was bought for 100M and had just won Player of the Year the season in his preferred position back in a position that he doesn't want to play and is clearly worse at? I can't.
 
jamielowndes said:
He was literally the top scorer in 2020/21 playing as a False 9.
Click to expand...
He played in attacking midfield once that season. It was as a 65th minute substitute in the FA Cup semifinal against Chelsea. A game in which Jesus played up front.

The rest of that season he almost solely played in central midfield.

He’s never played as a false 9 for us.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Unread Posts

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top