The Midfield

Surely if we sign enough centre backs one of them could play midfield if they ain't covering for not having fullbacks.

More centrebacks please

Or wide attackers
 
Outlandish thought. Rodri does the job of two maybe 3 players.

Why don't we put grealish in there alongside kovacic. Grealish is composed and kovacic can do the leg work.

That's my thought and have been thinking grealish should play centrally for a while now, we bought him from villa doing that.

Kova and leg work??? If he ran any slower he’d stop.
 
And how long do we wait considering we have been ignoring it for 2 years.
Anybody with legs,an appetite and playing for a decent club has got to be better than the current mess.
We’ve dominated English football for a decade because on the whole we make better decisions than our rivals, we have a clear strategy that’s served us well and will continue to do so.

I don’t think that strategy includes making impulse purchases of unsuitable players half way through a transitional season. I agree with you that we’ve waited too long to refresh the midfield but the end of the summer window will be the time to judge favourably or unfavourably how well the rebuild has gone.
 
We’ve dominated English football for a decade because on the whole we make better decisions than our rivals, we have a clear strategy that’s served us well and will continue to do so.

I don’t think that strategy includes making impulse purchases of unsuitable players half way through a transitional season. I agree with you that we’ve waited too long to refresh the midfield but the end of the summer window will be the time to judge favourably or unfavourably how well the rebuild has gone.
Our strategy will look pretty poor when the reigning champions finish trophyless and mid table the following season
 
We’ve dominated English football for a decade because on the whole we make better decisions than our rivals, we have a clear strategy that’s served us well and will continue to do so.

I don’t think that strategy includes making impulse purchases of unsuitable players half way through a transitional season. I agree with you that we’ve waited too long to refresh the midfield but the end of the summer window will be the time to judge favourably or unfavourably how well the rebuild has gone.
At this point the rebuild hasnt even started (hopefully). We have no number 1 goalie. No RB. No LB. No DM. No Second Striker. Issues all over midfield.

And 13 Centre Halfs, 60% of which cant run. And the rest who are still in nappies. Its a shit show!!
 
All too old.

Of the 4 I’d only keep Kev because even though he’s too old his quality is still apparent. The other 3 are officially shit nowadays imo.
I don't think Gundogan and KDB will be retained. Long term, our midfield is fine imo. Rodri, Kovacic, Bernardo, Foden, Grealish and you could possibly add Marmoush as a no. 10 in the role KDB used to play if we play Savinho and Bobb on the wings. O'Reilly and Macatee look like they could make it too. It's the defence that is an issue as only Gvardiol seems to be fit to play every week.
 
Our strategy will look pretty poor when the reigning champions finish trophyless and mid table the following season
Should have done what we did now in the Summer. I thought KDB and Gundogan would flop but I didn't think it would matter. Unfortunately the defenders went awol
 
recruitment big part of problems. we should fight a lot more for keeping Alvarez or Palmer but maybe less when Walker or Ederson wants to jump ship to Saudi as thats kind of sign of they are ok to check out but we did it the other way while Palmer and Alvarez will be crucial players over next 10 years in top football.

and obviously we did bring in midfield reinforcement but those were Phillip, Nunes and Gundogan. just not good enough.
 
I don't think Gundogan and KDB will be retained. Long term, our midfield is fine imo. Rodri, Kovacic, Bernardo, Foden, Grealish and you could possibly add Marmoush as a no. 10 in the role KDB used to play if we play Savinho and Bobb on the wings. O'Reilly and Macatee look like they could make it too. It's the defence that is an issue as only Gvardiol seems to be fit to play every week.
Thats midfields not fine though. It’s a rodri injury away from being the same shite it is now. We need a proper unit to hold it together if hes out. And to compliment him when hes in.
 
We need a rugged box to box athlete who also needs to have tactical nous and decent technical ability

Bellingham
Nico @ 75% is the only player we have like that.

NO ONE else can tackle or get round the pitch.

He's not perfect but even at 75% he's better than the other options to create mobility and bite.
 
recruitment big part of problems. we should fight a lot more for keeping Alvarez or Palmer but maybe less when Walker or Ederson wants to jump ship to Saudi as thats kind of sign of they are ok to check out but we did it the other way while Palmer and Alvarez will be crucial players over next 10 years in top football.

and obviously we did bring in midfield reinforcement but those were Phillip, Nunes and Gundogan. just not good enough.
Yes fair enough. But given what we have right now why can’t we go with a Kova, Nunes , Grealish midfield? Maybe not top class individually but as a unit cant be worse than what we saw yesterday?
Really not sure what Pep is doing right now
 
Jacob Wright is the only defensive midfielder we have in the squad. There’s no way he’ll get picked though.

So we are asking 8s and 10s to cover there. Almost none of them are suited to it (even if they once were) and almost none of them have pace.

Nico O’Reilly is the only one with pace so he could do a job there, he did play there in pre-season last Summer, despite being an attacking midfielder. Will he get picked though?

Time’s up for the others now, their struggle in defensive midfield has gone far enough. It’s time for something new, so why not O’Reilly?
 
It’s really true, we are Rodri FC.

We are also mentally weak.

We need 2 World class midfielders that keep the ball and are technically brilliant.

The club knows this but tonight was a huge wake up call.

Two weeks of the window left.
The mentality issue has become a real problem, not sure why though. We don't seem physically robust either at times. Is this a symptom or a cause of the mentality thing? Needs sorting regardless.
 
What does that mean ? What does o Reilly think he is
An attacking midfielder. A No8.

Now I'm 'old school' where playing in midfield meant getting forward to help the forwards and doing your bit defensively.

But I think he seems himself as more of a forward thinking player.
 
The mentality issue has become a real problem, not sure why though. We don't seem physically robust either at times. Is this a symptom or a cause of the mentality thing? Needs sorting regardless.
It’s not a case of Physicality or Mentality, it’s Physicality AND Mentality.
Every team we struggle against has fitter, faster, stronger midfielders.
Not only that but is there anything more inevitable after we concede one that we collapse, no backbone at all in this squad, it’s shocking.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top