This team wouldn't make the top 8, let alone the top 4. The idea that those who didn't start in the last defeat must be better than those who did may seem attractive but it is a bit daft.
Currently, we have many players who are in poor form, especially in midfield where only Nico G is a firm starter. Foden, KDB, Bernardo and Gundo aren't good enough these days. Better play the team that started vs. Spurs.
Well that's the point isn't it, You've named four players that haven't been good enough, So that leaves us down to the bare bones.
Everyone is going back to the team that played against Spurs, What about the team that battered Newcastle 4-0 (Which was our best performance of the season), That team had Rico Lewis, Gundogan and Phil Foden all in the starting line up.
Kovacic is another that started against Spurs, He hasn't been pulling up trees either, Truth be told he's been bobbins.
O'Reilly deserves his chance that's not even up for debate, How many times does he have to prove himself to show Pep he deserves a Premier League start, Before we know it he'll be sold and become a hell of a player elsewhere and he'll be one of numerous players that's got away.
De Bruyne legs are gone yet I'd still have him starting, At least he had to bollocks to try something different, Take risks with the ball and open the opposition up, The rest have it all too easy playing it safe.
So the idea of not starting players that started in the previous defeat isn't daft, It's daft continuously playing the same players and expecting different results.