Lots of fans say no, but in my opinion if he stays and then scores a few goals or an important winner, then there is a way back.
I think him coming back into the squad though would be dependant on him singing a new contract with a release clause for foreign Champions League clubs.
We have to keep him in anyway, we showed today that we have a good squad who can compete. In our first 2 games we have played Aston Villa, and Liverpool, and deserved to win both of those games. So at the end of the season we should be up there, and hopefully going deep in the cups. We can’t let our striker go, especially one of the quality of him, additionally we can’t let him go to Liverpool. Since Howe has came in we have actually went toe to toe with Liverpool in pretty much every match, with the exception of the away match last season where we hid our tactics ahead of the cup final against them a week and a half later.
We can’t be selling our star player to them or any other club we hope to challenge titles for.
I’ll tell you this now, our first team is so good under Howe, that if PSR had allowed us to expand the rest of the squad, and keep the likes of Isak, we’d be winning the league this year instead of looking to do it in 5-10 years time.
Thanks, interesting and FWIW I agree, it won’t be the same but if he is scoring you’ll find away to live together.
Interesting on a foreign CL team as really only PSG or Real who could pay that amount outside of PL and might need to be cheaper to tempt them.
PSR comment is also interesting, as you know if your on here City fans don’t consider ourselves part of the big 6 or are in favour of these rules, Martin Samuel is the best journalist on this and always described it as a drawbridge, which rightly or wrongly we did what we did before it went up.
Newcastle and Man United would make such a good article and snapshot of what PSR do. We’ll have different answer on this, I’m sure but our opinion on the rules will be similar.
A great question is who wins the PL next, United or Newcastle…
Now the answer should be you guys, just won League Cup, owners wishing to invest, in the CL and on the whole brought well in the transfer market. Genuinely on the way up.
But for me despite finishing 15th, owners criticised for taking money out of the company and not investing, no European football performing poorly both on the pitch and in the transfer market.
But this transfer window shows they can still drop £200 million +, attract players (tends to mean pay high wages and go again). Newcastle can’t do that and if you invest for CL and you don’t make it again like Villa found, it becomes very problematic for you.
So I go United, as they keep getting another chance no matter how much they mess up, You guys have to keep defying the odds.
It’s a glass ceiling protecting the elite and that’s before VAR (which was somewhat questionable in their game against Fulham)