Premier League Games | 27/28/29 Sept '25

Chalobah must want to flatten Andrey Santos for getting him that red card, what a horrific piece of football from him, I'd laugh at that if I saw it at amateur level.
 
Can someone explain the red card / penalty incident at Brentford please.
The rag was pulled back in the area so it's a penalty and yellow card, fair enough. But I thought it could only be a red card under current rules if it was dangerous play. Yet I've just heard about the PL saying the rag wasn't in control of the ball so yellow was correct. Shearer has said he wasn't in control because he was being pulled back so it should have been red. Has there been a change in the interpretation of the double jeopardy aspect?
 
Can someone explain the red card / penalty incident at Brentford please.
The rag was pulled back in the area so it's a penalty and yellow card, fair enough. But I thought it could only be a red card under current rules if it was dangerous play. Yet I've just heard about the PL saying the rag wasn't in control of the ball so yellow was correct. Shearer has said he wasn't in control because he was being pulled back so it should have been red. Has there been a change in the interpretation of the double jeopardy aspect?
If the player doesn’t make a genuine attempt to win the ball, it can still be a penalty and a red card.

See Cancelo vs Fulham a few season’s back as an example.
 
If the player doesn’t make a genuine attempt to win the ball, it can still be a penalty and a red card.

See Cancelo vs Fulham a few season’s back as an example.
No doubt the rags will receive an apology from red Webb and his mates, as the Brentford player wasn’t making a genuine effort to win the ball.
 
Can someone explain the red card / penalty incident at Brentford please.
The rag was pulled back in the area so it's a penalty and yellow card, fair enough. But I thought it could only be a red card under current rules if it was dangerous play. Yet I've just heard about the PL saying the rag wasn't in control of the ball so yellow was correct. Shearer has said he wasn't in control because he was being pulled back so it should have been red. Has there been a change in the interpretation of the double jeopardy aspect?
Double jeopardy still exists, it only comes into play if a genuine attempt to play the ball is made. Can still get a red for deliberate stuff of which that was very deliberate. He should have saw a red its not even a debate. Another officiating fuck up but a happy one for once.
 
If the player doesn’t make a genuine attempt to win the ball, it can still be a penalty and a red card.

See Cancelo vs Fulham a few season’s back as an example.

Double jeopardy still exists, it only comes into play if a genuine attempt to play the ball is made. Can still get a red for deliberate stuff of which that was very deliberate. He should have saw a red its not even a debate. Another officiating fuck up but a happy one for once.
Cheers for the replies. I thought it had to be dangerous play for it to be a red if a penalty is awarded.
 
Can someone explain the red card / penalty incident at Brentford please.
The rag was pulled back in the area so it's a penalty and yellow card, fair enough. But I thought it could only be a red card under current rules if it was dangerous play. Yet I've just heard about the PL saying the rag wasn't in control of the ball so yellow was correct. Shearer has said he wasn't in control because he was being pulled back so it should have been red. Has there been a change in the interpretation of the double jeopardy aspect?
According to VAR ( what I'm told they said) the attacker wasn't in full control of the ball so it couldn't be classed as preventing a clear goalscoring chance. The same excuse for not sending the Palace keeper off in the final where it was claimed Haaland was going away from goal so the handball wasn't classed as stopping a clear goal scoring chance.
A load of rubbish
All smoke and mirrors
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top