City replacing Pep with Maresca feels like a club trying to copy its own homework and hoping nobody notices.
Pep is one of the greatest managers football has ever seen. You don’t replace that with a guy who couldn’t even keep control of Chavski for a full project cycle. Maresca talks the same positional football language, but that doesn’t mean he has the aura, adaptability, or elite-level management to handle a dressing room full of serial winners. Chavski fans were already questioning his rigidity, slow build-up, and inability to change games when things went wrong. Now we are supposed to believe he can succeed the most demanding manager in modern football? That’s not succession planning that’s wishful thinking.
The biggest concern is that Maresca looks like a system coach who only works when everything is perfectly structured around him. Guardiola earned authority through years of winning at Barcelona, Bayern, and with us. Maresca hasn’t earned that respect yet. One bad run and the comparisons to Pep will become unbearable.
And paying compensation to Chavski for a manager they were happy to lose just makes the whole thing look even stranger for me. Feels less like we are choosing the best coach available and more like we are desperately trying to preserve the Guardiola style without Guardiola himself. History usually shows that never works imo.