Recent content by tttt3

  1. T

    PL charge City for alleged breaches of financial rules

    I think he has it backwards here. He is framing it like City asked Etihad and Etisalat to step in as backup, when they are completely separate corporations defending their own reputations after the PL publicly branded their deals "sham" without ever interviewing them. Their High Court...
  2. T

    PL charge City for alleged breaches of financial rules

    I think you might have missed the point of what I laid out in the earlier posts. Have another read through if you have time, it's not about the season dates on the charge sheet, it's about the fact that the specific financial rules and fair market value frameworks didn't exist yet back then...
  3. T

    PL charge City for alleged breaches of financial rules

    Spot on with the analogy, that is exactly what I am saying. It’s like driving down a road that was legally 30mph in 2011, following the posted speed limit, and getting a ticket a decade later. To do that they used an old, vague "drive with due care and general good vibes" clause from the...
  4. T

    PL charge City for alleged breaches of financial rules

    Not quite, let me clarify! I mean that the specific rules we judge these sponsorships by today (like the Premier League's Associated Party Transaction rules, which didn't exist until late 2021) weren't around back in 2011. Because those rules didn't exist then, the league couldn't charge City...
  5. T

    PL charge City for alleged breaches of financial rules

    After my previous post, where I shared my thoughts on how the PL seemed to stretch vague "good faith" and "true and fair" clauses to retroactively apply 2021 sponsorship rules, a few people rightly pushed back and challenged my take. A lot of the feedback pointed to the leaked internal emails as...
  6. T

    PL charge City for alleged breaches of financial rules

    Personally, I am not going to worry too much about the contents of the appendices when they drop, and and will ignore the media hype until we actually hear City's arguments and context. When/if the appendices finally do come out, I suppose we are likely to see some uncomfortable-sounding...
  7. T

    PL charge City for alleged breaches of financial rules

    Fair enough, and I like the widget analogy, Grandad! I still see it a bit differently, though. The widget example describes a deceptive setup, like secretly lending money to a customer just to fake sales figures and trick a buyer or an auditor, which on the face of it sounds similar to what is...
  8. T

    PL charge City for alleged breaches of financial rules

    Yeah I read that section of the panel's reasoning, and you have summarised their logic really clearly. Where I see it differently, and again I am no expert so this is just my reading of it, is that I think both of the pillars they used to reach that conclusion are actually open to challenge...
  9. T

    PL charge City for alleged breaches of financial rules

    That quote from Sheikh Mansour was City's factual defense, which I completely agree with; as I said earlier, I don't believe ADUG funded Etihad at all. My point was more of a legal hypothetical about the rulebook itself: as I read it, even if you took the PL's factual theory at face value...
  10. T

    PL charge City for alleged breaches of financial rules

    Fair point, I shouldn't have used the word subsidies. Etihad explicitly rejected that label during Open Skies and described it as shareholder equity and loans from the Abu Dhabi government. Either way, it was a trade dispute over aviation treaties rather than a fraud ruling, and the PL rulebook...
  11. T

    PL charge City for alleged breaches of financial rules

    That is definitely the strongest version of the PL's case and I asked myself that same question, and you are right that matching amounts make the factual optics much harder to defend. Where the legal battle still sits, though, is that under English commercial law, "back-to-back" funding does...
  12. T

    PL charge City for alleged breaches of financial rules

    I completely agree with your second point. State equity or subsidies going into a state-owned national airline is completely normal commercial reality, which is why the panel trying to lump the Abu Dhabi government and Sheikh Mansour into a single wallet is such a weak spot in their ruling. On...
  13. T

    PL charge City for alleged breaches of financial rules

    Just to be clear, I don't actually believe our owner or ADUG put money directly into Etihad. I think Etihad's equity came from the Abu Dhabi government, as has always been stated. My point is purely a legal one: even on the PL's own version of events, they didn't actually have any rules against...
  14. T

    PL charge City for alleged breaches of financial rules

    Fair enough I see what you are saying but, nobody disputes that if a transaction is proven to be a genuine sham, where the sponsor is literally just an empty conduit for owner equity, then the accounts aren't true and fair and it's a clear breach. That’s why everyone agreed early on that proving...
  15. T

    PL charge City for alleged breaches of financial rules

    Thanks. No rush I am also signing off now. Look forward to hearing your opinions on this when you get round to it.

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top