Worst City player you've seen live/worst City squad

[Thenumber1blue]

Chris Shuker, Nigel Johnson, certainly Frontzeck, and I especially like the mention of Roy Gratrix. I'd forgotten how awful he was. Ralph Brand, Ian Mellor, Frank Carrodus, Adrian Heath.......

Shuker, good shout. Don't think I ever saw him get a touch

 

[chaddblue]

Barry Conlon

The epitome of a pub player

 

[Pigeonho]

Carl Shutt is another.

Wow. Just wow at that era

 

[chaddblue]

For just one performance, Otamendi vs Southampton in the 4-2 loss a few years ago.

If it’s the same match I’m thinking of, Kolarov was even worse

 

[Bozo]

Corradi.

 

[Blueles61]

Frontzek & Ike Immel

 

[MarsLlama]

If it’s the same match I’m thinking of, Kolarov was even worse

My god yeah, can't believe I forgot that. Love Kolarov but his jogging back was painful to watch.

 

[Gareth Barry Conlon]

Christian Negouai. Worst in relation to hype / reality ratio.

David Brightwell. Worst in relation ability / ability of rest of the team.

Someone from the Barry Conlon era was possibly the worst ever although it is hard to judge from those dark days in tier 3 where we had all sorts of players in the squad.

 

[Sky Blue]

Tony Vaughan. Simon Colosimo.

 

[inthenextlife]

I've seen so much dross over the years and it's half-excusable if the player at least tries but most of the names from the 90s onwards I have to agree with. However, the worst player I've seen in a City shirt live based on expectation, previous club form and the whopping amount we paid for him is Wilfried Bony. Inexplicably bad and I don't remember him having a decent game for us. Total fish out of water for £25-30 million.