It is by supporters of other clubs certainly. The number of arguments I’ve had on the subject during the World Cup has been nobody’s business. As others have said, his ability to play in tight areas, to run in behind and anticipate what’s coming, to win free kicks, and generally occupy the opposition, are all attributes that saw him flourish last season and make him a valuable asset to us, but are routinely ignored by those who’ve swallowed the Sun’s narrative. The finishing though is an issue, particularly when put clean through with time to think about his options, as are the occasional heavy touches that see him overrun the ball in promising positions. As has been said though, criticism of those aspects of his game on Blue Moon can often lead to overreactions in some posters, particularly those who’ve previously hailed him as a potential Balon D’Or winner when he’s plainly not at that level.
As regards a new contract, we certainly don’t want him leaving because he brings a particularly valuable skill set, but neither do we need to be held to ransom. Wages wise I don’t see anyone being prepared to offer him significantly more than he’s already getting, and I expect him to sign a new deal with us eventually