Tricky_Trev
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 18 Jan 2009
- Messages
- 31,580
Even Duncan Castles thinks they were wrong to interpret the new handball rule in the way that they did.
Yep. I assume it’s to cover a deflection leading to a simple tap in. Jesus had to make the space himself to create the goal. Clarification is certainly needed, but as Karen says, it can’t now happen until the end of the season unless they bring it in at Christmas after everyone’s played each other once.The commentators and journalists have not read the rule.
The rule says
It is an offence if a player:
- gains possession/control of the ball after it has touched their hand/arm and then:
- scores in the opponents’ goal
- creates a goal-scoring opportunity
AND THEN
Laporte does not and then anything. It inadvertently flicks off his arm which leads to controlled possession by another player.
This is about interpretation. It's not black and white at all. I think the rule was set up to stop a situation where the ball directly goes in off a players arm, or when it srikes an arm, and a player makes a conscious assist.
The VAR decision was harsh or wrong application of the handball rule.
So Oliver did not know about the rule and was passing judgement on the field.The commentators and journalists have not read the rule.
The rule says
It is an offence if a player:
- gains possession/control of the ball after it has touched their hand/arm and then:
- scores in the opponents’ goal
- creates a goal-scoring opportunity
AND THEN
Laporte does not and then anything. It inadvertently flicks off his arm which leads to controlled possession by another player.
This is about interpretation. It's not black and white at all. I think the rule was set up to stop a situation where the ball directly goes in off a players arm, or when it srikes an arm, and a player makes a conscious assist.
The VAR decision was harsh or wrong application of the handball rule.
Even Duncan Castles thinks they were wrong to interpret the new handball rule in the way that they did.
Every goal in every game this season has had a VAR review.
Do you have a dog and a white stick?I cannot recall an incorrect VAR decision that has gone against us.
I don’t think the handball created the chance at all. The ball barely deviated from its path. The chance was created and finished by Jesus, not as a result of the ball striking Laporte’s arm.
Simply don’t see how you can say that chance was created by the handball.