Not sure about some of the points above.
We did not have a better CB than Curle until we signed Kompany (IMO). The football was turgid but solid, I wonder if having Quinn in the team means we defaulted to long ball because of personnel and not Reid, Reid didn't buy Quinn and with Dave White getting injured we were very reliant on Quinn's goals. Paul Lake also never played for Reid (in a fit state at least) and any team would have missed him.
As for Booze. Reid was one of Kendals men and Kendal was the biggest booze monster of the game - all time. Kendal would have weekly team 'meetings' in a pub. The booze culture of the club was clearly rocking when Reid took over - it didn't get any worse because it could not have been any worse.
Some other points i accept but generally it was toward the end of the Swales era and the club was 10 years behind the rest at that point and there was a huge pile of problems. Brian Horton over achieved post Reid in terms of quality of football but then Reid delivered the better points totalls (as i recall it).
So in summary I think Reid was ok in a time when the club was dragging itself downward off the field.