I fully agree with you, we’re far better with the high press and I could be completely wrong here, second guessing Pep is impossible for seasoned trophy winning managers nevermind some clueless fan like myself. simply trying to offer an explanation for it as I can’t imagine it’s a case of the players just not putting the effort in as Pep would absolutely rollick them for it at least in private if not publicly and we’d see an immediate impact the following game yet we’ve seen it for weeks now leading me to believe it’s a planned thing.
In addition to what I said originally, we don’t have a very mobile midfield right now to do it effectively with an ageing silva in there and either gundogan or Rodri behind him, both of whom play in Gareth Barry’s Iron Boots.