FA Cup Replays 14/15 January

[citizen_maine]

The arm was in a natural position - good enough for a defender - which part of the pitch do you change from a defender to an attacker?

At the part where you stop defending and start attacking

 

[Gazza]

Yep, I’m sort of ok with that kind of handball being given, the ball was going nowhere near the scorer until the handball and it led directly to the goal, nothing like an accidental brush and then plenty of work to do to score.

Are you thinking of any goal in particular?

 

[Ohrodneyrodney]

At the part where you stop defending and start attacking

Makes absolutely no sense whatsoever.

 

[Gazza]

At the part where you stop defending and start attacking

The play can transition outside of your own box - so is it there?

 

[Zin 'messiah' Zimmer]

Your just a shit Man City, ringing out from the wolves fans

 

[willipp]

The arm was in a natural position - good enough for a defender - which part of the pitch do you change from a defender to an attacker?

Million dollar question pal. Not saying I agree totally, but to say it glances his arm isn’t true. Hits his arm directly and then falls right into the path of the attacker who scores. For me that’s an ok decision as it directly lead to the goal.

 

[ancoats]

Set in stone ? Except for Liverpool players you mean

they always come out with the funny quote stuff as well ? like inconclusive video replay ??? another words fuck off its a liverpool goal

 

[willipp]

Yep, I’m sort of ok with that kind of handball being given, the ball was going nowhere near the scorer until the handball and it led directly to the goal, nothing like an accidental brush and then plenty of work to do to score.

Agreed. If we let these kind of decisions muddy the waters then the rule won’t be changed as for me that was a fair call.

 

[Gazza]

Million dollar question pal. Not saying I agree totally, but to say it glances his arm isn’t true. Hits his arm directly and then falls right into the path of the attacker who scores. For me that’s an ok decision as it directly lead to the goal.

I must admit I was angry when I typed it and exaggerated but the games gone my friend.

 

[Ohrodneyrodney]

You simply cannot have different handball rules for defenders than attackers. Its completely nonsensical.