Sly v Arnie

[Inter Me Nan]

Can't believe nobody has mentioned Predator, bunch of slawjawed faggots in here!

 

[Dr Jacoby]

Arnie has starred in far more better movies than Sly.

Predator, Commando, T1 & 2, True Lies, Total Recall, The Last Action Hero, The Running Man, Twins....etc

Cop Land wasn’t bad, though.

 

[Magicpole]

I find I avoid all their films now as they are mostly fucking awful. The "acting" is well, less than terrific isnt it! But, having said all that, there are two I can watch every couple of years. Which is more than I can say about Harry fucking Potter and Star Bastard Wars.

 

[hilts]

Versus in what context?

Acting?
Neither can act for toffee but Stallone was a slightly better actor. Arnie is probably the worst Hollywood actor ever.

Films they were in?
Stallone. Rocky and Rambo are better than Terminator and Twins.

I think Arnies accent and Stallones speech make their acting seem worse than they were but Arnie is pretty poor Sly was good in cop land and a few other films.

Some rocky and Rambo films are piss poor and throwing in twins is a piss take tbh. You could have mentioned many better films he has been in.

First blood and cop land vs terminator and predator is a tough call.

 

[urban genie]

Arnie
terminator, T2 commando, predetor, running man, true lies, the 6th day, total recall, conan, twins, the last stand

Stalone
First blood, rocky 1&2, deathrace 2000, cliffhanger, escape to victory, tango & cash, Demolition man, cop land

Together
Lock up, the expendables

On number of watchable films I would say they are equal

Extra credit to stalone for writing an directing some of them and other films worth watching , and for staring in a porm film

 

[Bill]

Arnie and it's not even close

this

 

[Centurions]

sly. because first Rambo.

Agreed although the last Rambo very nearly changed my mind. What a disappointing way to finish the films.

 

[Phil1]

I don’t like to have my brain taxed too much when watching a film so they are both ok for me.
Rocky 1 and 2 and first blood are some of my favourite films though so I might just edge towards Sly.

 

[discopop]

Arnie for me Stallone almost singlehandedly ruined Judge Dredd with his showing so can’t be redeemed

 

[The perfect fumble]

Arnie
terminator, T2 commando, predetor, running man, total recall, conan, twins, the last stand

Stalone
First blood, rocky 1&2, deathrace 2000, cliffhanger, escape to victory, tango & cash, Demolition man, cop land

Together
Lock up, the expendables

On number of watchable films I would say they are equal

Extra credit to stalone for writing an directing some of them and other films worth watching , and for staring in a porm film

What about Arnie in True Lies, Eraser and his masterpiece Red Heat!

I see no one mentions Stalone in Judge Dredd, greatly underrated film that.