Nico Gonzalez | Newcastle deal agreed for £48m + £4m add-ons

Status
Not open for further replies.
I think we're (potentially) stronger.

Broken Stones & Broken Ake who would often be injured at the same time, or working their way back to fitness, are less reliable than Reis.

Savinho who couldn't finish, was weak and clueless defensively, is being replaced by someone who by accounts works hard defensively. And has some skill. If he scores less than Savinho it'll only be by one goal a season, so we are losing nothing.

Reijnders flattered to deceive, as has Marmoush. We'll only miss Marmoush whenever we play Newcastle, the rest of the time we can just be glad he wasn't there being offside.

The midfield is the dodgy one still though - of course we'll miss Rodri, but Bernardo wasn't far off burnt out. Gonzales wasn't someone we could build a side around - not when everyone is moving to aggressive and energetic pressing, he just isn't up to it.

Anderson's good and ready, Bouaddi could potentially be a great (though he'll need some time). One more in would be good - I'm not convinced by Fernandez but if management are, then maybe he's good enough.

My only issue is that we may take a few months to gel, but I think that by the deadline our squad will be more suitable for this PL the way it is now, than the squad we had.

Might be a bit too glass half full for some, but I'll stay that way until the deadline passes and then reassess things. Fingers crossed now....
I think I agree with your views by and large. I would add that we also signed two players mid season last year and so some of the departures offset that. Guehi offsets Stones and Ake on his own due to their fitness problems.

The midfield is the worry as the last two seasons we’ve been weaker than peak City. We needed to replace Gundogan and De Bruyne, never mind Rodri and Bernardo. Now we’re making wholesale changes and, as you say, that will take time. It would have been far better to bring an 18 year old wonder kid into the treble winning squad and let him learn and gradually replace one of our greats.

But it’s exciting to see what the squad looks like and how they develop.
 
Gonzalez, Marmoush, Reijnders, Ait Nouri.

All bought in the last 18 months or so, and none of them good enough for a team challenging at the top.

Three of them gone already and no one would care if Ait Nouri were to leave. Clearly we can’t keep going through players at that sort of rate even if we’ve recouped most of the outlay on them.

Hopefully this is the window where we start prioritising quality over numbers again.
Absolutely.

I would rather sign a top player who stays at City for 6 or 7 years and plays regularly, helping us win silverware, and leaves for a small fee - than acquire someone for say 30 million who is bit part, but we double our money in 2 years time. But yet spent 80 per cent of their time here on the bench!
 
Guehi and Reis > Stones and Aké
Rodri > Bouaddi
Anderson > 32 y/o Bernardo
Enzo >>> Reijnders
Allan > Savinho
Gakpo > Marmoush

We went into last season with Gvardiol, Dias, Khusanov, Stones and Aké as CBs and we brought forward signing a CB (Guehi) because of the double injury in January, but he was really Stones' replacement.

We're shaping up to have a stronger squad than last season, we've just left it late and need to get the deals done.
Glad shiny toy season is going well

Nobody knows who Allan is but now hes better than Savinho. If The Rags were buying this guy for £35mil we'd be laughing our asses off lets be real

Enzo he's ">>>" over Reijnders but Rodri doesnt over Bouaddi.... ok, have you watched these 4 play?

We signed Gakpo? We aren't getting him, and if we do its as a LW you dont wanna see him as a forward hes dog

Nico G, whos replacing him or is the plan to grind 50 games from Anderson or Bouaddi...

Bernardo still underrated, he lost his legs but still contributed massively and directly helped us in our h2h vs Arsenal. I love the Anderson signing but cmon, its a bit stpe up there is no guarantee this season we'll see more from him then we get from Bernardo who trend up every game in some capacity

Also the big one...Maresca vs Pep, no brainer
 
Nobody knows who Allan is but now hes better than Savinho.

He works hard and wants to be here so he’s already an improvement.

If he scores more than 1 league goal it’s categorical.

Bernardo still underrated, he lost his legs but still contributed massively and directly helped us in our h2h vs Arsenal. I love the Anderson signing but cmon, its a bit stpe up there is no guarantee this season we'll see more from him then we get from Bernardo who trend up every game in some capacity


I love Bernardo too but I don’t think people realise how many of our problems last season were caused by him and Nico as a pair offering nothing going forwards in terms of creativity from deep, it’s why Rodri made such a big difference when he played and why Foden - supposedly the most attacking midfielder - ended up playing deeper than he ever had before and even Cherki when playing 10 was picking the ball up the wrong side of half way when we were in possession.

Bernie by last season didn’t have the legs to do all the running in a midfield 2 and get involved in attacking, and Anderson does. You could already see on Sunday it’ll make a massive difference in the speed of our attacking play. The stats all back this up, but I think it was obvious with the eye test too.
 
Last edited:
Bit gutted about this. Think he did a decent job when Rodri was out. Doesn't seem to be moaning about lack of games time. Seems to want to be here and fight.

Watched the new amazon prime pep guardiola documentary today. That talk after the leverkusen game where he had given all the Fringe players a chance to shine and they fucked it up spectacularly. Maybe that was the turning point when they realised the recent signings weren't up to it.
Same point made

IMG_6283.jpeg
 
Guehi and Reis > Stones and Aké
Rodri > Bouaddi
Anderson > 32 y/o Bernardo
Enzo >>> Reijnders
Allan > Savinho
Gakpo > Marmoush

We went into last season with Gvardiol, Dias, Khusanov, Stones and Aké as CBs and we brought forward signing a CB (Guehi) because of the double injury in January, but he was really Stones' replacement.

We're shaping up to have a stronger squad than last season, we've just left it late and need to get the deals done.
I think the only thing you got right on your list was Rodri > Bouaddi. You think Vitor Reis is somehow better than Stones and/or Ake or a combo of Guehi and Reis is better than those two? You do realize that Reis has made two appearances for City, right? And I'm not even gonna say he played in his Prem debut. He was on for one minute. His other appearance was in the FA Cup against Orient. We don't know if Allan is better than Savinho; or if Enzo is better than Reijnders. Its puzzling that we might be pursuing Gakpo since he primarily plays on the left and that is the position that we are stacked at, unless we send Jack away and put Semenyo back on the right. Or is he now going to be our backup striker?
 
We don't know if Allan is better than Savinho; or if Enzo is better than Reijnders.

We don’t know if Enzo is better than Reijnders…

Sorry I’d normally make an honest attempt to reply to someone so clearly flapping, but this line makes it impossible to take you seriously.

If you’ve got a pair of eyes and have watched them both play a game of football, you know.
 
The cope in here is sometimes amazing. No CM in the club has a higher pedigree or bigger name than Enzo. „ don’t know if he’s good enough. „ „ overrated“
„ he’s a prick“
Prepare yourselves because he will join soon.
 
He works hard and wants to be here so he’s already an improvement.

If he scores more than 1 league goal it’s categorical.




I love Bernardo too but I don’t think people realise how many of our problems last season were caused by him and Nico as a pair offering nothing going forwards in terms of creativity from deep, it’s why Rodri made such a big difference when he played and why Foden - supposedly the most attacking midfielder - ended up playing deeper than he ever had before and even Cherki when playing 10 was picking the ball up the wrong side of half way when we were in possession.

Bernie by last season didn’t have the legs to do all the running in a midfield 2 and get involved in attacking, and Anderson does. You could already see on Sunday it’ll make a massive difference in the speed of our attacking play. The stats all back this up, but I think it was obvious with the eye test too.
We'll agree to disagree, as I definitely disagree

Think we'll be having midfield issues all season as we're banking on young players stepping up to some of our best ever players

Hope you dont jump on Allan in a year when he hasn't delivered
 
We don’t know if Enzo is better than Reijnders…

Sorry I’d normally make an honest attempt to reply to someone so clearly flapping, but this line makes it impossible to take you seriously.

If you’ve got a pair of eyes and have watched them both play a game of football, you know.
Oh I see. Like the 3 guys we just shipped? Clearly they all can play football. Nah - we sent them off. Clearly Pep and Txiki/Hugo saw something in those guys to make them want to get them over to us, no? Ah, but now you're glazing Enzo simply because Maresca wants him. Tell me why, in your cereal box analysis, is Reis - right now - paired with Guehi or Dias - better than Stones/Ake. I'll make it easy for you. You can't. You want it to be true.

And you didn't respond to the rest of your dreadful list because its based on hope. Tell me how Enzo who is a defensive liability. Who has zero presence in the air (it will matter if he's playing as an 8); who makes despairing tackles when he gets caught out; gets poor yellows in those tackles; has no pace; and how he could work himself into the front areas to beat a low block? And tell me how all of that is worth $130 million? Come on, at least study before you vomit your lazy take.
 
Tell me how Enzo who is a defensive liability. Who has zero presence in the air (it will matter if he's playing as an 8); who makes despairing tackles when he gets caught out; gets poor yellows in those tackles; has no pace; and how he could work himself into the front areas to beat a low block?

What are you on about? Seriously.

We’re comparing Reijnders and Enzo and you think we’re going to miss Reijnders presence in the air? His tackling? His pace?

Are you having a stroke? You’re worried Fernandez, who scored twice as many goals and twice as many assists last season will be less use in forward areas than Reijnders?

Seriously am I being clarkied? No one is this stupid? No one actually thinks Reijnders is a better player than Enzo. I don’t even want us to sign the prick and I know he’s 5x the player.
 
Last edited:
They'll get a 6/10 performance more often than not so if that's what they're looking for then fair enough, good luck to him and them
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top