I think I agree with your views by and large. I would add that we also signed two players mid season last year and so some of the departures offset that. Guehi offsets Stones and Ake on his own due to their fitness problems.I think we're (potentially) stronger.
Broken Stones & Broken Ake who would often be injured at the same time, or working their way back to fitness, are less reliable than Reis.
Savinho who couldn't finish, was weak and clueless defensively, is being replaced by someone who by accounts works hard defensively. And has some skill. If he scores less than Savinho it'll only be by one goal a season, so we are losing nothing.
Reijnders flattered to deceive, as has Marmoush. We'll only miss Marmoush whenever we play Newcastle, the rest of the time we can just be glad he wasn't there being offside.
The midfield is the dodgy one still though - of course we'll miss Rodri, but Bernardo wasn't far off burnt out. Gonzales wasn't someone we could build a side around - not when everyone is moving to aggressive and energetic pressing, he just isn't up to it.
Anderson's good and ready, Bouaddi could potentially be a great (though he'll need some time). One more in would be good - I'm not convinced by Fernandez but if management are, then maybe he's good enough.
My only issue is that we may take a few months to gel, but I think that by the deadline our squad will be more suitable for this PL the way it is now, than the squad we had.
Might be a bit too glass half full for some, but I'll stay that way until the deadline passes and then reassess things. Fingers crossed now....
The midfield is the worry as the last two seasons we’ve been weaker than peak City. We needed to replace Gundogan and De Bruyne, never mind Rodri and Bernardo. Now we’re making wholesale changes and, as you say, that will take time. It would have been far better to bring an 18 year old wonder kid into the treble winning squad and let him learn and gradually replace one of our greats.
But it’s exciting to see what the squad looks like and how they develop.
