42 | Antoine Semenyo - 2026/27

Give me 5 Prmeier league games he was exceptional in?

He’s technically awful no matter what competition.
We have a front three that have the touch and control of blind blacksmiths. He has the physical attributes to compete domestically but you need guile and technique in Europe.
 
He also was off it against Porto. Haaland was right…Semenyo is the ‘perfect premier league player.’ At best. And that’s being kind.

He’s not a European calibre or world class player. He’s a depth piece to come on with 30 minutes to go. Maybe will look better against knackered teams as a sub.

Baffled that he stayed on and Doku came off.
 
Even in the premier league he’s crap.

He needs dropping.
I got hate for saying that - since he somehow gets assists and goals in some games.

playing him with Doku just means for any opposition to double/ triple Doku since Semenyo can’t create at all. Someone like Ndiaye or even Allan would create a far better balance against better opposition. Let alone the defending. He’s very lazy often and leaves his fullback alone.
 
He really puts in the effort defensively, but his technique is so inconsistent it's frustrating.
 
If we were to face PSG, Bayern, Barça, Real, Atlético, or even Arsenal in a two-legged knockout tie with Semenyo in the starting XI, we shouldn't expect much: we would get torn apart. The reason is simple: it is impossible to implement a coherent style of play with him on the pitch. Facing teams of that caliber demands a certain level of precision and technical quality—qualities he simply lacks. There is no point hoping for anything else; we saw it last season at the Bernabéu, and we saw it again tonight. You don’t need to be a genius to realize he simply isn't cut out for these kinds of high-level matches.

He will do well in the Premier League—scoring goals and making a decisive impact—because the game there relies more on physical battles, an area where we are superior to 90% of teams (many of whom are technically limited); however, the demands of big European clashes are on a completely different level.
 
Nothing new, we always knew his technical quality was low, but playing against a team like PSG made that more pronounced.

But for however much anybody rates that quality, it only shows on LW, he cannot dribble AT ALL on the right, atleast on the left he looks somewhat more comfortable.

On the RW, Semenyo almost has to just be a wingback, lob the ball over the opposition LB and let him run through and cross, you cannot expect a slow methodical dribble from him there.

Its unfortunate that all 3 of Doku, Semenyo and Ndiaye are far more comfortable at LW.

I think we need to promote McAidoo and hope he can take the RW mantle, even if his recent game wasnt great.
 
He can tear apart most Premier league teams, but he isnt an elite level player ,he now needs a couple of goals to get him back on track ,can still see him ending up with 15-20 goals this season, but he looked out of his depth against PSG
 
I really like the lad. He usually operates on pure instinct but that deserted him last night which made for a very frustrating performance. He would have expected to have buried at least one of those chances.
 
How he does Play Full game is a miracle. Not for the elite games. Wished McAidoo was on bench to come in, pretty sure he wouldnt do more bad like semenyo.
 
He does a lot of very good things which get overlooked! What I like is he still wants the ball still tries to play to attack! Yep we know his weaknesses and I feel Maresca should know having him pick the ball up in midfield will be a liability against this psg side, if is this where Maresca is happy for him to be he has to to tell him two touches max control pass it even if it’s backwards, because losing it in midfield especially against this psg side it suicide!
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top