PL charge City for alleged breaches of financial rules

I've seen the recent chatter on social media about City being expelled from the PL, but also rumours to the contrary that the sanction may be a fine. Probably all baseless gossip. As a point of information though, I think automatic expulsion from the PL (not simply a heavy points deduction making this inevitable) would require a hefty majority of PL clubs to agree to this. I'm sure City have done the maths and have a good idea around the likely vote count that could mean expulsion does not have sufficient backing across the other clubs. There must also be some safeguards against the independent panel going completely rogue with a mad punishment. I initially thought this journey was comparable to a game of chess, but increasingly its more like a nuclear exchange where both sides understand they could obliterate the other (City via Etihad's actions against the PL). A negotiated peace seems to be the most likely end point to all of this.
I'd be surprised if expulsion could take place purely because of a vote. On that basis, a tyrannical majority could gang up on anybody for the most spurious reasons. And as Simon Jordan has pointed out, how would you weigh that up alongside the leniency of Chelsea's 'punishment'? This is where the PL are trying to go and is why they stressed the 'cooperation' of Chelsea, several months before the City decision was leaked. Further circumstantial evidence the decision was already known by the PL a long time before City knew it, in which case the tribunal members would be guilty of criminality.
 
There is nothing wrong with the balance of probabilities. It is how all civil actions are run including in the High Court, however it seems like common sense that if you have very serious allegations, you need compelling evidence, including financial records. This is a weakness in the PL's case. They admit to a weak evidential record.

Surely, if their case is that Etihad ran a scam sponsorship, they have to establish it by obtaining evidence from Etihad and cross examining them. It would be like finding a shoplifter, but not taking their evidence.
There is a problem with it however when the 'judges' and KC's presenting the so-called evidence to those 'judges' are selected by the same body... which wouldn't happen in an actual civil case.
 
I'm no fan of Jordan but he's spot on here,whether we like him or not he has got a voice in the media.
It's unreal how much chelsea got swept under the carpet,it was in the news for half a day at most.

It was how it played out the premier sucking them of in report! It’s like all the hedge funded clubs have all paid into all these clubs for there pension
 
If City win the appeal, the IC findings are wiped out. So why would Etihad launch a sovereign‑level legal action when the outcome they want has already been achieved?
Good point but it is an IF. They may want to be certain and to obtain direct vndication.

If was on the Etihad board, I would be straight to the High Court and ignore the vagaries of a commission that has labelled my company and board members a fraud.
 
They are the 3 KC's who represented the Premier League at the hearing apparently mate not the 3 man panel.

I doubt the original panel will ever be revealed, especially if City are successful in the appeal.
Yep, so obvious. Don't know what I was thinking!
 
The club will know and it would be passed on
I would imagine that would be subject to a further charge. There's a reason why they haven't been published. City releasing them to a third party is no different from the PL leaking them to the press.
They may have done so behind the scenes but Etihad would be ridiculously stupid to come out and say so.
 
I think the Holt piece has affected us a lot more than it should. Just ignore it. There have been numerous like these as soon as the penny dropped. I would fathom someone like Ornstein knowing more for sure. Relax, sanctions are anyways going to be bad with the verdict but we will try and overturn with the appeal.

He will put another similar one out in a day or two! Just because of the amount of clicks interactions it gets! 95% of the media are comics to me a fantasy click infested bottom dwellers of scum!
 
Paragraph 211 of the 93-page ruling, the CAS panel stated:



No doubt is strong.

Furthermore, CAS analysed primary corporate and financial data provided by Manchester City and Etihad Airways and much of this evidence was not studied in the PL commission.

Manchester City have constantly maintained that this was a partisan process. Read the verdict statement and you see this bias stamped right through it. There admit to missing documents and witness statements. They belong to Etihad. They cannot explain how and why Etihad supposedly operated a sham sponsorship agreement with City

They PL possibly felt that they could run the commission how they liked but now the process might be reviewed by the High Court, and that represents a danger for the PL.
This is the problem with inference: “We don’t have the proof, but we think this pattern in the emails suggests X.”And the IC effectively said: “Good enough.”
 
If we lose the appeal yes there is a real high chance that every sponsorship could come under the same microscope from 2018 to present. It’s going to be if the PL have the appetite to go after us AGAIN though or if they think the charges between 2009-2018 are sufficient enough (along with whatever punishment comes with it)

That is one of my biggest worries. There is the saving grace that the PL did deem Etihad FMV though so it won’t be as bad. That’s my understanding.
Oh what fun this fucking scenario is!!
 
I still cant get over what a sham and a stitch up this whole saga has been. The Premier league and the cartel/ monopoly establishment have tangled themselves up in so many ways all with objective of prosecuting and destroying their competition City.
ANY CITY FANS ON HERE WHO THINK THAT WE AND OUR BRILLIANT OWNERSHIP ARE TO BLAME ARE EITHER MAD or are FAKE FANS....
I CAN NOT THANK OUR OWNERS ENOUGH FOR WHAT THEYVE DONE FOR OUR CLUB.
 
Last edited:
There is nothing wrong with the balance of probabilities. It is how all civil actions are run including in the High Court, however it seems like common sense that if you have very serious allegations, you need compelling evidence, including financial records. This is a weakness in the PL's case. They admit to a weak evidential record.

Surely, if their case is that Etihad ran a scam sponsorship, they have to establish it by obtaining evidence from Etihad and cross examining them. It would be like finding a shoplifter, but not taking their evidence.
There is everything wrong with the "balance of probabilities". I can't believe it is still a legal threshold in the 21st Century, where evidence is readily traceable and abundant. It is, by it's very wording, a subjective threshold, no matter how the profession attempts to defend and portray it. It is the Caucasian Chalk Circle of justice.
 
Last edited:
What he’s really saying is how much cheating has gone on by those “in the room.” He’s named Chelsea but we know the cartel have cheated, will be interesting if it comes out.
FWIW I heard a snippet a week or so back that Arsenal and Liverpool think this has gone too far now and are bricking it that City will expose everything. It was about third hand so pinch of salt stuff really and I'm not hanging my hat on it but what was interesting is that the original source isn't anything to do with City or even a City fan so it wasn't said with any obvious bias towards us.
 
Paragraph 211 of the 93-page ruling, the CAS panel stated:



No doubt is strong.

Furthermore, CAS analysed primary corporate and financial data provided by Manchester City and Etihad Airways and much of this evidence was not studied in the PL commission.

Manchester City have constantly maintained that this was a partisan process. Read the verdict statement and you see this bias stamped right through it. The PL admit to missing documents and witness statements. They belong to Etihad. They cannot explain how and why Etihad supposedly operated a sham sponsorship agreement with City and they proceed regardless.

They PL possibly felt that they could run the commission how they liked but now the process might be reviewed by the High Court, and that represents a danger for the PL.

Paragraph 289?

1000002651.jpg
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top