PL charge City for alleged breaches of financial rules

Good news. It ought to bring the truth to light. If we've deceived auditors then we, as fans, have a right to know. We have a right to know if Khaldoon and Ferran have been lying. On the other hand, this may go a long way to clearing our name and restoring our reputation. I suspect it will be the latter.
100% this
 
Good news. It ought to bring the truth to light. If we've deceived auditors then we, as fans, have a right to know. We have a right to know if Khaldoon and Ferran have been lying. On the other hand, this may go a long way to clearing our name and restoring our reputation. I suspect it will be the latter.
It'll be better news if the FRC had the balls to check the audits of every other club in the Premier League as well as ours. I'd wager there be a fair old few clubs whose financial dealings would be on the "very suspect" side indeed.
 
I have no independent idea about whether this new review is good or bad.

However, I've barely seen a peep of it in the press. Given how many little things about the case have been picked up and sensationalised, and the feeling that certain journalists are being briefed by the PL/our rivals, that suggests to me that this can't be too bad.
 
It'll be better news if the FRC had the balls to check the audits of every other club in the Premier League as well as ours. I'd wager there be a fair old few clubs whose financial dealings would be on the "very suspect" side indeed.
Maybe this is the 'smoking gun' we have.

Bring in the FRC and we'll show you who's cheating!!!
 
The last thing i want is a governmental financial auditor getting involved. UK plc is fucking useless at balancing the books, we can't run a fucking bath. The whole issue is a fucking mess from start to finish. Somewhere in the near future a deal will be struck calling the whole thing off and we will settle for a fine for non cooperation and Fordham. I'm not wholly convinced by our posturing but i think the PL just can't prove it so stacked the deck as best as they could. I fully believe Masters is simply a middle management puppet worked by our rivals
 
I'm loving all this.

We are letting the premier league hang themselves out to dry in public.

Everyone from the red **** clubs screaming where is your irrefutable evidence.

Well here it is.

HMRC will be saying we are clean.

The FRC will say nothing to see here.

There is going to be nothing left for the premier league to point the finger at us.

Going to be glorious when this all comes back with a big fuckoff tick next to everything.

Don't the premier league look at our books every season anyway?

View attachment 208188

What I can’t get my head around is the complexity of the funding. AD government, etihad etc.
Is it that complex for the PL to misread it and decide it’s a sham?
You would think, only if it was unambiguous and clear cut that city were funded against the PL rules that they would use the word sham.
If they were even a tad unsure, you wouldn’t use the word sham in case it got contested.
Would all 3 of the panel have to agree on the wording of the report? Or just the Arsenal fan?
If it has been misinterpreted by the panel. The most important aspect of the charges by the way. Then it’s everything that Kaldoon has said. Clear and obvious. Tyranny of the majority etc.

So the question is. Is the funding deal that complex that it can be interpreted in different ways? Whereby the IC panel are partly correct but also city are partially correct. Is it that grey where balance of probabilities come in for something that should be black and white?
 
To me nothing us strange. It stinks of a cartel running the pl. It stinks of racism.

The pl and the British press/media are part of the cartel and racism.

I did have a smile to myself at Citys game on Saturday, being anti racism day. I thought yea right pl.
You only have to look at how FFP was dressed up many years ago. It was first touted as a response to clubs going bust but that mask has dropped. There was funnily enough a report recently which showed that football finances are completely on their arse. Quite clearly the big problem is how the PL hoards money and fails to distributes its income downwards.

The funniest thing about FFP is it hurts the poorest and lower clubs the most because when Championship clubs are promoted they have to invest in their squads heavily to compete but they simply aren't allowed to do it. Look at the Midland clubs, Burnley or the likes of Norwich.

Wrexham are the absolute prime example of how investment wins because they literally came from nothing to something in a very short period. That is a story worth telling however ultimately if we are to believe the PL and all of the media and pundits then Wrexham are just dirty cheats. If Wrexham got promoted to the PL then they will seriously struggle because the rules mean they cannot invest like they have before, so they'll just go back down.

These teams bounce up and down the PL because they're good enough to get promoted however they're not good enough to stay up and bounce on from there. Those with richer owners can't change that situation because of the rules. And when they get relegated the PL clubs rape and pillage for their best players.

It's indeed a cartel, a protectionist cartel where the PL brand is ultimately built around the brands of the likes of Arsenal, Liverpool and United. So they get what they want, protecting them becomes more important than protecting a newly promoted club because that is where the revenue is. It's unfair but the PL is just a private business which can do whatever it wants, it isn't a nationally run football league.

The notion that City have been found guilty of something is just ridiculous because the PL is not a court. The idea that you cannot invest in your own business is just lunacy but opposing that is what City are guilty of.
 
Everything related to Ian Byrne should start with with Lilelong liverpool Supporter. One wonders if he would be as keen to use his parliamentary privileges if Liverpool were being investigated
Interesting you say that.
I have a mate who happens to be a Liverpool fan.
He also happens to have been with Customs & Excise in Liverpool back in the day, and still works (privately) in the tax sector.

Along with the banter we’ve had about all this, he mentioned (after I brought up United’s ongoing £100m HMRC issues) that Liverpool’s auditing/accounting isn’t the best (especially pre fSG) , and he would welcome a full investigation of ALL PL clubs finances to shake out a lot of dodgyness, rather than just the targeting of City and having Chelsea self-report for leniency.
 
The killer corrupt line in the PL panel's verdict is them absolving Sheikh Mansour of all complicity. Clear and obvious tailoring because they knew they dare not accuse him even though their verdict pointed the finger.
Yes it really stands out. Despite all the protestations of no Government interference there is no doubt in my mind that someone higher up has said leave him out of this, which creates an unbelievable story that I’m sure will be mentioned on appeal.
 
I'll have a pint of what you're drinking.

The FRC isn't the "government getting involved". They're a body that regulate financial reporting and audit quality and you'd expect them to be interested in a scenario where an auditor has allegedly missed £830m of misreported revenue.

This is purely on BDO and nothing to do with City. Either we deliberately misled them and they did the best they could under the circumstances, or the quality of their audit work was below standard, or we and they haven't done anything wrong.

We might have been able to convince them that the sponsorships were kosher when we knew they weren't for example. But what happened with Fordham, where we paid £12-13m a year off our books? What did they ask and what did we tell them?
PB - before Fordham was set up and implemented, surely the club took legal advice?
 
Everyone knows the Fordham thing is “dodgy”. Masters and the cartel can’t nail us on that one though.
The “£900 million “ is the crux of everything as you know .
Absolutely the UK government is “involved “ ;)
Except they have nailed us on Fordham, which is part of the £900m.

However there is something in there, unrelated to auditing standards, that makes me agree that the government has been involved.
 
Interesting you say that.
I have a mate who happens to be a Liverpool fan.
He also happens to have been with Customs & Excise in Liverpool back in the day, and still works (privately) in the tax sector.

Along with the banter we’ve had about all this, he mentioned (after I brought up United’s ongoing £100m HMRC issues) that Liverpool’s auditing/accounting isn’t the best (especially pre fSG) , and he would welcome a full investigation of ALL PL clubs finances to shake out a lot of dodgyness, rather than just the targeting of City and having Chelsea self-report for leniency.
We know that isn't going to happen though is it? The funny thing is as long as you are compliant with the rules then you'll never get investigated so wrongdoing will never be found. City were only investigated in the first place because of the leaked emails.

Football needs blowing apart. It's hard not to see the irony when we're accused of cheating by organisations such as UEFA which have been completely rife with corruption scandals over the years. And don't get me started with FIFA which jesus christ probably has a storage area for brown envelopes.

I always wonder how PSG have never been investigated or sanctioned but then again having your chairman/CEO on the board of UEFA probably helps.... Amazing coincidence how Qatar got the WC too eh? I think for City our problem is the money simply comes from the wrong place. If you're American, Qatari or Russian, great we'll turn a blind eye but UAE, no thanks.

England has never held a WC for decades simply because our brown envelopes aren't big enough.
 
Last edited:

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top