PL charge City for alleged breaches of financial rules

If we are indeed confirmed as guilty and any high court case fails then surely Khaldoon as a prominent political figure is a buster flush? Reputation wise it really would be an horrendous look for him and even more so for Abu Dhabi?

Buster Flush ? Are you suggesting he's going to have to reinvent himself as some sort of ska tribute act? I can't believe he'll have to resort to that. Mind I would prefer The Bad Manners dining experience to an Abba one; cartwheeling bald blokes in dresses serving up the antipasti. It could perhaps provide some part time work for some of the FOCs on here, if their hips are up to it.
 
The FRC review will not help City.

They are not looking at whether our books are correct, they are looking at whether audit procedures were followed by the book.

In almost all of their reviews, they find that there were deficiencies in the audit and give the auditor a slap on the wrist. They will most likely do this in the BDO/ City case.

That is not to say audit deficiencies mean that the accounts are misstated - the FRC won’t comment on this.
 
I'll have a pint of what you're drinking.

The FRC isn't the "government getting involved". They're a body that regulate financial reporting and audit quality and you'd expect them to be interested in a scenario where an auditor has allegedly missed £830m of misreported revenue.

This is purely on BDO and nothing to do with City. Either we deliberately misled them and they did the best they could under the circumstances, or the quality of their audit work was below standard, or we and they haven't done anything wrong.

We might have been able to convince them that the sponsorships were kosher when we knew they weren't for example. But what happened with Fordham, where we paid £12-13m a year off our books? What did they ask and what did we tell them?

On the other hand, the auditors aren't there to make sure the accounts are correct, they are there to make sure they give a true and fair view. They may have looked at all the minor issues and decided they didn't affect the true and fair view.

The only one that would, of course, is the sponsorship funding and up until 2018 there is no way they would have even asked the question unless there was a direct payment from ADUG that was picked up. Two payments from Etihad wouldn't have raised alarm bells. Raised a few questions for management, maybe, but alarm bells no.

After 2018, I can't imagine they would have stayed as auditors without getting enough comfort on the source of funds. And the resignation of your auditors is a fatal sign - they had cards to play to get to the bottom of it. I said at the time, within five minutes the partner would have been calling Soriano asking for a meeting. The stakes were raised significantly after that. Still, no restated accounts, no change in audit opinion.

It doesn't look to me like a high-risk situation for club or auditors, quite frankly. Yet here we are.
 
Well the truth of this whole thing will have to come out at some point.

If we haven't done it, then the audit review will confirm what we all suspect - a vicious witch-hunt.

The audit review won't confirm anything about the verdict on City.

The audit review is to do with BDO.
 
Yes it really stands out. Despite all the protestations of no Government interference there is no doubt in my mind that someone higher up has said leave him out of this, which creates an unbelievable story that I’m sure will be mentioned on appeal.
Precisely! And 24 people lied. Errr, no.
 
The killer corrupt line in the PL panel's verdict is them absolving Sheikh Mansour of all complicity. Clear and obvious tailoring because they knew they dare not accuse him even though their verdict pointed the finger.
If Mansour rocks up to the appeal and says I 100 percent am aware of where the funds came from then what do the appeal panel do because it will show that at least part of the verdict is unsafe?
 
The FRC review will not help City.

They are not looking at whether our books are correct, they are looking at whether audit procedures were followed by the book.

In almost all of their reviews, they find that there were deficiencies in the audit and give the auditor a slap on the wrist. They will most likely do this in the BDO/ City case.

That is not to say audit deficiencies mean that the accounts are misstated - the FRC won’t comment on this.
Interesting. So you're basically saying that it's neither good or bad news for us?
 
Buster Flush ? Are you suggesting he's going to have to reinvent himself as some sort of ska tribute act? I can't believe he'll have to resort to that. Mind I would prefer The Bad Manners dining experience to an Abba one; cartwheeling bald blokes in dresses serving up the antipasti. It could perhaps provide some part time work for some of the FOCs on here, if their hips are up to it.
Am I the only one who likes both Bad Manners and ABBA? ;)
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top