PL charge City for alleged breaches of financial rules

Isn’t calling them a sham the same as calling them fraudulent?

Under section 17 of the Theft Act 1968, false accounting is committed where someone dishonestly falsifies an account, or uses an account they know is or may be materially false or misleading, with a view to GAIN or intent to cause loss. So if City knowingly recorded sponsorship revenue as genuinely coming from Etihad when, in substance, it knew the money was actually owner funding disguised as Etihad sponsorship, and did so dishonestly to obtain a regulatory advantage, that could potentially overlap with false accounting & possibly fraud by false representation.

So - in answer to your question - the answer is thus:

Yes, in substance.

Calling the sponsorship arrangements “sham” in the sense used by the Commission means alleging that the documented arrangements deliberately disguised the true reality. Coupled with findings that City misstated accounts & concealed matters from auditors/regulators, that's effectively an allegation of fraudulent or dishonest conduct. The only caveat is legal terminology: it's not the same as a criminal conviction for fraud.
 
Isn’t calling them a sham the same as calling them fraudulent?
The cynic in me believes that they used the term “sham” for maximum effect, knowing that it would incited legal action which would overturn the verdict after the most damage had been done to the club’s reputation.

This is why the panelists names are redacted, to shield them from legal action.
 
Treasury Devil James Eadie? Think Lord Pannick gave him a very difficult time a few years back. PL must be idiots to bring in someone who so frequently represents the UK Government especially given there football governance is a complete sham. Tossers.
Perhaps he's the man on the inside? Working for the Gov't to minimize any damage re ADG and their investments in the UK.
 
The cynic in me believes that they used the term “sham” for maximum effect, knowing that it would incited legal action which would overturn the verdict after the most damage had been done to the club’s reputation.

This is why the panelists names are redacted, to shield them from legal action.

It could be “I’m not putting my fucking name to that.”
 
Seems to be a lot of infighting going on.

I get both sides of this, some are desperately trying to shut down anything that could backfire on us when the appendices come out. There's also the feeling that it would be very surprising if the PL did have the capability to use a 3 person panel of KCs but chose not to do so, on their biggest ever case. Then ontop of that, claiming they have cogent evidence, enough to consider every City witness liars and the direct evidence provided fabrications and such, without actually having that. It would be shocking behaviour, if that's what happened and that's why some are holding off on committing to it.

I actually get that. I am concerned about what's in the appendices.

But I see the other side too, the club are being bombarded daily in the media, fans verbally abused, threatened in some cases... All while these perfectly reasonable questions remain unanswered. Would these rivals be accepting stick from City fans at this point? Would they fuck. They'd be claiming City had paid them off already, so would the press. So why are some on here being more hard on our own, than they are our rivals about this? Ease off on the paternalism, it's very grating to some.

It's not like they are not entitled to want those questions answered, it's not like we haven't already had leaks that all the PL had was yet more emails and called no witnesses on the core allegation. That might turn out to be bollocks but it didn't just come from a random city fan on twitter. We need to see more, now is not the time to give up.

I asked this earlier but didn't get an answer. Do KCs actually have the right experience to decide a case like this? I get they are most probably very experienced in prosecuting or defending a case irrespective (almost) of the facts, but wouldn't we all feel more comfortable if it was three current or retired judges who decide the case, and have been deciding cases like this for decades, as it will be at the appeal?

Can KCs just switch from a career of prosecuting / defending to judging at the drop of a hat and then back again? Genuine question, I don't know.
 
I asked this earlier but didn't get an answer. Do KCs actually have the right experience to decide a case like this? I get they are most probably very experienced in prosecuting or defending a case irrespective (almost) of the facts, but wouldn't we all feel more comfortable if it was three current or retired judges who decide the case, and have been deciding cases like this for decades, as it will be at the appeal?

Can KCs just switch from a career of prosecuting / defending to judging at the drop of a hat and then back again? Genuine question, I don't know.

KCs are perfectly legitimate adjudicators & many are highly experienced at it. But a tribunal chaired by an experienced former judge does give me somewhat greater confidence on the specifically judicial task of weighing competing evidence & deciding whether the extremely serious allegations against City have actually been proved.

And yes, they can switch hats between cases. That's normal in arbitration: the same senior lawyer may act as counsel in one dispute and as an arbitrator in another, provided there's no relevant conflict or appearance of bias.
 
KCs are perfectly legitimate adjudicators & many are highly experienced at it. But a tribunal chaired by an experienced former judge does give me somewhat greater confidence on the specifically judicial task of weighing competing evidence & deciding whether the extremely serious allegations against City have actually been proved.

And yes, they can switch hats between cases. That's normal in arbitration: the same senior lawyer may act as counsel in one dispute and as an arbitrator in another, provided there's no relevant conflict or appearance of bias.

Fair enough. Thanks for that.

I am just trying to find reasons why the panel seemingly found overwhelming reasons to believe the PL's circumstantial case over the club's documentary and witness evidence, other than that the club actually did what was alleged (which doesn't make sense to me) or that the panel is bent (which doesn't make much sense either, tbh).

I'll strike this one off the list. Or, at least, push it further down. One down, another twenty to go :)
 
A Parliamentary Select Committee has requested HMRC & FRC investigate City. If they come back saying they found nothing, then the spotlight will fall on the PL with everyone asking "Then what the fuck are you accusing City of?".

If this is the case, it kills the PL's witch hunt against us dead! It's not gone unnoticed that the PL have never used the word fraud against City. Why? Because the moment they do, the process would immediately move beyond the PL's control, into the jurisdiction of governmental statutory bodies. This is the last thing the PL want.
If nothing is found can that self same parliamentary committee request an investigation by HMRC and FRC into the cartels finances ? Asking for many friends
 
I’ve been reading through the boards over the last few weeks, and it’s obvious that the current atmosphere around the club is taking a massive toll on all of us. There is no denying that this is an incredibly stressful, frustrating, and exhausting period to be a City fan. We are all anxious, we are all on edge, and we are all feeling the weight of what's going on.
But because of that stress, I’ve noticed a lot of us are starting to turn on each other. Threads are turning into arguments, people are snapping at the slightest difference of opinion, and the general vibe here is becoming really hostile.
We need to take a step back and breathe.
Arguing amongst ourselves achieves absolutely nothing. The media and rival fans are already doing everything they can to tear us down; the very last thing we should be doing is helping them by tearing each other apart from the inside. This forum has always been a place for us to escape, share our passion, and support the team we love. It shouldn’t be a battlefield where we take out our external frustrations on fellow Blues.
We all cope with stress differently. Some want to vent, some want to remain optimistic, and some are preparing for the worst. All of those feelings are valid, but we have to respect each other's perspectives.
When the world is against City, the only thing that matters is how we stick together. Let’s bring back the camaraderie, show each other a bit of patience, and remember that we are all on the same side.
Keep the faith, calm the nerves, and let's stand strong together as one.
 
No. You could probably get AI to generate them for you though and they would probably end up being pretty close.
Not having visibility of the actual appendices, I can't see how you could use AI to effectively generate them, nor would you be in any way able to trust that they were credible or indeed "pretty close" to the real thing.
 
I think the panel address this in the verdict. The explicitly say the came to the conclusion they did not need to establish how or why the sponsors entered into the DFS, only that they did.

The reasoning for that is hidden in the appendices so it may be an avenue for appeal, but also isn't it kind of moot? Etihad having other options for funding doesn't matter if the evidence shown was enough to establish ADUG did fund them.

It all comes back to the central question - how did the PL establish that ADUG were the source of the money? They can't have had accounting or banking evidence in support of that position because they've no authority to get it from CPC or ADUG or Etihad. Emails surely would not be enough even in the face of modest accounting evidence to the contrary (CAS showed that) so WTF did they actually have?
I agree that the panel didn't necessarily need to establish how or why the sponsors participated in the alleged scheme. But paragraph 75 doesn't protect its conclusions about where the money actually came from.

The real issue is paragraph 77, where the panel explicitly rejected the CPC explanation as false and concocted after the event. That's a positive finding of fact, not simply a question the panel chose to leave unanswered.

If the CPC explanation is true, City has a potentially powerful basis for appeal. They could challenge the panel's factual findings, its assessment of the evidence, and the reasoning behind its rejection of the CPC explanation.

More importantly, paragraph 111 explicitly concludes that the £830m represented equity contributions paid by ADUG rather than commercial revenue paid by the sponsors. If City can establish that those funds actually originated from government assistance through the CPC, that directly challenges the foundation of the Disguised Funding Scheme finding, including the panel's alternative reasoning on economic substance.

Of course, City would need to demonstrate a material error in the panel's findings or satisfy the requirements for introducing fresh evidence. Simply arguing that the CPC explanation is more plausible wouldn't be enough.

But the crucial point is that paragraph 75 only allows the panel to leave the sponsors' motives unexplained. It doesn't insulate its findings about the source of the money from appeal.

Ultimately, everything depends on whether the panel had compelling independent evidence establishing ADUG as the source of the funds, or whether that conclusion relied heavily on dismissing the CPC explanation. Without the appendices, we simply cannot know.
 
I’ve been reading through the boards over the last few weeks, and it’s obvious that the current atmosphere around the club is taking a massive toll on all of us. There is no denying that this is an incredibly stressful, frustrating, and exhausting period to be a City fan. We are all anxious, we are all on edge, and we are all feeling the weight of what's going on.
But because of that stress, I’ve noticed a lot of us are starting to turn on each other. Threads are turning into arguments, people are snapping at the slightest difference of opinion, and the general vibe here is becoming really hostile.
We need to take a step back and breathe.
Arguing amongst ourselves achieves absolutely nothing. The media and rival fans are already doing everything they can to tear us down; the very last thing we should be doing is helping them by tearing each other apart from the inside. This forum has always been a place for us to escape, share our passion, and support the team we love. It shouldn’t be a battlefield where we take out our external frustrations on fellow Blues.
We all cope with stress differently. Some want to vent, some want to remain optimistic, and some are preparing for the worst. All of those feelings are valid, but we have to respect each other's perspectives.
When the world is against City, the only thing that matters is how we stick together. Let’s bring back the camaraderie, show each other a bit of patience, and remember that we are all on the same side.
Keep the faith, calm the nerves, and let's stand strong together as one.
Well said
 
I’ve been reading through the boards over the last few weeks, and it’s obvious that the current atmosphere around the club is taking a massive toll on all of us. There is no denying that this is an incredibly stressful, frustrating, and exhausting period to be a City fan. We are all anxious, we are all on edge, and we are all feeling the weight of what's going on.
But because of that stress, I’ve noticed a lot of us are starting to turn on each other. Threads are turning into arguments, people are snapping at the slightest difference of opinion, and the general vibe here is becoming really hostile.
We need to take a step back and breathe.
Arguing amongst ourselves achieves absolutely nothing. The media and rival fans are already doing everything they can to tear us down; the very last thing we should be doing is helping them by tearing each other apart from the inside. This forum has always been a place for us to escape, share our passion, and support the team we love. It shouldn’t be a battlefield where we take out our external frustrations on fellow Blues.
We all cope with stress differently. Some want to vent, some want to remain optimistic, and some are preparing for the worst. All of those feelings are valid, but we have to respect each other's perspectives.
When the world is against City, the only thing that matters is how we stick together. Let’s bring back the camaraderie, show each other a bit of patience, and remember that we are all on the same side.
Keep the faith, calm the nerves, and let's stand strong together as one.
Great post
 
I’ve been reading through the boards over the last few weeks, and it’s obvious that the current atmosphere around the club is taking a massive toll on all of us. There is no denying that this is an incredibly stressful, frustrating, and exhausting period to be a City fan. We are all anxious, we are all on edge, and we are all feeling the weight of what's going on.
But because of that stress, I’ve noticed a lot of us are starting to turn on each other. Threads are turning into arguments, people are snapping at the slightest difference of opinion, and the general vibe here is becoming really hostile.
We need to take a step back and breathe.
Arguing amongst ourselves achieves absolutely nothing. The media and rival fans are already doing everything they can to tear us down; the very last thing we should be doing is helping them by tearing each other apart from the inside. This forum has always been a place for us to escape, share our passion, and support the team we love. It shouldn’t be a battlefield where we take out our external frustrations on fellow Blues.
We all cope with stress differently. Some want to vent, some want to remain optimistic, and some are preparing for the worst. All of those feelings are valid, but we have to respect each other's perspectives.
When the world is against City, the only thing that matters is how we stick together. Let’s bring back the camaraderie, show each other a bit of patience, and remember that we are all on the same side.
Keep the faith, calm the nerves, and let's stand strong together as one.
Rag ;)
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top