- Joined
- 27 Jun 2007
- Messages
- 4,880
Isn’t calling them a sham the same as calling them fraudulent?
Under section 17 of the Theft Act 1968, false accounting is committed where someone dishonestly falsifies an account, or uses an account they know is or may be materially false or misleading, with a view to GAIN or intent to cause loss. So if City knowingly recorded sponsorship revenue as genuinely coming from Etihad when, in substance, it knew the money was actually owner funding disguised as Etihad sponsorship, and did so dishonestly to obtain a regulatory advantage, that could potentially overlap with false accounting & possibly fraud by false representation.
So - in answer to your question - the answer is thus:
Yes, in substance.
Calling the sponsorship arrangements “sham” in the sense used by the Commission means alleging that the documented arrangements deliberately disguised the true reality. Coupled with findings that City misstated accounts & concealed matters from auditors/regulators, that's effectively an allegation of fraudulent or dishonest conduct. The only caveat is legal terminology: it's not the same as a criminal conviction for fraud.