PL charge City for alleged breaches of financial rules

There will not always be news.

This is an unusual case. In 2020, CAS overturned the UEFA ruling wrt to Etihad Airways largely on the basis of Etihad's financial records and witness statements. That is not opinion, it is a finding of their arbitral award.

The Premier League re-opened the case. We wondered why, given the competence of CAS, but they have the power to do so. I think the actions of the Premier League in cutting Etihad out of their inquiry, when they knew of the significance of their evidence at CAS, and their centrality in the case, is irregular. It makes the verdict unsafe because the evidential record is limited, and it appears devious.

We know that Etihad Airways are taking legal counsel.

In my opinion, City have been very wary of this in-house case because of the experience of the UEFA case, and the fact that the UEFA case foundered, would leave you with the impression that the Premier League were going to learn from UEFA's "procedural mistakes". Knowing this, and that there was no CAS referral, City's priority must have been to demonstrate that the Premier League case was partisan. We have done that.
Always informative Marv. Enjoying the positive posts.
 
If we are to believe that the PL's case involves a conspiracy theory that payments were made from ADUG to ADG and then through Etihad to City, then we have a situation where an Industrial Tribunal, answerable to themselves, have accused the ADG, a nation state, of fraud.
This isn't accusing ADG companies of creative accounting around some Sponsorship contracts, this is on a whole higher level that is massively above the PL's pay grade!!
For this reason, I expect this to either be overturned on appeal or, very quickly moved on to the HC. Its fucking nuts!! Wars have started for less, FFS.
 
If we are to believe that the PL's case involves a conspiracy theory that payments were made from ADUG to ADG and then through Etihad to City, then we have a situation where an Industrial Tribunal, answerable to themselves, have accused the ADG, a nation state, of fraud.
This isn't accusing ADG companies of creative accounting around some Sponsorship contracts, this is on a whole higher level that is massively above the PL's pay grade!!
For this reason, I expect this to either be overturned on appeal or, very quickly moved on to the HC. Its fucking nuts!! Wars have started for less, FFS.
I know its unlikely but like would city have anticipated this because if they had of shown everything pl would also likely have appealed also.. like I know normal cases dont win on appeal or even in high court but this really doesnt feel like a normal case one of a generation
 
Well they say:

i) Charge 1(A)
110) Each of the AD Sponsorship Agreements was a sham:Appendix 20.
111) If we are wrong to reach that conclusion, then the economic substance of each ADSponsorship Agreement differed from the legal form of the relevant AD Sponsorship Agreement in that the Tagged Sum element of the Recorded Sponsorship Fee was an equity contribution payable and paid by ADUG not commercial revenue payable and paid by theAD Sponsor: Appendices 15 and 24.
112) Either way the Club’s financial statements in each of the seasons to which Charge 1(A)relatesa) Very substantially overstated the Club’s revenue, andb) Did not provide a true and fair view of the Club’s financial position:

ii) Charge 1(B):
116) The agreements underlying the were a sham: Appendix 20.
117) If we are wrong on that, then the economic substance of such agreements and theas a whole differed from the legal form of those agreements, in that theliability recorded therein was a liability of the Club (1) which was the Club’s obligation topay, and (2) which ADUG paid on its behalf: Appendices 16 and 24.
118) Either way the Club’s financial statements in each of the four seasons to which this limbof Charge 1(B) relatesa) Ought to have recognised the sums payable under the as anexpense of the Club (but did not), andb) Did not provide a true and fair view of the Club’s financial position: Appendices 23and 24.


:) You know perfectly well that @the talisman was referring to the sponsorship funding, not just the issue of sham contracts. Lay people, not surprisingly, conflate the shamness (shamity?) issue with the sponsorship funding issue but, as I see it, this is the situation:

- Shamness disproved, still in trouble over the funding.

- Funding disproved, all our problems disappear, on the sponsorship anyway.

They can structure paragraphs 110-112 as cleverly and as lawerly as they want, but that holds true regardless. Which is why I don't understand why they went down the sham path - assuming they are right about the funding, which I still find incredible, they didn't have to go down the sham route to find the rule breaches proven to the standard required. It has opened up a can of worms that they had better left closed, imho.

By the way, the first "limb" of 1B relates to Mancini, so paragraphs 116-118 are nothing to do with sponsorship.

Edit: Fuckity fuck. Messed up, just a minute ... Fixed now :)
 
Last edited:
It's just the way of the world today. Nobody has got any patience, nobody has got a concentration span, nobody can bear to wait for something anymore because everything is now now now in this fast paced multi media world we live in. Everything comes at you 24/7 the current local and world news is fed into our front rooms on multi TV channels. Sports news on 24/7 news channels, podcasts, YouTube, tik tok, Instagram, X, FB, influencers and on it goes. Turn the radio on for some respite and there's now more channels than ever to discuss, yes you've guessed it politics and sport.

Then there's the adverts everywhere pushing the next latest shiny thing whether it be food, fashion, jewellery, holidays, media personalities etc. The narrative for everything is immediate and now and everyone has to be invested in it to discuss it like the latest TV reality programme with 15m viewers and all the spin offs because we just can't get enough now. Music is a perfect example where the average length of a song is getting less and less due to streaming companies like Spotify wanting shorter songs for more play and people don't have a concentration span to get past the first 30 seconds before hitting next.

We all need to chill and go and read a book, go for a walk in nature and let the release valve depressurise and not worry about shit we have no control over. Concentrate on a siege mentality and fuck em all and what will be will be.
You missed one very annoying item in the TV media - wall to wall adverts for funeral and / or life insurance. Weekday TV in NZ can have three different companies advertising in each break - and channel hoping doesn't work - same ads on the other channels. Think they are trying to give us all heart attacks as we get so annoyed with bombardment. Unfortunately, prime time TV reverts to other mind-boggling childish ads - at least a bit of respite.
 
I am really concerned where this seems to be heading, i thought there would have been some offramp that either side could use, however the seems no will on either side. I am very surprised with the PL, they seem hellbent on destroying us as a club. I dont believe they want us anywhere near the PL ever again.

100% mate. The PL has played us off the park so far in their roles as accuser and commission. Not holding out much hope for the PL appeal panel to change their commission's opinion - we're simply not welcome and the money-grabbing yank bastards will continue to litigate / legislate until we're gone.
 
There will not always be news.

This is an unusual case. In 2020, CAS overturned the UEFA ruling wrt to Etihad Airways largely on the basis of Etihad's financial records and witness statements. That is not opinion, it is a finding of their arbitral award.

The Premier League re-opened the case. We wondered why, given the competence of CAS, but they have the power to do so. I think the actions of the Premier League in cutting Etihad out of their inquiry, when they knew of the significance of their evidence at CAS, and their centrality in the case, is irregular. It makes the verdict unsafe because the evidential record is limited, and it appears devious.

We know that Etihad Airways are taking legal counsel.

In my opinion, City have been very wary of this in-house case because of the experience of the UEFA case, and the fact that the UEFA case foundered, would leave you with the impression that the Premier League were going to learn from UEFA's "procedural mistakes". Knowing this, and that there was no CAS referral, City's priority must have been to demonstrate that the Premier League case was partisan. We have done that.
'... Manchester City FC will now pursue the appeal avenues open to it, on the basis that the opinion contains clear material errors, of law, principle and fact, and is unsafe.

The Club has diligently respected due process for eight years on the basis that the Premier League Board and Executive would behave as an independent, impartial and fair-minded regulator, free from partisan influence ... '

Even though this is a City site, we have to ask the question why a lot of those who claim to be legal bods on here scoff at or just completely ignore a part of what is City's legal defence. We know why it's blatantly so in the mainstrem media, but it's a dereliction of duty for that to be the case on here. Some of it can be explained by the brainwashing of how the mainstream narrative has been framed, but a significant part of it is because some on here are deliberately trying to veer us away from the City statement.

As Marvin says, the evidential record is limited. A limited evidential record makes the tribunal's decision unsafe. Why is the evidential record limited? It's twofold: 1) the tribunal deliberately limited it; 2) City were wary of what evidence to produce. Why did the tribunal limit the evidence? Because they didn't want a decision based on best evidence. If that is the case, it is not fair-minded. Why wouldn't the tribunal be fair-minded? After all, they're supposed to be an arbitration panel under the auspices of the Arbitration Act. This is the $64,000 question. We need to take a look at how the tribunal was assembled, who the Chair and panel were, and if they sat in accordance with the Arbitration Act. As I've argued from the outset, if the PL appointed the tribunal Chair, then the tribunal is compromised at birth. It's the old Rousseau chestnut of having blind faith in a grand legislator. As we saw in the French Revolution and see with the partisanship involved in US Supreme Court appointments, they don't grow on trees. That the PL also pay the Chair's wages and that future appointments are bound by the same contract are grounds for saying they are dependent, whether factually or potentially, and therefore cannot be independent. Who did the PL appoint? They appointed Murray Rosen. For the same reasons as just cited, as an Arsenal season ticket holder, so that the potential for doubt can be minimised, he should not have been appointed, granted Lord Pannick is also an avid Arsenal supporter. That he was appointed, in the name of integrity, he should have recused himself. That he didn't is a stain on his name and cause for doubting everything that follows, particularly as the names of the 3 person tribunal he was tasked with appointing continue to be redacted. What does the Arbitration Act say?

'Introductory

1 General principles.
The provisions of this Part are founded on the following principles, and shall be construed accordingly—
(a)the object of arbitration is to obtain the fair resolution of disputes by an impartial tribunal without unnecessary delay or expense;

(b)the parties should be free to agree how their disputes are resolved, subject only to such safeguards as are necessary in the public interest;

(c)in matters governed by this Part the court should not intervene except as provided by this Part.'

Has the PL tribunal complied with the above principles? Did it withold the judgment? Did it inform the parties of the judgment at the same time? Did the PL leak, or facilitate the leak of the judgment?

The bottom line is, the PL - and UEFA - have maliciously tried to stop City at every turn and hunted us down for every misdemeanour while turnning a blind eye to wrongdoing by other clubs. City and Everton have been punished, but United and Liverpool haven't. The evidence is clear there is discrimination and undue influence in a league the rulebook of which states all the clubs have equal status, and this is a significant part of City's legal defence, and which I fully back above all the discussion of who funded who and whether it was within the rules. The rules are malicious, and that some people claiming to be City fans fail to see them for what they are and are not willing to fight City's corner on this makes me wonder whether in fact they are City fans. As Marvin says, the dodging of the Etihad evidence by the tribunal is devious. It was meant to be an arbitration, not a prosecution. City were not only up against the PL, they were also up against the tribunal, and is why they were wary with which evidence was produced. The question that now needs to be asked is, 'Are the appeal judges going to support the behaviour of the tribunal?'
 
Last edited:
'... Manchester City FC will now pursue the appeal avenues open to it, on the basis that the opinion contains clear material errors, of law, principle and fact, and is unsafe.

The Club has diligently respected due process for eight years on the basis that the Premier League Board and Executive would behave as an independent, impartial and fair-minded regulator, free from partisan influence ... '

Even though this is a City site, we have to ask the question why a lot of those who claim to be legal bods on here scoff at or just completely ignore a part of what is City's legal defence. We know why it's blatantly so in the mainstrem media, but it's a dereliction of duty for that to be the case on here. Some of it can be explained by the brainwashing of how the mainstream narrative has been framed, but a significant part of it is because some on here are deliberately trying to veer us away from the City statement.

As Marvin says, the evidential record is limited. A limited evidential record makes the tribunal's decision unsafe. Why is the evidential record limited? It's twofold: 1) the tribunal deliberately limited it; 2) City were wary of what evidence to produce. Why did the tribunal limit the evidence? Because they didn't want a decision based on best evidence. If that is the case, it is not fair-minded. Why wouldn't the tribunal be fair-minded? After all, they're supposed to be an arbitration panel under the auspices of the Arbitration Act. This is the $64,000 question. We need to take a look at how the tribunal was assembled, who the Chair and panel were, and if they sat in accordance with the Arbitration Act. As I've argued from the outset, if the PL appointed the tribunal Chair, then the tribunal is compromised at birth. It's the old Rousseau chestnut of having blind faith in a grand legislator. As we saw in the French Revolution and see with the partisanship involved in US Supreme Court appointments, they don't grow on trees. That the PL also pay the Chair's wages and that future appointments are bound by the same contract are grounds for saying they are dependent, whether factually or potentially, and therefore cannot be independent. Who did the PL appoint? They appointed Murray Rosen. For the same reasons as just cited, as an Arsenal season ticket holder, so that the potential for doubt can be minimised, he should not have been appointed, granted Lord Pannick is also an avid Arsenal supporter. That he was appointed, in the name of integrity, he should have recused himself. That he didn't is a stain on his name and cause for doubting everything that follows, particularly as the names of the 3 person tribunal he is tasked with appointing continue to be redacted. What does the Arbitration Act say?

'Introductory

1 General principles.
The provisions of this Part are founded on the following principles, and shall be construed accordingly—
(a)the object of arbitration is to obtain the fair resolution of disputes by an impartial tribunal without unnecessary delay or expense;

(b)the parties should be free to agree how their disputes are resolved, subject only to such safeguards as are necessary in the public interest;

(c)in matters governed by this Part the court should not intervene except as provided by this Part.'

Has the PL tribunal complied with the above principles? Did it withold the judgment? Did it inform the parties of the judgment at the same time? Did the PL leak, or facilitate the leak of the judgment?

The bottom line is, the PL - and UEFA - have maliciously tried to stop City at every corner and hunted us down for every misdemeanour while turnning a blind eye to wrongdoing by other clubs. City and Everton have been punished, but United and Liverpool haven't. The evidence is clear there is discrimination and undue influence in a league the rulebook of which states all the clubs have equal status, and this is a significant part of City's legal defence, and which I fully back above all the discussion of who funded who and whether it was within the rules. The rules are malicious, and that some people claiming to be City fans fail to see them for what they are and are not willing to fight City's corner on this makes me wonder whether in fact they are City fans. As Marvin says, the dodging of the Etihad evidence by the tribunal is devious. It was meant to be an arbitration, not a prosecution. City were not only up against the PL, they were also up against the tribunal, and is why they were wary with which evidence was produced. The question that now needs to be asked is, 'Are the appeal judges going to support the behaviour of the tribunal?'
Brilliant assessment, needs to go onto mainstream media streams.
 
'... Manchester City FC will now pursue the appeal avenues open to it, on the basis that the opinion contains clear material errors, of law, principle and fact, and is unsafe.

The Club has diligently respected due process for eight years on the basis that the Premier League Board and Executive would behave as an independent, impartial and fair-minded regulator, free from partisan influence ... '

Even though this is a City site, we have to ask the question why a lot of those who claim to be legal bods on here scoff at or just completely ignore a part of what is City's legal defence. We know why it's blatantly so in the mainstrem media, but it's a dereliction of duty for that to be the case on here. Some of it can be explained by the brainwashing of how the mainstream narrative has been framed, but a significant part of it is because some on here are deliberately trying to veer us away from the City statement.

As Marvin says, the evidential record is limited. A limited evidential record makes the tribunal's decision unsafe. Why is the evidential record limited? It's twofold: 1) the tribunal deliberately limited it; 2) City were wary of what evidence to produce. Why did the tribunal limit the evidence? Because they didn't want a decision based on best evidence. If that is the case, it is not fair-minded. Why wouldn't the tribunal be fair-minded? After all, they're supposed to be an arbitration panel under the auspices of the Arbitration Act. This is the $64,000 question. We need to take a look at how the tribunal was assembled, who the Chair and panel were, and if they sat in accordance with the Arbitration Act. As I've argued from the outset, if the PL appointed the tribunal Chair, then the tribunal is compromised at birth. It's the old Rousseau chestnut of having blind faith in a grand legislator. As we saw in the French Revolution and see with the partisanship involved in US Supreme Court appointments, they don't grow on trees. That the PL also pay the Chair's wages and that future appointments are bound by the same contract are grounds for saying they are dependent, whether factually or potentially, and therefore cannot be independent. Who did the PL appoint? They appointed Murray Rosen. For the same reasons as just cited, as an Arsenal season ticket holder, so that the potential for doubt can be minimised, he should not have been appointed, granted Lord Pannick is also an avid Arsenal supporter. That he was appointed, in the name of integrity, he should have recused himself. That he didn't is a stain on his name and cause for doubting everything that follows, particularly as the names of the 3 person tribunal he is tasked with appointing continue to be redacted. What does the Arbitration Act say?

'Introductory

1 General principles.
The provisions of this Part are founded on the following principles, and shall be construed accordingly—
(a)the object of arbitration is to obtain the fair resolution of disputes by an impartial tribunal without unnecessary delay or expense;

(b)the parties should be free to agree how their disputes are resolved, subject only to such safeguards as are necessary in the public interest;

(c)in matters governed by this Part the court should not intervene except as provided by this Part.'

Has the PL tribunal complied with the above principles? Did it withold the judgment? Did it inform the parties of the judgment at the same time? Did the PL leak, or facilitate the leak of the judgment?

The bottom line is, the PL - and UEFA - have maliciously tried to stop City at every corner and hunted us down for every misdemeanour while turnning a blind eye to wrongdoing by other clubs. City and Everton have been punished, but United and Liverpool haven't. The evidence is clear there is discrimination and undue influence in a league the rulebook of which states all the clubs have equal status, and this is a significant part of City's legal defence, and which I fully back above all the discussion of who funded who and whether it was within the rules. The rules are malicious, and that some people claiming to be City fans fail to see them for what they are and are not willing to fight City's corner on this makes me wonder whether in fact they are City fans. As Marvin says, the dodging of the Etihad evidence by the tribunal is devious. It was meant to be an arbitration, not a prosecution. City were not only up against the PL, they were also up against the tribunal, and is why they were wary with which evidence was produced. The question that now needs to be asked is, 'Are the appeal judges going to support the behaviour of the tribunal?'

1792907066059.gif
 
If we are to believe that the PL's case involves a conspiracy theory that payments were made from ADUG to ADG and then through Etihad to City, then we have a situation where an Industrial Tribunal, answerable to themselves, have accused the ADG, a nation state, of fraud.
This isn't accusing ADG companies of creative accounting around some Sponsorship contracts, this is on a whole higher level that is massively above the PL's pay grade!!
For this reason, I expect this to either be overturned on appeal or, very quickly moved on to the HC. Its fucking nuts!! Wars have started for less, FFS.

There we go. That's more like it. Good man. The whole scenario is preposterous.
 
'... Manchester City FC will now pursue the appeal avenues open to it, on the basis that the opinion contains clear material errors, of law, principle and fact, and is unsafe.

The Club has diligently respected due process for eight years on the basis that the Premier League Board and Executive would behave as an independent, impartial and fair-minded regulator, free from partisan influence ... '

Even though this is a City site, we have to ask the question why a lot of those who claim to be legal bods on here scoff at or just completely ignore a part of what is City's legal defence. We know why it's blatantly so in the mainstrem media, but it's a dereliction of duty for that to be the case on here. Some of it can be explained by the brainwashing of how the mainstream narrative has been framed, but a significant part of it is because some on here are deliberately trying to veer us away from the City statement.

As Marvin says, the evidential record is limited. A limited evidential record makes the tribunal's decision unsafe. Why is the evidential record limited? It's twofold: 1) the tribunal deliberately limited it; 2) City were wary of what evidence to produce. Why did the tribunal limit the evidence? Because they didn't want a decision based on best evidence. If that is the case, it is not fair-minded. Why wouldn't the tribunal be fair-minded? After all, they're supposed to be an arbitration panel under the auspices of the Arbitration Act. This is the $64,000 question. We need to take a look at how the tribunal was assembled, who the Chair and panel were, and if they sat in accordance with the Arbitration Act. As I've argued from the outset, if the PL appointed the tribunal Chair, then the tribunal is compromised at birth. It's the old Rousseau chestnut of having blind faith in a grand legislator. As we saw in the French Revolution and see with the partisanship involved in US Supreme Court appointments, they don't grow on trees. That the PL also pay the Chair's wages and that future appointments are bound by the same contract are grounds for saying they are dependent, whether factually or potentially, and therefore cannot be independent. Who did the PL appoint? They appointed Murray Rosen. For the same reasons as just cited, as an Arsenal season ticket holder, so that the potential for doubt can be minimised, he should not have been appointed, granted Lord Pannick is also an avid Arsenal supporter. That he was appointed, in the name of integrity, he should have recused himself. That he didn't is a stain on his name and cause for doubting everything that follows, particularly as the names of the 3 person tribunal he is tasked with appointing continue to be redacted. What does the Arbitration Act say?

'Introductory

1 General principles.
The provisions of this Part are founded on the following principles, and shall be construed accordingly—
(a)the object of arbitration is to obtain the fair resolution of disputes by an impartial tribunal without unnecessary delay or expense;

(b)the parties should be free to agree how their disputes are resolved, subject only to such safeguards as are necessary in the public interest;

(c)in matters governed by this Part the court should not intervene except as provided by this Part.'

Has the PL tribunal complied with the above principles? Did it withold the judgment? Did it inform the parties of the judgment at the same time? Did the PL leak, or facilitate the leak of the judgment?

The bottom line is, the PL - and UEFA - have maliciously tried to stop City at every corner and hunted us down for every misdemeanour while turnning a blind eye to wrongdoing by other clubs. City and Everton have been punished, but United and Liverpool haven't. The evidence is clear there is discrimination and undue influence in a league the rulebook of which states all the clubs have equal status, and this is a significant part of City's legal defence, and which I fully back above all the discussion of who funded who and whether it was within the rules. The rules are malicious, and that some people claiming to be City fans fail to see them for what they are and are not willing to fight City's corner on this makes me wonder whether in fact they are City fans. As Marvin says, the dodging of the Etihad evidence by the tribunal is devious. It was meant to be an arbitration, not a prosecution. City were not only up against the PL, they were also up against the tribunal, and is why they were wary with which evidence was produced. The question that now needs to be asked is, 'Are the appeal judges going to support the behaviour of the tribunal?'
Great post. This goes to the core of what I can't my head around... something else at play here which is deeply unfair / unsafe(our new word)/ bias etc.. We are a long standing, champion member of the PL. We have brought great viewing, wealth and interest into the "brand/product" of the Premier League. I can't understand why the PL would want to humiliate, harass and witch hunt one club only for 15 fucking years! - the club that has been the flagship for its own success over those last 15 years. Because let's get one thing straight, no other team has excited the global audience like we have. Rules broken, stretched, got around - maybe, maybe not, there's a self destruction risk to the league itself here. Arsenal are boring as piss, United are a joke, Spurs even worse, Chelsea a car crash and Liverpool blow hot and cold. The PL owe us 100 years of gratitude for keeping their beloved brand at the top of the global football tree. This is the thanks we get.
 
Last edited:
At last after a Tsunami of opinions a balanced intelligent analysis in a clear and defined review, if I had a hat would take it off to you.
My clumsy belief is that we are fighting a corrupt elite with an unhealthy influence within and over the Premier League. Our end game must be the High Court free from bias and self interest and the flimsy house of cards of the Premier League and cartel will fall apart
 
How can you be certain that the Premier League didn't obtain evidence that CAS never had access to?
You are right, I can't ,but neither can you be sure that they have more evidence. We don't know. One thing is for sure with their verdict coming out and quite a bit of it being redacted, they question is what don't they want to reveal.
 
Great post. This goes to the core of what I can't my head around... something else at play here which is deeply unfair / unsafe(our new word)/ bias etc.. We are a long standing, champion member of the PL. We have brought great viewing, wealth and interest into the "brand/product" of the Premier League. I can't understand why the PL would want to humiliate, harass and witch hunt one club only for 15 fucking years! - the club that has been the flagship for its own success over those last 15 years. Because let's get one thing straight, no other team has excited the global audience like we have. Rules broken, stretched, got around - maybe, maybe not, there's a self destruction risk to the league itself here. Arsenal are boring as piss, United are a joke, Spurs even worse, Chelsea a car crash and Liverpool blow hot and cold. The PL owe us 100 years of gratitude for keeping their beloved brand at the top of the global football tree. This is the thanks we get.
Good post and very true.
 
Not been on this thread for a couple of days but I've seen some posters remarking that they feel some people on here are not actual blues and are deliberately winding people up.

Just a reminder to contact the mods if you have any concerns and we'll check out the posters. Thanks
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top