Managers make the best pundits because they know what they’re talking about and have far more interesting insight into tactics than ex-player pundits can ever get near. Every football game should have at least one manager in the studio.
What I always notice from managers is their acceptance and forgiveness of players making mistakes as just part of the game and have and will always happen. They understand that players are humans and not robots and there will always be mistakes from everyone, including the best players. From this, they seem to instead want to concentrate on good play and tactics or defending that created the situation to force the mistakes. Whereäs, I find ex-player pundits very much labour on player mistakes and go over them too much. Doing this, they often skate over the good play or even dismiss it, saying, ‘you can’t make mistakes at this level like that no matter how good that move was’… which is both naïve and silly.
Having intelligent pundits also makes a difference. People who can string a coherent sentence together and can articulate their points properly. Instead of morons who speak infant English… usually ‘ffick as fack’ Cockneys who can’t fucking talk properly at all (I miss our old chant, ‘if you can’t talk proper shut your mouth’).
However, there are exceptions to the rule and some ex-players can make good pundits, but they rarely seem to make PL coverage. Keith Andrews (obviously now a manager) was always class on Sky’s EFL games, proper knows his football that lad. Another ex-player who’s always been a good pundit on there is Jobi McAnuff.