PL charge City for alleged breaches of financial rules

IF City have any NEW evidence that was not available at the original hearing then that evidence would be admissable and it would not be that difficult to argue that it should be allowed.

THAT is all I am saying and I don't understand what part of that you're struggling with.

Etihad said they had "not been contacted or asked to provide evidence by the PL". This has been going on for several years so that does not necessarily mean that they would have been available at the time thery were contacted. But the fact that the evidence wasn't available to the panel at the original hearing means it's new evidence. If they weren't called then it can be argued that it wasn't available for the panel to consider because the panel didn't ask for it (you can argue all night about whether the panel or City should have called Etihad before you get started on that one, but the point remains that by not hearing any evidence from Etihad the panel did not consider all the facts).

The rest is futile. Twisting and turning it to suit your argument acheives nothing. You're just basing your argument on the basis that because they "may" have been available, it would be rejected but I would suggest that's a very weak argument for dismissing vital evidence.

Aside from that, we don't know if any statement or evidence by Etihad would be substantial enough to make any difference in any event. As I keep saying, we're just guessing.
Under certain limited circumstances, additional evidence could be considered.

Ethiad's statement talks about the PL. It doesn't talk about whether or not City sought to have Ethiad provide evidence. If it did not, then we're going to have a really hard time getting new evidence considered on Appeal, for example. There will be other arguments to keep that evidence out - and the presumption is in favor of NOT allowing it before an appellate panel. It's not a slam dunk, which is what most of the lawyers here have been trying to explain for weeks.
 
City could have called Etihad. We did not. Whoever made that decision deserves the Manchester City medal of honour. We are alive now, because of that call.

In fact, any reasonable person will either be in a state of non-belief, or shock, that the PL inquiry can have "found" that Etihad and MCFC conspired together in a sham sponsorship without having called for evidence from "Etihad Airways". Then consider that the Court for Arbitration of Sport overthrew the UEFA verdict of disguised funding after studying evidence from Etihad Airways and Manchester City. Serious questions will be asked of the PL at the High Court.

That is where we are heading. I have read the CAS arbitral award, and the verdict statement, and I judge that City are facing the most serious allegations, but that the Premier League have over reached themselves in producing this verdict. The lawyers claimed that the PL would face a very difficult evidential and legal bar in proving fraud. Their solution appears to have been to restrict the admitted evidential record.

We will likely move now from a limited examination of the evidence, to an examination of the process. The PL appeal body is going to have to consider whether they stand by that process. Is it going to stand up to scrutiny at the High Court? I doubt it.
If that's true, then the evidence was available, and I would be very surprised if an appellate panel hears new evidence from Ethiad. It would wouldn't be medal of honor worthy. It would be a gaffe of the highest regard. Worse than Nunes in the Derby a couple of years ago.
 
Well, my moon is always half full. I think Stefan does a good job of explaining, from a technical and legal perspective, just how difficult it will be for City to be completely cleared of all charges. I 100% agree with that. However, I see more potential avenues for City to introduce fresh evidence during the appeal, and I also believe that Etihad, if they are genuinely prepared to take the PL to the High Court, has a better chance of getting the court to examine the underlying allegations of fraud.
I think Etihad Airways have more than 1 legal avenue open to them.
 
If that's true, then the evidence was available, and I would be very surprised if an appellate panel hears new evidence from Ethiad. It would wouldn't be medal of honor worthy. It would be a gaffe of the highest regard. Worse than Nunes in the Derby a couple of years ago.
Not if the commission was in a mood to describe it as concocted or dishonest. Etihad have a free hand now to go to the High Court on the basis of an irregularity in process. Our only way out in this process was to find an independent court. CAS was available in the UEFA case. It is not available in this case, hence we had to use the bias of the PL against them. You consider it a gaffe. Well then I have to ask you why we didn't make the obvious move.

You can think what you like about the strategy but the fact remains that an Etihad action at the High Court is our nuclear weapon. Let us hope it is viable.
 
Here’s what I think happened -

City knew they couldn’t get Mansour to directly fund the sponsors.

They did it via government accounts instead - which was probably against the spirit of the rules but technically legal.

Due to Mansour’s high level government position, the PL basically consider it as Mansour funding the sponsors - via the government.

City financial staff were blasé about the source of funding and lazily called it ADUG on emails and spreadsheets - despite it being technically from the government. This was also early days in terms of the FFP rules so wording wasn’t quite as tight.

Staff at some point (after the leak…) were told to remove the ADUG references as they may cause confusion about the source of funding.

City argue that in accordance with the rules, it’s fine for the money to come from these government accounts. The PL think City have just fudged it.

I'd gladly put money on this being more or less the truth. Explains how the club can be bullish on irrefutable evidence (You have bank statements showing money from ADG/CPC > Etihad > City, and 24 people to testify as such, which is all true), and it explains how the commission can still find against us for pretty much all of it because there is a comprehensive email trail explaining more or less how it all worked.

And if this is true, the sort of sanctions that are being spoken of are even more laughable. At the end of the day it's still a bloke putting his own money into his own business. It's not the greatest sporting scandal in history.
 
And what do the financial records of Etihad and Manchester City show? Financial experts from UEFA, Manchester City and Etihad Airways presented evidence to CAS, and they took statements from City officials and very senior executives from Etihad, including its President, and from Sheikh Mansour. CAS concluded that there was no doubt that Etihad met their obligations to MCFC in full. The PL knows full well this evidential record exists but they ignored it. They will have to live, die or settle on the basis of what appears to be a breach in procedure.

They didn’t ignore it, it is referenced in the judgment. The IC just found very differently to CAS and as a consequence are essentially saying they believe those witnesses perjured themselves at CAS, at least some of them.
 
Stefan trusts both our owners -- which we all do -- and the process.

It seems like he trusts the process more, and through that lens, his change in tone makes absolute sense.
What about the process of the American Red Cartel desperately trying to stop Manchester City FC competing for over 14 years with rules unfit for purpose and solely designed to protect the American owned cartel clubs . An “illegal “ protection racket headed by Richard Masters . The PL isn’t a viable fair competition or business model it is a gangster protection racket and it needs exposing for what is . It is no wonder the UK media is doing everything in its power to “protect “ the shambolic “illegal “ system the PL has and currently operates under the full protection of Richard Masters and his New York security service.
Someone somewhere needs to blow this wide open and bring the lot down !
Maybe our owners have threatened to do this and here we are ?

CTID
 
I think Etihad Airways have more than 1 legal avenue open to them.
Yes, Etihad has several potential legal avenues open to them, not just defamation. Malicious falsehood is particularly interesting, but unlawful means conspiracy and unlawful interference with business could also be explored.

The key point is that some of these claims could potentially bring the Commission's sham findings before the High Court for independent scrutiny. As a third party, Etihad may have options that City itself doesn't.
 
Not if the commission was in a mood to describe it as concocted or dishonest. Etihad have a free hand now to go to the High Court on the basis of an irregularity in process. Our only way out in this process was to find an independent court. CAS was available in the UEFA case. It is not available in this case, hence we had to use the bias of the PL against them. You consider it a gaffe. Well then I have to ask you why we didn't make the obvious move.

You can think what you like about the strategy but the fact remains that an Etihad action at the High Court is our nuclear weapon. Let us hope it is viable.
How the panel would take the evidence does not effect it's availability.

Why didn't we make the obvious move? My guess is that we did present "Ethiad" evidence in line with what we produced at UEFA and CAS. People like Pearce who were Ethiad employees at the time of the transactions/e-mails in question and the documents from that time, which had been sufficient in the past. So we did make the obvious move. As to additional evidence from Ethiad, we may well have asked and Ethiad declined -- for any number of reasons - timing, confidentiality, governing law in the UAE. No one expected the panel to go as far as they did in smearing Ethiad along with City. (That might be the opening we need, FWIW, but that's complete speculation.)

Ethiad can certainly take a case to the High Court or wherever else, but it won't be "irregularity in process" Ethiad isn't a PL member. They aren't a party to the agreements that are governing the dispute between the PL and City. There's no "process" that the PL is obligated to follow as to Ethiad.
 
I thought a law had been brought in that English Clubs are not allowed to join any sort of break away leagues ? I may be wrong but I`m almost certain it was brought in a little while after the supposed Super League fiasco ?

Not sure mate, but if we are innocent I'd like the club to go for the jugular after dealing with all this shit. I imagine there'll be another wave of toxicity after our appeal most likely goes nowhere and we ultimately take it higher.

If that means seeking compensation off the league and certain clubs so be it. Hopefully Etihad and the other sponsors do likewise. Whether there's much of a league left to break away from then is anybody's guess.
 
Yes, Etihad has several potential legal avenues open to them, not just defamation. Malicious falsehood is particularly interesting, but unlawful means conspiracy and unlawful interference with business could also be explored.

The key point is that some of these claims could potentially bring the Commission's sham findings before the High Court for independent scrutiny. As a third party, Etihad may have options that City itself doesn't.
The claims they are going to bring are going to depend on what jurisdiction they'd bring the claim in. I'm skeptical that there is actually an impending IPO, but that might cause them to bring suit in the States. It's a pretty high bar, but I think NY (which I think -- 2/3 chance -- would have jurisdiction at least before a forum non conveniens motion) recognizes corporate defamation.
 
What about the process of the American Red Cartel desperately trying to stop Manchester City FC competing for over 14 years with rules unfit for purpose and solely designed to protect the American owned cartel clubs . An “illegal “ protection racket headed by Richard Masters . The PL isn’t a viable fair competition or business model it is a gangster protection racket and it needs exposing for what is . It is no wonder the UK media is doing everything in its power to “protect “ the shambolic “illegal “ system the PL has and currently operates under the full protection of Richard Masters and his New York security service.
Someone somewhere needs to blow this wide open and bring the lot down !
Maybe our owners have threatened to do this and here we are ?

CTID
I'm not the guy to argue against you. I've been lawyering for over 25 years, and I don't have a ton of faith in judicial process thanks to that experience. A quasi-judicial process like this, where a business running the process side of things is also the charging party? I mean, you have to play their game, but it's not due as much deference, in my experience, as Stefan is imputing upon it. And maybe that was City's mistake. Counting on fairness from this process.
 
City could have called Etihad. We did not. Whoever made that decision deserves the Manchester City medal of honour. We are alive now, because of that call.

In fact, any reasonable person will either be in a state of non-belief, or shock, that the PL inquiry can have "found" that Etihad and MCFC conspired together in a sham sponsorship without having called for evidence from "Etihad Airways". Then consider that the Court for Arbitration of Sport overthrew the UEFA verdict of disguised funding after studying evidence from Etihad Airways and Manchester City. Serious questions will be asked of the PL at the High Court.

That is where we are heading. I have read the CAS arbitral award, and the verdict statement, and I judge that City are facing the most serious allegations, but that the Premier League have over reached themselves in producing this verdict. The lawyers claimed that the PL would face a very difficult evidential and legal bar in proving fraud. Their solution appears to have been to restrict the admitted evidential record.

We will likely move now from a limited examination of the evidence, to an examination of the process. The PL appeal body is going to have to consider whether they stand by that process. Is it going to stand up to scrutiny at the High Court? I doubt it.
Yep, are the 3 judges going to want to add their names to what appear to be a lot of shortcomings and the defamations?
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top