- Joined
- 16 Jun 2021
- Messages
- 550
- Team supported
- Manchester City
Under certain limited circumstances, additional evidence could be considered.IF City have any NEW evidence that was not available at the original hearing then that evidence would be admissable and it would not be that difficult to argue that it should be allowed.
THAT is all I am saying and I don't understand what part of that you're struggling with.
Etihad said they had "not been contacted or asked to provide evidence by the PL". This has been going on for several years so that does not necessarily mean that they would have been available at the time thery were contacted. But the fact that the evidence wasn't available to the panel at the original hearing means it's new evidence. If they weren't called then it can be argued that it wasn't available for the panel to consider because the panel didn't ask for it (you can argue all night about whether the panel or City should have called Etihad before you get started on that one, but the point remains that by not hearing any evidence from Etihad the panel did not consider all the facts).
The rest is futile. Twisting and turning it to suit your argument acheives nothing. You're just basing your argument on the basis that because they "may" have been available, it would be rejected but I would suggest that's a very weak argument for dismissing vital evidence.
Aside from that, we don't know if any statement or evidence by Etihad would be substantial enough to make any difference in any event. As I keep saying, we're just guessing.
Ethiad's statement talks about the PL. It doesn't talk about whether or not City sought to have Ethiad provide evidence. If it did not, then we're going to have a really hard time getting new evidence considered on Appeal, for example. There will be other arguments to keep that evidence out - and the presumption is in favor of NOT allowing it before an appellate panel. It's not a slam dunk, which is what most of the lawyers here have been trying to explain for weeks.