A footballer’s tale everyone should read

Joined
21 Feb 2008
Messages
5,169
Location
https://gjfootballarchive.com/
I just want to highlight the incredible story of George Smith. A City player who went through some incredible experiences fighting for his country but then came under pressure to keep quiet as he tried to resurrect his football career. I interviewed him in 2002 and have just posted some of the story for the former players. I think most will seriously feel for George and what he went through. See:

 
Excellent stuff Gary.
Thanks Noel. Doing these features for Once A Blue has really helped me. I had a bit of a writer’s block and when we discussed doing them it was suggested that I put myself in them. I never normally do that and I was uncertain but it’s meant I’m more reflective when writing. I”m putting myself back into the room and remembering how I feel. IT’s really helped and I’m enjoying doing them. Glad people are enjoying them. Nice to remember these players too.
 
I just want to highlight the incredible story of George Smith. A City player who went through some incredible experiences fighting for his country but then came under pressure to keep quiet as he tried to resurrect his football career. I interviewed him in 2002 and have just posted some of the story for the former players. I think most will seriously feel for George and what he went through. See:

Thanks for sharing. Really good read and very sad.
 
Talking of him scoring five in a game, that match was also Roy Clarke's debut for City. Some years ago I was introduced to Clarke outside Maine Road before a game.

I said to him "I remember your debut when George Smith scored five." He replied "George Smith? I went to school with him." This was clearly quite impossible.

I gathered later he was suffering from dementia, just as George Smith was. What a cruel disease.
 
Talking of him scoring five in a game, that match was also Roy Clarke's debut for City. Some years ago I was introduced to Clarke outside Maine Road before a game.

I said to him "I remember your debut when George Smith scored five." He replied "George Smith? I went to school with him." This was clearly quite impossible.

I gathered later he was suffering from dementia, just as George Smith was. What a cruel disease.
Yes but the great thing was that Roy’s wonderful family and George’s too were keen to ensure they got out and about. With dementia it’s so important to try and keep the person living within in the world. When I first met Joe Mercer it was clear he was living with dementia but his wife Norah ensured he’d attend things like the FWA player of the year event etc. She told me how a famous LFC name was in a similar situation to Joe but his family didn’t want anyone to know and so they withdrew him from the world.

It’s always difficult and each individual is different of course. Once A Blue have held memory groups for former players now and that’s a great initiative.
 
What a fantastic read, thanks for that Gary.
Thanks. Appreciated. I don't know if you've seen the other articles in the series but they cover Tony Book, Gerry Gow, Johnny Hart, Fionan 'Paddy' Fagan, Trevor Francis, Sir Tom Finney on David White, Ron Healey, Bert Trautmann & Malcolm Allison. Plenty more to come over the coming months too.
 
Wonderfully relevant article just before remembrance Sunday. Its amazing the effects of loyalty and discipline had on that generation. Can you envisage trying to cover up such a debilitating injury nowadays, just because FF was involved.
An excellent addition to your fine body of work Gary. I was unaware of the existence of Soundbites, but they will be required reading in the immediate future.
Please keep them coming.
 
Thanks. Appreciated. I don't know if you've seen the other articles in the series but they cover Tony Book, Gerry Gow, Johnny Hart, Fionan 'Paddy' Fagan, Trevor Francis, Sir Tom Finney on David White, Ron Healey, Bert Trautmann & Malcolm Allison. Plenty more to come over the coming months too.
Excellent read, Gary, along with the others you have so far produced for this series. I was so glad you chose first-up to be Bert Trautmann, my first ever City hero!

I wonder about your future plans for these articles? Have you ever done (or thought about doing?) something on Jack Reynolds, the 'Father of Dutch Football' who started at City in the early 1900s with his brother? The link with modern day City is something I touched on in conversation on here in 2018 with 'KS55' regarding the great Hungarian team of the 50s with Puskas, Hidegkuti, Koscis etc. Whilst Jack never played for our first team, yet his contribution to footballing history from his humble beginnings in Whitefield is, I believe, beyond compare (and as an aside, as a PoW during WWII, he also found time to be banged up by the Nazis alongside one of my literary heroes, P G Wodehouse!)

I attach my note to 'KS55' for your interest. Keep the good work coming, it's both illuminating and appreciated!
====================================

"Only saw the great Hungarian side on newsreels/tv and the like but, as with any Blue growing up in the late 50s/early 60s, I took great pride in learning how Don Revie was used by City as a deep-lying centre forward on the same lines as Nandor Hidegkuti of that fabulous Hungarian team.

As for Rinus Michels and Vic Buckingham (quoted elsewhere in your follow up posts), I don't know if the following will be of interest to you and others. The so-called 'Father of Modern Dutch Football' was a guy from Manchester, Jack Reynolds.

He had a largely undistinguished playing career, which started with City around 1900 (he was a winger but never actually played for the first team.. I think he had a bit of competition from some bloke called Meredith at the time..!) His brother Billy, a centre forward, was also on City's books at the time. Jack went to other clubs as a jobbing-player, then went into coaching, landing up in Amsterdam at the end of WWII as coach of Ajax.

At Ajax, Reynolds set up the club to (a) have a playing style based on possession and 'immediate pressure on opponents in possession' (b) have every team at the club, from junior levels upwards, playing in the same style (c) have training designed around individual players having constant access to a ball, emphasising technical skills over the 'English mentality' of training being all about lapping the pitch/physical exercise.

This blueprint carried on throughout the 50s/60s (including Vic Buckingham's time at Ajax after he left Sheffield Wednesday in some disgrace - the Tony Kay/'Bronco' Layne/Peter Swan betting scandal) and was refined/extended and so on by Rinus Michels when he became coach, ultimately developing the great Ajax team which included Johann Cruyff which emulated the feat of Real Madrid of the 50s in winning three consecutive European Cups. Michels and Cruyff, as we all know, took this thinking/system to the Dutch national team (and, oh my! wasn't that a beautiful thing to watch between 1974-78?!) and to Barcelona.

And again, we all know what happened when Cruyff took the managerial reins at Barca, with La Masia and Guardiola following on..

I remember reading one interesting quotation from Jack Reynolds not long after the time he took over at Ajax, in which he said 'For me, attack is and remains the best form of defence.. we play an open game, you can't afford to neglect the wings'

It may be something of a stretch to claim that what we are currently witnessing with our beloved Blues runs back all the way to Hyde Road but the links are there! Jack Reynolds took all he learned as a coach and added his own ideas to make something new. It took years of refinement by like-minded thinkers such as Buckingham/Michels/Cruyff and so on to get to the all-conquering club side that was Ajax and the mind-blowing 'total voetbal' of the Dutch 70s team.

But that's where the great Barca side (and the great Spanish national side of the past decade, too) came from. And thank goodness Cruyff was at Barca to mentor Guardiola.

And even greater thanks to the Sheikh for enabling us to get the best of the best to come to Manchester. It really is the most beautiful football I've ever witnessed."
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top