PL charge City for alleged breaches of financial rules

The gambling theories are complete nonsense, profits are made on football regardless of who wins, draws or loses. The bookmakers have a built in profitability on the prices they offer. It would make absolutely zero sense to try and fix a match. They do however have a handle on anyone trying to match fix when they see unusual betting patterns so conversely they are helping to keep the game honest.

However, there’s been spot betting in the past, especially relating to Asian companies. They would not get away with it here with the latest technology. It’s more punters spot fixing not bookmakers trying to rig games.

I take it you’re referring to Tony Bloom and Matt Benham regarding ownership, both are not bookmakers but use scientific algorithms to profit from betting. They don’t need to fix matches as they make their money using legitimate tactics. Besides, would you not think there would have been whistleblowers over the many years they’ve been operating?
Making money from betting doesn’t mean you cannot and wouldn’t want to make money from fixing it
 
I wonder whether City's lawyers could use Arsenal's Emirates deal to challenge the panel's interpretation of the Etihad agreements.

When Arsenal were struggling to finance their new stadium, Emirates brought forward around £35m in sponsorship payments. Perfectly legitimate, of course.

Obviously, advance payments and retrospective contractual amendments aren't the same thing, but both can have genuine commercial explanations.

If the panel treated the timing of City's amendments, particularly around the 2013 FFP shortfall, as evidence of wrongdoing, our lawyers could argue that the panel placed too much weight on the timing without sufficiently considering legitimate commercial explanations.

The Arsenal example wouldn't disprove the PL's allegations, but it could help demonstrate that structuring sponsorship agreements around a club's financial needs isn't inherently suspicious.

The key question for an appeal would be whether the panel made an identifiable error in rejecting those alternative explanations, rather than simply reaching a conclusion City disagrees with.
Just reading this and remembered something I was made aware of some years back regarding Arsenal. Back in around 2000/2001 Arsenal sold a chunk of shares to Granada Media for approx 1.6-3.4 times their open market value in order to help fund the building of the new stadium.
 
City very rarely leak information and when they brief it is virtually always information already in the public domain. You can’t compare us to the systematic hate campaign by some of our malicious commercial rivals.
I mean who do you seriously think leaked to Keegan and Ziegler about the wins in APT? It wasn’t the premier league was it.
 
I think our opening submission at the appeal hearing should be simple: ask the panel to watch a short video clip of the PL/cartel CEO DICK Masters being interviewed in 2023.
When asked about Peps remarkable achievement of winning five out of six PL titles, the man heading the organisation supposedly responsible for ensuring the impartiality and integrity of the rules responded with an answer that was nothing short of absurd.

"But, regimes come and go, empires rise and fall. We've seen that in the Premier League already in its 32-year history, and City will be the same ultimately. Someone will take over eventually."

That clip deserves to be seen by the panel. It raises a fundamental question about the independence, impartiality and credibility of the organisation responsible for overseeing the very rules at the heart of the appeal.
It doesn’t. He doesn’t say anything unrealistic or unreasonable there.

If he had said “and we need to do something about it” you’d have a point.
 
No, it was a Freudian slip — and a hugely revealing one. It exposed what I believe has been the underlying objective all along: that the targeted rule changes and vexatious charges were part of a concerted policy aimed at forcing us out of the Premier League. In case you hadn't noticed, there's a damn good chance of us being in The Championship in August 2027.
In that context, it raises a fundamental question: was removing City not only the wider agenda of the cartel, but also Richard Masters’ personal mission from the moment he was appointed — a mission he was expected to pursue on their behalf?
That is precisely why the panel needs to see the interview. A Freudian slip can sometimes reveal more about the thinking behind an agenda than any carefully rehearsed public statement.

Thanks - I totally agree, the attempts to stifle our development has really been incessant since the US owners cartel saw their arses at our threat to them.

I think you missed my :)-
 
What could be the reason for us apparently agreeing to the fast track appeal process? A sign of confidence in the appeal or playing the long game? I very much doubt magic twat's theory that it's to delay publication of the full ruling/sanctions as that provides no long-term advantage to us.
 
Just reading this and remembered something I was made aware of some years back regarding Arsenal. Back in around 2000/2001 Arsenal sold a chunk of shares to Granada Media for approx 1.6-3.4 times their open market value in order to help fund the building of the new stadium.

Surely not - Arsenal as a club/owners are beyond scrutiny !

You must be mistaken :)-
 
I mean who do you seriously think leaked to Keegan and Ziegler about the wins in APT? It wasn’t the premier league was it.
Ziegler is no friend of City. Some of the APT case was briefed out to Keegan but it was very small beer compared to the relentless organised campaign against City. Plus it was accurate honest info, unlike the lies and distortions spread against City.
 
They are accused of sham contracts to the tune of millions. A very serious allegation that impacts their reputation.

Im pretty certain they’ll be permitted full access in order to defend their position.
They would have to get a judge to provide them that access though, which comes back to the original point in TH’s tweet. They can’t possibly have ‘all ducks in a row’ as they haven’t yet been officially granted access to the report despite an obviously having received it via the club. They’ve reportedly engaged with top quality counsel so I have no doubt they’ll find a path, but clearly the original tweet was premature.
 
They would have to get a judge to provide them that access though, which comes back to the original point in TH’s tweet. They can’t possibly have ‘all ducks in a row’ as they haven’t yet been officially granted access to the report despite an obviously having received it via the club. They’ve reportedly engaged with top quality counsel so I have no doubt they’ll find a path, but clearly the original tweet was premature.
I read ‘ducks in a row’ to relate to commencing a claim.
 
When this is done a roll call of names should be published as to who should no longer be accepted

After seeing a video of David Mooney questioning the value of the Sergio goal immediately after the first decision I expect him to be looked at
He hates our ownership. Something to do with skin colour or middle easterners not accepting homosexuality or something. I havent listened to any of his podcasts for a decade or so.

Last time I heard him he was telling the bbc that anti-city sentiment from the media is all in City fans heads.

I suspect he will be slightly enjoying our owners troubles right now.
 
They would have to get a judge to provide them that access though, which comes back to the original point in TH’s tweet. They can’t possibly have ‘all ducks in a row’ as they haven’t yet been officially granted access to the report despite an obviously having received it via the club. They’ve reportedly engaged with top quality counsel so I have no doubt they’ll find a path, but clearly the original tweet was premature.
Whose original tweet was premature?
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top