PL charge City for alleged breaches of financial rules

That just a silly argument though - the overview release states very clearly that the panel found that the seriousness of the allegations necessitated a high bar which they believed the PL reached.

No it didn't it just called all Citys witnesses lies and fraudsters. I have seen it read anything that backs up your point .
 
No it didn't it just called all Citys witnesses lies and fraudsters. I have seen it read anything that backs up your point .
It can be interpreted that way sure, but they refer to the appendices when doing so and no one knows what is in them. We can always hope that that it is true that the basis of their decision isnt as substantial, but frankly right now you have to assume that there is some very damning stuff in there. That doesnt mean our case is dead, but if you read some posts on here you would almost think that some people think than once the appendices finally gets released the PLs case falls apart and it opens them up for breaking it down. Simply wont be the case
 
I agree. The PL could have avoided all this shit by showing respect for the CAS ruling. But, they decided to take the fight to City instead and have another bite of the cherry because City are not wanted at the top table. Sadly, unless there is a settlement, it'll be a fight to the death.
The only hope that I can see to avoid this scenario is for the PL to find some 'new evidence ' which clears City of all charges and a full apology via the media.
This is because City will not admit to having done anything illegal and therefore will not be a party to some kind of compromise.
 
Here is a thought for anyone still thinking ADUG could have paid money directly into Etihad:

For every debit in accounting there has to be a corresponding entry. It's called double entry (quiet at the back!).

So if ADUG paid money into Etihad directly, the entry would be debit the bank and credit another account. What would that account be? Because after ten years there must have been a billion in it.

It could have been credited to the profit and loss account as revenue or as a reduction in sponsorship expenses. But an entry to either of those at 80 million a year would easily be disproved by Etihad's auditors. That's easy to check.

Or it could have been credited to a balance sheet to account - share capital, a liability account. I think we can discount share capital for a billion. I haven't heard of Mansour owning Etihad. So that leaves a liability account, but that would also have a billion in it by 2018 and would stand out in the accounts like a sore thumb.

So where is this billion credit supposed to have gone?
Eh? This is one of the few things us nobodies *can* answer. Etihad were receiving ongoing equity injections to fund operations back then whilst they built out fleet, capacity etc. The other side is share capital. Hogan has openly discussed as such. The only question is where the cash came from the conspiracy says ADUG, common sense says central funds.
 
Eh? This is one of the few things us nobodies *can* answer. Etihad were receiving ongoing equity injections to fund operations back then whilst they built out fleet, capacity etc. The other side is share capital. Hogan has openly discussed as such. The only question is where the cash came from the conspiracy says ADUG, common sense says central funds.

It says ADUG. Directly.
 
Last edited:
Hate using such terms but I think there are quite a few
" bad actors " currently appearing on this thread with the intention of stirring the pot to the point that posters are unsure of exactly where the club is likely to end up following the PL's witchunt.

The cartel are fighting for the ultimate control over the PL, with considerable assistance from the individuals purporting to be acting in the best interests of the PL. Masters and others have taken the money and have been driven.

Depressing as it is, the findings of the IC were " shocking " by design and intent, and the shock waves were quickly spread by a willing media - a truly spineless collection of bad actors !

City have been far too good in achieving success despite all the obstacles placed before it and the US cunts are now fighting real dirty, which is their norm as clearly witnessed in everything they involve themselves in.

Holding our nerve and bringing the fuckers down has to prevail for the benefit of football - not that the club will get any thanks from our enemies or the braindeads !
 
No it didn't it just called all Citys witnesses lies and fraudsters. I have seen it read anything that backs up your point .
I mean it’s literally on the first page of the report….

“6) The serious wrongdoing alleged by the PL against the Club by each Charge required strong, cogent evidence to prove that individual Charge. As set out below and in the Appendices to this document, with the exception of Charge 4(B) we were satisfied to the requisite standard that there was such evidence.”

A statement as such and then the appendices just saying ‘well we didn’t see any evidence but we just think City did it…’ would be the shortest appeal in the history of law.
 
Explosive if the appendices are published, blues.

The “workings out” will be available for scrutiny. We’ll be able to see who is being called a liar and how the IC thinks the “disguised funding” has happened.

This will enable us all to no longer need to gap-fill and remove the ifs and buts and speculation about how the IC reached their conclusions.

I envisage an exceptionally busy week on here.
Well, there's no such thing as a "tribunal report" in this case, so I wish Samuel had used the correct terminology: "our Decision" if he's referring to the full decision, including the appendices, or "Core Decision" if he simply means an unredacted version of what's already been published.

Even if it's hardly ideal for the club or those involved, I would welcome its publication. We deserve to know the full story.
 
The only hope that I can see to avoid this scenario is for the PL to find some 'new evidence ' which clears City of all charges and a full apology via the media.
This is because City will not admit to having done anything illegal and therefore will not be a party to some kind of compromise.
Now that would be nice
 
I mean it’s literally on the first page of the report….

“6) The serious wrongdoing alleged by the PL against the Club by each Charge required strong, cogent evidence to prove that individual Charge. As set out below and in the Appendices to this document, with the exception of Charge 4(B) we were satisfied to the requisite standard that there was such evidence.”

A statement as such and then the appendices just saying ‘well we didn’t see any evidence but we just think City did it…’ would be the shortest appeal in the history of law.

The requisite standard is lower then CAS and it only needs the pl ic to think it took place. How did the pl ic prove ALL Citys evidence was lies and fraudulent ? Pl ic doesn't need to prove it just believe it happen
CAS needed proof
 
Sorry I’ve no idea what you’re trying to say. I literally said the conspiracy is ADUG were providing the injections and that conspiracy makes no sense because it’s would mean going out of your way to ignore the legitimate ways of doing so.

I know you don't. Let me explain it more simply.

** Here is a thought for anyone still thinking ADUG could have paid money directly into Etihad:

For every debit in accounting there has to be a corresponding entry. It's called double entry (quiet at the back!).

So if ADUG paid money into Etihad directly, the entry would be debit the bank and credit another account. What would that account be? Because after ten years there must have been a billion in it.

It could have been credited to the profit and loss account as revenue or as a reduction in sponsorship expenses. But an entry to either of those at 80 million a year would easily be disproved by Etihad's auditors. That's easy to check.

Or it could have been credited to a balance sheet to account - share capital, a liability account. I think we can discount share capital for a billion. I haven't heard of Mansour owning Etihad. So that leaves a liability account, but that would also have a billion in it by 2018 and would stand out in the accounts like a sore thumb.

So where is this billion credit supposed to have gone?
 
That just a silly argument though - the overview release states very clearly that the panel found that the seriousness of the allegations necessitated a high bar which they believed the PL reached.
Although the if we’re wrong about this we’ve got FMV up our sleeve bollocks suggest the bar was as high or low as they wished.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bez
Sorry I’ve no idea what you’re trying to say. I literally said the conspiracy is ADUG were providing the injections and that conspiracy makes no sense because it’s would mean going out of your way to ignore the legitimate ways of doing so.
I see you've not addressed the fact that nearly everyone on this thread thinks you're not a blue and have only joined the forum to stir the shit.
 
I agree. The PL could have avoided all this shit by showing respect for the CAS ruling. But, they decided to take the fight to City instead and have another bite of the cherry because City are not wanted at the top table. Sadly, unless there is a settlement, it'll be a fight to the death.
Precisely, the PL could have let sleeping dogs lie and protected the product. Scudamore would have done that.

With Masters the show has become a madhouse. Russ Abbot couldn't have gone a better job (for those of the older generation).
 
Your missing a key word from the paragraph "persuade". "How the club was able to PERSUADE AD sponsors to participate."
In other words, they did participate but why the agreed to is unclear.

View attachment 210241
Persuasion suggests the sponsor was “in on” the arrangement hence the “sham” findings.

I can’t wait to see these appendices.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top