Here is a thought for anyone still thinking ADUG could have paid money directly into Etihad:
For every debit in accounting there has to be a corresponding entry. It's called double entry (quiet at the back!).
So if ADUG paid money into Etihad directly, the entry would be debit the bank and credit another account. What would that account be? Because after ten years there must have been a billion in it.
It could have been credited to the profit and loss account as revenue or as a reduction in sponsorship expenses. But an entry to either of those at 80 million a year would easily be disproved by Etihad's auditors. That's easy to check.
Or it could have been credited to a balance sheet to account - share capital, a liability account. I think we can discount share capital for a billion. I haven't heard of Mansour owning Etihad. So that leaves a liability account, but that would also have a billion in it by 2018 and would stand out in the accounts like a sore thumb.
So where is this billion credit supposed to have gone?