PL charge City for alleged breaches of financial rules

Martin Samuel in the Sunday Times today writes:

This week could be seismic for Manchester City, if rumours predicting the publication of the unredacted tribunal report are true. That is the version believed to name names of the executives implicated and the depth of the deception in language far stronger than we have seen. So far legal challenges, not just from the club but from the various individuals detailed, have delayed publication; those with prior access to it consider the contents devastating.

It is also suggested any punishment could be announced before Manchester City’s appeal, which may have to wait until the New Year, but the course of that does not get any easier. As stated here many weeks ago, the challenge is to alight on a penalty that is just and proportionate, while not inadvertently sending the club into liquidation and the league’s financial fabric into meltdown. Those unforeseen consequences are now in plain side. There is a UEFA report in circulation suggesting if Manchester City failed to meet their transfer obligations Ligue 1 in France would be placed in jeopardy. It can be presumed that Lille, Troyes, Marseille, Lyon, PSG, Lens and Rennes are all owed sumd both large and small by City and French football does not have the substantial broadcast revenues keeping English football afloat.

Having said this, Chelsea, Nottingham Forest, Everton, Leicester City, Sheffield Wednesday, Bournemouth, Wolverhampton Wanderers, Burnley, Crystal Palace and Leeds United could also be impacted the same way here and some of those clubs are already in a state of financial distress. The more the ramifications from this episode become apparent the worse it gets.
Cue: Disco inferno by the trampps
 
Yet you had that balloon Kieran Maguire who is on the tv and radio more often than Romesh Ranganathan these days arguing with blues on Twitter yesterday that getting rid of City would have no impact on the PL.

Haaland is the only superstar in the PL. he has bigger social media following than 14 of the other premier league clubs combined !

The PL are in a crisis. Their current champions are the most unattractive winners in PL history - with a talent drain of the league almost complete.

Take Haaland out of the Balon Dor top 20 and there is one other player from the self proclaimed best league in the world ( at 15th position ). Good luck making Declan Rice the new poster boy to get in those TV rights next time around.

And at the same time the PL are intent on making the last 14 years of their competition void, and will spend the next 10 years in legal battles with the UAE in a fight to the death.

Genius work by Masters.

You just highlighted the power of the yank owners and their press/media.

They keep banging the drum that the pl is the best in the world. Say it often enough and the brain dead believe you.
As you say the pl has one world super star in Haaland. The world best manager has left after a decade of hate from the yanks and the press/media.

The yanks will take control of the pl, it will become a closed shop without promotion or relegation or it turns into a ESL.
If its stays as the pl the standard will drop, take away the jeopardy you take away sport.

The pl is being eaten and destroyed by the yanks with the help of the press/media.
 
Sorry Marvin but you seem quite locked to the idea that winning at CAS, where UEFA turned up with literally nothing and James Hogan testified for the defence that their case was bollocks, means that in some way the PL panel could never rule in the PLs favour.

The CAS ruling states that they found that it was solely UEFA’s burden to prove their case, not City’s to defend theirs. The same burden applied in the PL arbitration and the panel found based upon the mountain of highly sensitive documents City were compelled to provide that the PLs case was proven.

The polarity in findings actually does the opposite of what you wish to achieve in not showing the PL panel must have erred but instead asking what was in those documents, and in the appendices , to allow them to find that way and rule several witnesses to be liars.
I’ve said all along we need the appendices.

Everything else is guesswork and gap filling.
 
You just highlighted the power of the yank owners and their press/media.

They keep banging the drum that the pl is the best in the world. Say it often enough and the brain dead believe you.
As you say the pl has one world super star in Haaland. The world best manager has left after a decade of hate from the yanks and the press/media.

The yanks will take control of the pl, it will become a closed shop without promotion or relegation or it turns into a ESL.
If its stays as the pl the standard will drop, take away the jeopardy you take away sport.

The pl is being eaten and destroyed by the yanks with the help of the press/media.
City are part of that ESL cartel though. US educated chairman who jumped in feet first given the chance and a statement from Joel Glazer on the MCFC website.

City are doing their bit.
 
Precisely, the PL could have let sleeping dogs lie and protected the product. Scudamore would have done that.

With Masters the show has become a madhouse. Russ Abbot couldn't have gone a better job (for those of the older generation).
As bobbyowensquiff was saying, it's been - VERY - personal with Masters, and the rest of the executive too you suspect.
 
Why is there little mention of Rui Pinto in all this?
Is he not the one who obtained City's e- mails illegally, upon which this whole farago is based?
After our case is concluded does anyone think that he will dish the dirt on other clubs he claims to have incriminating e- mails about?
My thought is that he won't, because in reality City are the only club he has e- mails about.
How often has he hacked into City's e-mails historically?
Who sponsored him?
I think we should be told....,
 
Persuasion suggests the sponsor was “in on” the arrangement hence the “sham” findings.

I can’t wait to see these appendices.

This is what I can't understand. In my mind, at least, I have proven to myself that it can easily be shown that ADUG didn't pay directly to Etihad. So it must have been through ADG. But then why did the club have to persuade the sponsors to do anything? They didn't even have to know about it. And if they didn't know about it, how could the contracts be sham?

As far as I can see, the PL's argument is that the club entered into unnecessary funding schemes, unnecessarily told all the parties about them, unnecessarily involved all the parties in them, and then unnecessarily documented them all in emails to all the parties through the club's servers?

It's all too weird to me.
 
Nunes signing a new deal another soft signal and it's just business as usual.
I do wonder that the soft signal all along has been that there has been talks that even if we are found guilty, the sanctions hardly would put a dent in us on the sporting side.
People(Media) assume it will be scorched earth because it pays their bills, but it is all the chance in the world that the whole trial and conclusion of it is two parties that wants to be seen to win, but that even the PL agree that City has to go on as normal
 
This is what I can't understand. In my mind, at least, I have proven to myself that it can easily be shown that ADUG didn't pay directly to Etihad. So it must have been through ADG. But then why did the club have to persuade the sponsors to do anything? They didn't even have to know about it. And if they didn't know about it, how could the contracts be sham?

As far as I can see, the PL's argument is that the club entered into unnecessary funding schemes, told all the parties about them, involved all the parties in them, and then documented them all in emails through the club's servers?

It's all too weird to me.
And if the club actually called it a Disguised Funding Scheme it probably wasn’t very well disguised. But giving it a title and continually referring to it as such, as the Premier League and/or the IC have done, looks like an attempt to back up their suppositions with a defined but invented identity.
 
Yet you had that balloon Kieran Maguire who is on the tv and radio more often than Romesh Ranganathan these days arguing with blues on Twitter yesterday that getting rid of City would have no impact on the PL.

Haaland is the only superstar in the PL. he has bigger social media following than 14 of the other premier league clubs combined !

The PL are in a crisis. Their current champions are the most unattractive winners in PL history - with a talent drain of the league almost complete.

Take Haaland out of the Balon Dor top 20 and there is one other player from the self proclaimed best league in the world ( at 15th position ). Good luck making Declan Rice the new poster boy to get in those TV rights next time around.

And at the same time the PL are intent on making the last 14 years of their competition void, and will spend the next 10 years in legal battles with the UAE in a fight to the death.

Genius work by Masters.
With his Una Paloma Blanca Jonathan King looks, there's a reason we've been getting Kieran Maguire day and night, day after day, week after week, and less of Dan Roan and Rob Harris. He's the PL poster boy spouting their propaganda. He was claiming the other week he knew why the names of the IC panel had been withheld. How would he know that? Is it possible he was one of the PL witnesses?
 
The Martin Samuel piece is alarming with its description of the threat to Ligue 1 and an array of English clubs, as well as its threat to tell all on the criminal activities of City executives - "devastating" in fact. Samuel's article can in fact be seen as a plea for sense,for sanctions that are "just and proportionate" and do not send the club into liquidation. This is fine if it did not appear that this is exactly what the PL and the cartel intend to try.

City must have seen the unredacted report in all its seismic glory and they are still bullishly confident and are going ahead eith the appeal and seem prepared to go as far as it takes. We have seen on this thread this very morning that the claims of financial wrong doing are, at least. open to question. that City claim to have evidence in the form of bank statements, receipts etc to show we have not broken any rules. As for the accusations against executives they can only be based on emails, and if we prove we have done nothing wrong ...

The PL have to be very careful about accusations aimed at our executives. Many are respected figures on a global scale and may take the pl for millions in damages if the accusations can not be sustained in court (not a PL tribunal) and it will not be Ligue 1 going bust but many PL clubs who have to pan enormous legal fees and damages.

My view is that we'll never see the unredacted report,
 
Precisely, the PL could have let sleeping dogs lie and protected the product. Scudamore would have done that.

With Masters the show has become a madhouse. Russ Abbot couldn't have gone a better job (for those of the older generation).
The potential fallout just seems to get more seismic each week, Masters is playing Russian roulette with the PL, & the Red Cartel are loading the bullets, drooling at the prospect of putting City out of contention with hefty punishments, meanwhile City haven’t won the PL for 2 seasons, while they go through a natural dip in fortunes as they go through a post Pep rebuild.
They’re caught between a rock and a hard place, give into the baying crowds, & potentially destroy the PL as City’s owners go schorched earth, or protect the brand,come to some arrangement with City, & change the current rules that are hamstringing the majority of PL clubs.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top