PL charge City for alleged breaches of financial rules

If we're trying to stop publication it's fair to say that the full redacted report isnt going to be too much fun for us.
I want to see this report warts and all, if it is going to be devastating then I want to see why. We have placed a lot of trust in our owners and their stewardship. I want to believe and trust them and hope we are right in doing so. I just feel we are kidding ourselves if we believe we are squeaky clean, i dont think any club is either.

I am sadly losing my love for the game at the top level.
 
By the way, I agree with you on the selective use of the good faith rule.

The PL could easily have started investigations on Sheffield United, Chelsea, Everton and Newcastle for their collaborative involvement in those multi-party ffp-busting transactions a few years back, Chelsea's asset sales, Chelsea's (again) fake amortisation, Chelsea's (again) off the books payments and God know's what else, looking for years through all emails and internal documentation for evidence of bad faith. But ..... crickets.

It seems to be a tap they turn on and off as they want.
All PL rules are used selectively both on and off the field.

Their philosophy seems to have been to make rules just in case.
Hopefully this unfairness can be, at some stage of the legal process, used against them.
 
Hate using such terms but I think there are quite a few
" bad actors " currently appearing on this thread with the intention of stirring the pot to the point that posters are unsure of exactly where the club is likely to end up following the PL's witchunt.

The cartel are fighting for the ultimate control over the PL, with considerable assistance from the individuals purporting to be acting in the best interests of the PL. Masters and others have taken the money and have been driven.

Depressing as it is, the findings of the IC were " shocking " by design and intent, and the shock waves were quickly spread by a willing media - a truly spineless collection of bad actors !

City have been far too good in achieving success despite all the obstacles placed before it and the US cunts are now fighting real dirty, which is their norm as clearly witnessed in everything they involve themselves in.

Holding our nerve and bringing the fuckers down has to prevail for the benefit of football - not that the club will get any thanks from our enemies or the braindeads !
A disproportionate amount of them seem to be called Tommy…
 
I am not claiming to be an ITK, let us get that clear at the beginning. I was talking this week with an old friend who has been well connected at City since pre Swales. He told me he was talking to a director of City, at the begining of this, who he knows and considers him not to be a liar. The director told him that the Sheikh said at the beginning, that whatever the cost he will pay the lawyers etc as he considers City have done nothing wrong. No matter what the media write or whether they are at the top of their game, no matter what the ' independent ' panel or the appeal panel say, this is a fight to the finish and the Sheikh has told the directors this, no expense spared in the fight to clear City. Unless the PL find a way to now clear City this is going to a truly independant court and hearing. It really will be a terrible ending for one or the other if it gets to the High Court.
 
The potential fallout just seems to get more seismic each week, Masters is playing Russian roulette with the PL, & the Red Cartel are loading the bullets, drooling at the prospect of putting City out of contention with hefty punishments, meanwhile City haven’t won the PL for 2 seasons, while they go through a natural dip in fortunes as they go through a post Pep rebuild.
They’re caught between a rock and a hard place, give into the baying crowds, & potentially destroy the PL as City’s owners go schorched earth, or protect the brand,come to some arrangement with City, & change the current rules that are hamstringing the majority of PL clubs.
I doubt our owners would need to pursue a scorched earth policy. Simply redirecting their significant wealth to a competitor league would be a major blow for the PL.
 
Here is a thought for anyone still thinking ADUG could have paid money directly into Etihad:

For every debit in accounting there has to be a corresponding entry. It's called double entry (quiet at the back!).

So if ADUG paid money into Etihad directly, the entry would be debit the bank and credit another account. What would that account be? Because after ten years there must have been a billion in it.

It could have been credited to the profit and loss account as revenue or as a reduction in sponsorship expenses. But an entry to either of those at 80 million a year would easily be disproved by Etihad's auditors. That's easy to check.

Or it could have been credited to a balance sheet to account - share capital, a liability account. I think we can discount share capital for a billion. I haven't heard of Mansour owning Etihad. So that leaves a liability account, but that would also have a billion in it by 2018 and would stand out in the accounts like a sore thumb.

So where is this billion credit supposed to have gone?
Suspense Account somewhere if they can't tie it to an invoice.?
 
Martin Samuel in the Sunday Times today writes:

This week could be seismic for Manchester City, if rumours predicting the publication of the unredacted tribunal report are true. That is the version believed to name names of the executives implicated and the depth of the deception in language far stronger than we have seen. So far legal challenges, not just from the club but from the various individuals detailed, have delayed publication; those with prior access to it consider the contents devastating.

It is also suggested any punishment could be announced before Manchester City’s appeal, which may have to wait until the New Year, but the course of that does not get any easier. As stated here many weeks ago, the challenge is to alight on a penalty that is just and proportionate, while not inadvertently sending the club into liquidation and the league’s financial fabric into meltdown. Those unforeseen consequences are now in plain side. There is a UEFA report in circulation suggesting if Manchester City failed to meet their transfer obligations Ligue 1 in France would be placed in jeopardy. It can be presumed that Lille, Troyes, Marseille, Lyon, PSG, Lens and Rennes are all owed sumd both large and small by City and French football does not have the substantial broadcast revenues keeping English football afloat.

Having said this, Chelsea, Nottingham Forest, Everton, Leicester City, Sheffield Wednesday, Bournemouth, Wolverhampton Wanderers, Burnley, Crystal Palace and Leeds United could also be impacted the same way here and some of those clubs are already in a state of financial distress. The more the ramifications from this episode become apparent the worse it gets.

Nought new that! If that premier panel believed everyone lied they of course the redacted will be devastating Samual!
There were a couple of new things.

1. The club and individuals have launched legal challenges to prevent publication.
2. It will be published this week.

Those points were news to me anyway. Of course a journalist saying something will happen doesn't make it true so as with everything else I will wait and see.
 
I mean it’s literally on the first page of the report….

“6) The serious wrongdoing alleged by the PL against the Club by each Charge required strong, cogent evidence to prove that individual Charge. As set out below and in the Appendices to this document, with the exception of Charge 4(B) we were satisfied to the requisite standard that there was such evidence.”

A statement as such and then the appendices just saying ‘well we didn’t see any evidence but we just think City did it…’ would be the shortest appeal in the history of law.
Surely strong cogent evidence as proof must include the actual financial transactions between all parties. If not, how can they be satisfied the evidence met the requisite standards in a case that can ruin a billion pound business. This is the most important aspect of the case, the money trail. Without it the verdict has to be unsafe.
 
I know you don't. Let me explain it more simply.

** Here is a thought for anyone still thinking ADUG could have paid money directly into Etihad:

For every debit in accounting there has to be a corresponding entry. It's called double entry (quiet at the back!).

So if ADUG paid money into Etihad directly, the entry would be debit the bank and credit another account. What would that account be? Because after ten years there must have been a billion in it.

It could have been credited to the profit and loss account as revenue or as a reduction in sponsorship expenses. But an entry to either of those at 80 million a year would easily be disproved by Etihad's auditors. That's easy to check.

Or it could have been credited to a balance sheet to account - share capital, a liability account. I think we can discount share capital for a billion. I haven't heard of Mansour owning Etihad. So that leaves a liability account, but that would also have a billion in it by 2018 and would stand out in the accounts like a sore thumb.

So where is this billion credit supposed to have gone?
And as already said, it’s day 1 accounting, it goes to share capital.
 
Well, the only reason I can see for publishing an unredacted decision now is that the sanctions are also about to be announced.

Also, if Samuel is correct that the executives involved will be named, surely the appendices would have to be published too? The panel explicitly states that it uses abbreviations and shorthand throughout the Decision to refer to individuals and entities, with Appendix 36 providing the glossary and list of abbreviations, and Appendix 37 identifying the key individuals and entities.
 
Surely strong cogent evidence as proof must include the actual financial transactions between all parties. If not, how can they be satisfied the evidence met the requisite standards in a case that can ruin a billion pound business. This is the most important aspect of the case, the money trail. Without it the verdict has to be unsafe.
And this surely has to be the missing evidence that gets mentioned by the panel in the verdict statement.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top