THey're talking about the whole report, of which the audit was a part, as not being very relevant.
They also make it abundantly clear that we didn't prove our defence, so parroting the EY audit as proof of innocence is completely misleading.
The panel made it clear neither side produced anything that convinced them either way.
View attachment 210345
UEFA were given the option at CAS, once the panel decided that City should have turned over the evidence requested, whether to go away with the new evidence and build a case, or just finish it all then and there. They made a terrible strategic decision to not use the new evidence they were entitled to because UEFA wanted the whole thing settled by the start of the season.
In the 115 case, The High Court made City hand over all the evidence 3 years before the hearing. So we know for a fact that CAS was won because UEFA had almost zero evidence, that Dudney's report (of which EY was a part) didn't convince the panel because it had limited relevance, and the PL had access to all the evidence they wanted long before the hearing they won.
This isn't "bad" for City's chances at the appeal, it's just the CAS verdict doesn't prove our innocence the way Marv and a few others keep insisting it does. CAS literally spelled it out for you. UEFA had no meaningful evidence because they had emails. We already know the PL had enough documents they made over 1m searches of that evidence when building their case.