PL charge City for alleged breaches of financial rules

Succinct and exact.
The whole case against us is built upon jealousy and its tactic is defamation.
Throw in a bit of protectionism and a soupçon of bias - and it is indeed a public shafting.

Still reckon we'll have the last laugh - but will it be enough after all this?
Yes.
 
As is plainly obvious I am no where near as emotionally challenged with all this as City supporters but as I tried to point out a while ago it was becoming obvious that some were clearly being mislead and if at the end of the process nothing much has changed then I would fear for some posters mental well being.
I think what you have done is try and add a perspective to the CAS ruling which I think is important
I don’t subscribe to the view that City got off at CAS on a technicality but the fact that UEFa/Cas and the PL operate under different jurisdictions is a major issue and clearly is something some simply haven’t recognised. Whilst some comparisons can be made ultimately the question is , I guess, is had the CAS case been assessed as on the balance as opposed to comfortable satisfaction would the decision been the same ?

Pretty sure I might have mentioned this before, but you come across as one hypocritical and smug twat.

Just saying .........................
 
Having said that, and I quote, " The majority of the panel nonetheless finds that the conclusions of Ernst &Young do support MCFC's case. In particular, the theory that ADUG directly funded or reimbursed Etihad for its sponsorship contributions to MCFC is discredited".

It's pretty clear to me what they are talking about in paragraph 267 and 268 and they are very different things. How on earth do you think the criticism that Dudney relied on financial information from MCFC has any bearing on the quality of EY's work which was based on ADUG's financial information?

Edit: btw, they didn't say the EY work wasn't reliable or independent, they said it wasn't as reliable and independent as a full independent audit. Not the same.

THey're talking about the whole report, of which the audit was a part, as not being very relevant.

They also make it abundantly clear that we didn't prove our defence, so parroting the EY audit as proof of innocence is completely misleading.

The panel made it clear neither side produced anything that convinced them either way.

1794839171990.png
UEFA were given the option at CAS, once the panel decided that City should have turned over the evidence requested, whether to go away with the new evidence and build a case, or just finish it all then and there. They made a terrible strategic decision to not use the new evidence they were entitled to because UEFA wanted the whole thing settled by the start of the season.

In the 115 case, The High Court made City hand over all the evidence 3 years before the hearing. So we know for a fact that CAS was won because UEFA had almost zero evidence, that Dudney's report (of which EY was a part) didn't convince the panel because it had limited relevance, and the PL had access to all the evidence they wanted long before the hearing they won.

This isn't "bad" for City's chances at the appeal, it's just the CAS verdict doesn't prove our innocence the way Marv and a few others keep insisting it does. CAS literally spelled it out for you. UEFA had no meaningful evidence because they had emails. We already know the PL had enough documents they made over 1m searches of that evidence when building their case.
 
Poster well being ha ha the majority are pissing themselves laughing at how desperate followers of other clubs are to prove and hope were guilty and in doing so remove a competitor because that the bit you hate competition.
Yes, I really am worried that Pannick and Co. just clicked on 'Copy/Paste' to resolve this next fiasco without actually reading the rules...

While in the real world, I objectively evaluate the multiple positive indicators for City's eventual emergence against the manifold examples of conjecture, wildly emotional hyperbole and evidenced f*ck ups and bad faith repeatedly shown by football's governing institutions...
 
THey're talking about the whole report, of which the audit was a part, as not being very relevant.

They also make it abundantly clear that we didn't prove our defence, so parroting the EY audit as proof of innocence is completely misleading.

The panel made it clear neither side produced anything that convinced them either way.

View attachment 210345
UEFA were given the option at CAS, once the panel decided that City should have turned over the evidence requested, whether to go away with the new evidence and build a case, or just finish it all then and there. They made a terrible strategic decision to not use the new evidence they were entitled to because UEFA wanted the whole thing settled by the start of the season.

In the 115 case, The High Court made City hand over all the evidence 3 years before the hearing. So we know for a fact that CAS was won because UEFA had almost zero evidence, that Dudney's report (of which EY was a part) didn't convince the panel because it had limited relevance, and the PL had access to all the evidence they wanted long before the hearing they won.

This isn't "bad" for City's chances at the appeal, it's just the CAS verdict doesn't prove our innocence the way Marv and a few others keep insisting it does. CAS literally spelled it out for you. UEFA had no meaningful evidence because they had emails. We already know the PL had enough documents they made over 1m searches of that evidence when building their case.
Your relentlessly negative take is unsupported by any evidence of what the PL has. - 'million of docs' to search doesn't mean they found anything to support their stitch up.
 
Succinct and exact.
The whole case against us is built upon jealousy and its tactic is defamation.
Throw in a bit of protectionism and a soupçon of bias - and it is indeed a public shafting.

Still reckon we'll have the last laugh - but will it be enough after all this?
Took a Japanese ex-pat friend (PSG fan) through it all last night - quite objectively re: what has happened thus far, but sharing clearly what were my views on what really might be going on and how the whole thing appeares to me when you looked at the patterns and tone being expounded at each stage.

He could see the weird nature of proceedings, but better still his Ukrainian girlfriend seemed very on the money with it, pre-prompting several of my views - 'that sounds very strange'/'trial by media then?'' (re: things like the tone of the report, redacted reasoning, panel hired and chosen by PL, and media hype for us to be extincted).

I found out she has a colleague who is a big football fan and rag (we're all in London) who, when she's asked him about it in the past has responded that it's all just media bullshit too. Seems like we're not alone in seeing through the BS...
 
That's a strange take on the issue. As I understand it, City could only be expelled if a 75% majority (15 of 19) of the other clubs vote in favour of it. So we would need only 5 clubs to be against it.
Has any media outlet considered the outcome if were cleared of the majority of charges ?
 
I saw a clip the other day it was that utter bellend max rushden who used to be on soccer am. He was basically licking Harris arse. But he was saying it was disgusting how city fans had treated him. Mocking the death of his wife and even throwing bricks through his window! Are these twats just making stuff up now or what?
In fairness, the bricks had the old crest on
 
Again, if I'm the PL I would say that's a statement limited to Etihad, Etisalat and their affiliates. Its not an all encompassing statement.
But the PL can't go on a fishing expedition either, can they? They get to look at every transaction SM authorized with his relatively massive business empire?

Would they comb through every FSG or Ineos transaction?

Pretty easy to make an argument that this is just a witch hunt if they are going that far.
 
What is the difference between on balance and comfortable satisfaction? Neither should be acceptable given the handpicked jury and executioner we now have.
Significant

Comfortable satisfaction is a stricter standard of proof than the balance of probabilities, requiring a higher level of certainty that an allegation is true.particularly in serious cases.
While the balance of probabilities means something is more likely than not to have happened, comfortable satisfaction demands a firm conviction based on the totality of evidence presented.
 
It's a moot point though. It needs 15 votes in favour of expulsion to reach the 75% threshold whether we get a vote or not

Pass
15/20 - 75%
15/19 - 78%
Fail
14/20 - 70%
14/19 - 73%

This is what CAS said about the EY agreed-upon procedure.
View attachment 210331
The paragraph 268 you posted talks about Dudney's analysis of information provided by MCFC to show all the sponsorship money came from Etihad, the criticism being that it didn't address the possibility that ADUG put money into Etihad. That was addressed in the above paragraphs, especially 267, with words like "supports case" and "discredited" the UEFA theory.
Looks like Domalino might be wrong, yet again.
 
THey're talking about the whole report, of which the audit was a part, as not being very relevant.

They also make it abundantly clear that we didn't prove our defence, so parroting the EY audit as proof of innocence is completely misleading.

The panel made it clear neither side produced anything that convinced them either way.

View attachment 210345
UEFA were given the option at CAS, once the panel decided that City should have turned over the evidence requested, whether to go away with the new evidence and build a case, or just finish it all then and there. They made a terrible strategic decision to not use the new evidence they were entitled to because UEFA wanted the whole thing settled by the start of the season.

In the 115 case, The High Court made City hand over all the evidence 3 years before the hearing. So we know for a fact that CAS was won because UEFA had almost zero evidence, that Dudney's report (of which EY was a part) didn't convince the panel because it had limited relevance, and the PL had access to all the evidence they wanted long before the hearing they won.

This isn't "bad" for City's chances at the appeal, it's just the CAS verdict doesn't prove our innocence the way Marv and a few others keep insisting it does. CAS literally spelled it out for you. UEFA had no meaningful evidence because they had emails. We already know the PL had enough documents they made over 1m searches of that evidence when building their case.
An abundance of emails does not make the case anymore conclusive or persuasive for the league to announce sham or make up disguised funding.

City have evidence that is not based on probability and this may have happened.

No matter what way you slice it up. The whole case is a joke. Believing the league have somehow put together a cogent argument based on emails received from city and the hack is no more plausible than the cpc paid ethiad via equity.

Marvin is rabbiting on abit about ethiad and the HC. At least he is staying optimistic and not falling into believing that city have done something illegal instead of a work around like everyone else is not helpful.

Not every positive piece of information has to be taken apart to show city in a negative way.

Regardless, getting bogged down again on the leagues ever changing rules, the legitimacy of CAS and the made up sham opinion only screams one thing to me…a relentless organised attack.

I can find no fault in how city circumvented the rules. Mancini was paid big deal. This shit happen daily. Tapping up, agent deals, selling parts of the club to oneself. It’s all dirty.

Anyway, trying to say city did this or did that based on a trap set up and guarded by the cartel is not seeing the bigger picture but following the narrative that has been set.

City is ultimately an outsider in a world of joiners that thrived. We don’t belong in that group. Don’t worry about it.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top