PL charge City for alleged breaches of financial rules

I'm sort of fascinated as to what happens if the league maintains it's stance, the club are criminally investigated and find nothing, and an American court finds in Etihad's favour, and we are audited again and pass. There's a real mess of internationally competing claims there?
That's the killer question right there, & the nightmare scenario lying in wait for the Premier League.

If City are found to have committed no criminal acts & are cleared, the spotlight then falls squarely on the PL, & the trumped up breaches of their private members club rules & whether FFP, PSR, ATP & SCR are fit for purpose.

We just have to keep our nerve & remain patient whilst the process plays itself out.
 
We did escape serious punishment I have never said otherwise indeed prior to any charges I was stating quite clearly we would and should be charged. There’s absolutely no doubt that our owners and their legal representatives came out ahead.

I don’t think I have ever said that City are guilty. If you can find any of my posts that say otherwise save when I thought you had an issue defending the Mancini case then I will apologise accordingly.
Good luck to anyone willing to reread all the shit he's wrote
 
Wonder if this does mean the full in-redacted report will be released this week then as Samuels indicated
If as a PL club director I was being asked to put my financial cock on the block I would want to see the full unredacted report and have my own legal team scrutinise its findings.
 
2 very interesting paragraphs from that article:

'The proposal does not speculate about the possible sums involved. It is understood that both Etihad, valued at about £4bn, and Etisalat are waiting for the league to publish the full judgment — which insiders suggest may have been delayed because of the lack of legal protection afforded to the directors — before deciding on their next steps.

Technically, a “third party” is not limited to the UK courts, however. Such action could be taken in other territories, including the United States. A third party such as a club sponsor is not a signatory to the Premier League’s rulebook, and therefore not bound by its private arbitration process. An American lawsuit, for instance, would involve additional costs, with both sides required to pay its own legal fees regardless of the outcome. Corporate defamation claims in the US have been known to run into the billions.
The Premier League has declined to comment.'



A lot more to play out in this.

Smartmatic currently has an active $2.7bn defamation open against Fox and dominion voting settled for $800m against Fox on a $1.6bn claim. Both against the rigged 2020 election claims.

For context the former amount is all 20 PL clubs potentially giving us 1.5 years of domestic TV rights. Absolutely none of them can afford that according to the latest regulator report.

As for the former paragraph quited, delaying an outcome because the directors don't have protection doesn't scream watertight does it?
Where was this published mate?
 
From the article:

Technically, a “third party” is not limited to the UK courts, however. Such action could be taken in other territories, including the United States. A third party such as a club sponsor is not a signatory to the Premier League’s rulebook, and therefore not bound by its private arbitration process. An American lawsuit, for instance, would involve additional costs, with both sides required to pay its own legal fees regardless of the outcome. Corporate defamation claims in the US have been known to run into the billions.

:)
Holy fuck we are going for their throats.
 
I posted the following football governance solution a few weeks ago, in an attempt to prepare the narrative for what should come next after FFP, PSR, ATP & SCR.

It's part of a three pronged attack where we defend ourselves against the PL's breaches, tear apart FFP, PSR, ATP & SCR as not being fit for purpose, but crucially we offer a fairer, more workable solution that doesn't stifle responsible owner investment, but still protects clubs from reckless owners.

Responsible Owner Investment Model​

As with any other UK industry, an owner should be allowed to invest how they see fit to grow their business, with a few very important caveats to protect clubs from reckless overspending.

Club A has an annual turnover of £100m. SCR rules state a club can only invest 85% of their football-related revenue on net player sales, on player wages, head coach wages, agent fees, & transfer amortisation etc.

My proposal would mean that any squad investment over that 85% figure needs to be met personally by the club owner. In respect to those specific player transfers above that 85% limit, all associated fees must be paid in full prior to final Premier League ratification.

Liabilities arising from this additional investment eg: gross wages, potential bonuses etc, must be deposited into a Premier League controlled escrow account, to cover the contractual liabilities throughout the contract duration.

For example, Club A buys a player outside of their 85% SCR allowance for £10m on a 4 year contract, with an annual base salary of £1m plus £500k per season in potential bonuses.

Club A's owner must pay for that player's £10m transfer in full from his personal funds, & deposit a further £6m in his club's escrow account to cover the salary liabilities over the length of the 4 year contract. Any interest accumulated from this escrow account is then used to fund grassroots football.

If Club A's owner goes bust or walks away, Club A owe nothing for the £10m player, & the player's salary liability is covered by the £6m in Club A's escrow account. Any bonuses not met by the player, are returned to the club on expiry of the 4 year contract, or on a contract extension, whereby ongoing liabilities will revert to Club A's 85% SCR allowance.

Club A Debt​

A good debt-to-income (DTI) ratio for Club A is 36% or lower, meaning that less than 36% of their gross (pre-tax) income goes toward paying their annual debt obligations.

Club A will have a healthy balance of debt & income. Lenders will view Club A favorably & see plenty of room for savings or new loans. Any debt above this must be levied solely against the owner in a personal capacity, further protecting Club A from financial irresponsibility.

In Conclusion ​

To the lurking opposition fans & uncertain City fans, once this process is over, I highly doubt English (and by extension) European football will ever be the same.

Something has to change, so instead of picking the bones out of auditing minutae, I'd like to hear (especially from opposition fans) what your thoughts are on FFP, PSR, ATP & SCR?

Are you for or against these rules in their previous & current guises? Why? And what would you want to see in place instead (if anything), & again, why?
Another simpler solution is to just ban American owners!
 
It’s impossible to say at this stage how any club, other than City and the “red cartel” will vote imo.

Correct because we don’t know what the cartel clubs are telling those other clubs they’ll be giving them personal incentives new rules they’ll bring in anything to persuade them! Remember them getting fucking Reading to abstain so ffp got voted in! These cartel yank owned clubs are utter cunts! They play dirty I’d say as far as paying pinto to hack our club!
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top